Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 24 by Onlysorta Onlysorta

Who cums first? You, or is Zoe REALLY getting off right now?

Zoe orgasms, you… don’t?

It's an incredible new sensation when you fulfill Zoe’s request of a good, hard dicking, but it’s not quite how you imagined an all-out, intense fuckfest to feel. Pounding away at the chubby hottie's pussy, you can tell from her moans that Zoe is having the time of her 19- year-long life. Don't get this wrong, the sex feels GREAT, its just... nevermind that, you're grabbing another fistful of her beauteous ass just to pull the cute girl closer. You feel her clit bump into your pelvis over and over again, and her quiet whimpers with each thrust is kind of a turn-on.

While your grunts evolve into quiet moans as her vulva lips tickle your cock, her eyes go crossed, and her body quakes. Zoe holds your chest close as an orgasm wracks her voluptuous frame, whimpering like a bunny rabbit in your arms. You feel her pussy convulse and enwetten your penis as she rides out the fireworks of climax, and don't stop thrusting even while the busty brunette clutches at your shoulders. It takes her a while to come down from it, but eventually Zoe's only reaction is her DDD-cup breasts heaving atop her chest as she huffs in tongue lolling joy.

"Heh, looks like somebody had a good time~"

Even with its teensy size, your dick makes a soft sound when you pull out of your... girlfriend? It's probably too soon to call Zoe your girlfriend, despite how much you love the weirdo right now; she's just so sexy, cute, positive, affectionate and all those other things that make you feel all warm and fuzzy inside. You regard her moaning in her post-orgasmic bliss, and think that the only thing that's marring your first sexual encounter is that, well, umm... your ‘little soldier’ is still standing at attention. You actually flush when you realize it's because you didn't cum.

When Zoe sits up, sand completely coating her big, bubbly backside, she joins you in noticing your tiny cock's stiffness; immediately realizing you didn’t cum. She examines your baby carrot with huge eyes, and starts blushing. "W-wait, you're still hard!? Ohmigosh, Sam I'm so sorry, did I do something wrong? Was it like, not good?"

“No, It was fun! I just… I guess, I uh, wanted to take things slower?” You say, feeling very embarrassed for yourself despite knowing that this was better than being premature. “Plus, it's definitely better if I don't y-y-y'know... finish inside you.”

But your little chubby-bunny wasn't satisfied with your answer, grabbing your body closer to her huge, bare breasts as she says, "You fucking me like crazy was my favoritest wet dream, that's why I couldn't last. Can't you tell me your wet dream? I wanna fulfill it!"

"If you want to get Sam off, just suck his dick. That's every guy's fantasy— especially the hot ones." Rebecca explains all matter-of-factly over Zoe's shoulder, her bikini bottoms still laying in the sand a few feet away. A wicked smile overtakes the cheerleader's snooty features when a new thought hits her horny mind, visible as her bare pussy drips onto the ground. "Unless Zoe, you'd prefer if I made him cum again. It wasn't hard for me earlier~"

“What!? No! I can do this!” The brunette squeaks, her cheeks lighting up a bright, neon pink in embarrassment. “C’mon Sam, just tell me what you think about when you touch yourself! Give me your naughtiest fantasy, right now!”

Will you tell Zoe your #1 sexual fantasy? Even with Rebecca right there?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)