Dinner with Mom

The next day, I woke up to see Riley’s pretty eyes staring at me as her head bobbed up and down on my cock. I groaned in amazement at how I’d gotten so lucky to have a big sis like her. I put my hand on the back of her head and she moaned around my cock. She must have been sucking me off for a while because I was already nearly bursting with cum.

With a loud moan, I shot my seed down my sister’s throat. My phone buzzed.

“Hi, Cole! I’m starting getting ready now!” Emily’s text read. I glanced at the time and realized abruptly it was very late. I glanced up at Riley.

“Why is it already 2:00?” I asked her.

“You were tired after your, ahem, rendezvous with April Torres.” Riley grinned at me. The memory flashed into my head, of April’s gorgeous Latina tits bouncing as she rode me fiercely, head thrown back in lust.

“Damn, that was awesome.” I nodded. Riley, wearing a plain cotton bra and panties which was unusual for her, cuddled against my chest. I wrapped my arms around her.

———

Three hours later, I walked into the restaurant, my hand in Emily’s, and Riley walking beside us. I saw Mom in a gorgeous, tight dress, and she smiled when she saw me, but when she saw Emily, her face dropped in horror.

“What?” Emily asked self-consciously.

“Mom, this is Emily, my girlfriend.” I said, shooting an intense look at her.

“Cole, honey, you might want to sit down.” Mom said worriedly. Frowning, I did, and Emily sat on my left.

“Emily, I presume you don’t know your birth father.” Mom said. Emily’s mouth hung open.

“How the hell do you know that?” she blinked.

“I have a question. Are you in the older two or the younger two?” Mom asked Emily.

“Younger. I’m the youngest.” Emily blinked. Mom let out a deep breath of relief.

“What was that about?” I demanded.

“You never told me her last name was Willis. Your father’s first wife was named Katy Willis.” Mom told me.

“How many wives has he had?” Riley asked curiously.

“I’m his fourth. Katy, Natalie, Ruby, and me.” Mom blinked.

“Wow. I only knew about Natalie.” I said.

“That’s because he kept the other two more secretive, as he had kids with them. He had two kids with Katy, and one with Ruby, I think.” Mom said sadly.

“Hold on, so my mother was once married to Cole’s dad?” Emily asked, looking a little green.

“Yes. If you were one of your two older sisters, you’d be Cole’s half-sister.” Mom said. Emily shot me a panicked look, just as Hannah walked up, smiling nervously. She’d been late, and Riley and I exchanged worried looks.

“Hi, Mrs. Campbell. I’m, um, I’m Hannah Willis. I’m the future mother of your son’s baby.” Hannah smiled politely. Emily looked at me with immense horror on her face, and I summed up that Hannah was one of the elder two Willis sisters, making her my half-sister.” Hannah blushed while speaking to Mom.

“Hannah... are you part of the younger two or the older two Willis sisters?” Mom asked Hannah.

“Huh? I’m second oldest, why is that important?” Hannah frowned. Mom gave me a look of **** horror. I stood up and wrapped an arm around Hannah.

“We, uh, we should talk.” I said.

———

“You’re my brother?” Hannah asked, stunned. We were outside of the restaurant on a bench, and her hands were in mine.

“Yep.” I said.

“Hold on, does that mean Emily is, too?!?” Hannah gasped.

“No. No, only the older two Willis sisters are my dad’s. You and your older sister. Your younger two sisters have a different dad.” I said. Hannah threw her arms around me tightly.

“I’ve always wanted a brother.” she whispered.

“Even a brother who knocked you up?” I whispered back. Her eyes met mine, and she stroked my cheek.

“Yes.” she said, and then she was kissing me heatedly. I kissed her back, and I held my older half-sister in my arms, her baby bump against my own stomach.

After our kiss, we walked back in, and Mom looked at our joined hands with some nausea.

“Are you guys OK?” Emily asked. Hannah kissed me lightly on the lips, and Mom rushed off suddenly. Hannah gave me a sad look as we sat at the table.

“I’m glad you guys are OK.” Emily said, taking each of our hands. Riley placed her hand on my shoulder, her eyes asking a question. I nodded.

“Well, I guess this is the time to tell you that Cole and I are sleeping together.” Riley blurted.

“Well, I know that. There’s only two rooms.” Emily rolled her eyes. But Hannah looked shocked.

“No, we’re like... sleeping together.” I said. Emily’s eyes widened.

“For how long?” Emily whispered.

“We just had sex the first time when I got back to the apartments. First time I came was just kissing and groping.” Riley explained. Emily squeezed my hand.

“It’s my fault, isn’t it? I was a terrible girlfriend first time around.” Emily said miserably.

“What? No!” I protested.

“Really? Because I feel like you slept with half the Glade during our relationship!” Emily reminded me, not angrily, though.

“That has nothing to do with you or your skills as a girlfriend.” I said seriously. I pulled Emily close and we kissed. She gasped her surprise but kissed me back.

“Cole... Hannah... we need to talk.” Mom said, having returned still looking ill. Hannah and I exchanged glances but we followed her out to her car. Hannah leaned against me as we stood facing Mom.

“You two seem to be very close... despite Cole dating Emily.” Mom challenged.

“Well...” I said, but Hannah placed a hand on our unborn child.

“Having a baby draws us together. I broke things off with my husband because I love Cole.” Hannah said. Mom’s eyes widened at that revelation, but she only said

“And being siblings doesn’t change that for you two?”

“Not even a little bit.” I affirmed. Hannah smiled brilliantly at me, and we kissed. Mom walked forwards and threw her arms around the two of us.

“I’m so happy to be a grandmother, and I want you two to know, I wholly support your relationship. It’s not your fault.” Mom whispered as she cradled me and Hannah. I wrapped an arm tightly around her, and found two amazing pairs of tits squashing against me.