Kaitlyn Gathering Information (Edging )

"Well, I suppose I'll go next now that we heard that humiliating confession," responded Kaitlyn taking the spot in front of John where Paige just was.

"Kaitlyn, please just keep going until I cum," John pleaded. "Please, it's really annoying when I don't get to shoot."

"But everyone else hasn't had their fun yet," said Kaitlyn. "I can't do that if you already creamed all over now can I?"

"Kaitlyn please, I'm begging you" said John. "I really really want to cum."

"Well, unfortunately that's not my problem John," said Kaitlyn as she wrapped her hand around his dick and started to slowly jerk him off.

"I'm not joking Kaitlyn, it feels rather irritating to just have your sensitive areas stimulated so much and still be denied that final push," said John.

"Yeah, yeah, yeah, whatever you say," said Kaitlyn dismissively. "You should feel glad to be having so many beautiful girls willing to jerk you off."

"I am but I still need to actually cum at some point otherwise it's just ****," John responded.

Kaitlyn continued stroking John's dick until it stood at attention pointing straight at the ceiling. She wasn't as good at giving handjobs as Michelle or Paige were, but it still felt incredible to him.

"Now John, my question for you would be what exactly did you do with all the underwear you stole from Megan?" asked Kaitlyn.

"Oh my god!" John "Just use your imagination I don't want to go in depth on that."

"Well we have to know all the juicy details don't we?" said Kaitlyn as she continued stroking John's dick.

"I don't want to tell you though, it's too embarrassing," said John. "It's bad enough I hurt her, she doesn't need more specifics."

I heard he'd wait for Megan to get all wet down there, then steal the dirty things after she had put them in her hamper," said Sara.

John's face immediately went beet red after hearing her speak. "How does she know that? Could she have seen me? Who else knows about it? How many people know?" thought John a little panicked. "This is bad, this can't get back to Megan or I'm dead. As far as she's concerned I just either masturbated or humped my matress thinking about having sex with her, she doesn't need to know more than that."

"Damn! Really?! He really is a huge perv isn't he?!" Kaitlyn responded to Sara, still jerking John off. He was lost in thought, but Kaitlyn's voice snapped him back to reality.

"So, our hugely perverted panty thief," Kaitlyn addressed John. "If you would be kind enough to share what you did with Megan's panties, you just might be able to cum."

"I still have some dignity left you know," said John. "I might be naked, tied to a chair, and at your mercy, but I don't need to cum so badly that I'll humiliate myself that much by revealing that information." Kaitlyn giggled at the statement. The idea that John still had any dignity left after being ousted as a pervert to his crush and her entire social circle, having his naked body tied to a chair and recorded for all to see, and being informed he'd be doing everything naked until his crush and his mother think he's ready to wear clothes again was absurd to Kaitlyn. Judging by the smirks and giggles coming from the other girls in the room she clearly wasn't the only one who found the absurd statement amusing.

Kaitlyn gave John a sexy smile, and as she continued stroking his dick, she said in a very sexy teasing voice "Oh John, please tell me what you did with the panties, I just gotta know, you just have my girlhood trembling just thinking about the kinds of things you did and the fantasies that went through your head." John looked at Kaitlyn with a stunned expression on his face. He wasn't expecting her to say that.

"Oh my god, could she... actually... like me?" thought John as the girl jerked him off. One look at the shocked expression on his face told Kaitlyn she needed to keep this act going. "The very thought of you secretly being there when I change out of these wet panties just to take them as a trophy when I'm not looking has me so wet John," teased Kaitlyn. John was getting very turned on by her words, and was losing himself in a fantasy as she jerked him off. "Oh John please you just have to tell me, I just need to know what such a handsome young man would do with such a private possession, it just turns me on so much thinking about it," Kaitlyn continued as she began to pump John's dick faster and faster. "You can trust me, in fact if you tell me I'll even strip completely naked right here, and play with myself thinking of nothing but you," she continued lying through her teeth. "To think after all the times I masturbated thinking about you John, you'll finally be able to watch me, it's such a turn on."

John moaned with pleasure and his breathing started getting heavier as he was lost in a fantasy of seeing Kaitlyn masturbate butt naked. "Just imagine it John, all you have to do to see my large naked breasts, all you have to do to see me completely naked, and all you have to do to see me masturbate is just tell me what you did with Megan's panties after you stole them," Kaitlyn continued teasing. "Come on John, don't you want to see me naked, don't you think I'm beautiful? Come on, I want you to touch my intimate girl parts, just lost in a fantasy of what you'd do with my stolen panties If you're a good boy and tell me I'll even let you cum all over my bare-naked-tits."

The more Kaitlyn spoke, the more it drove John to the edge. The fact that his cock was being jerked off by her was only bring him there quicker. John wasn't thinking rationally anymore, he was no longer thinking with his brain and was now instead thinking with his dick. He actually believed that Kaitlyn wanted him that badly, he wasn't going to pass up a chance to see her naked. As he was brought closer and closer to the edge he confessed every last detail related to what he'd do with the underwear he stole. He confessed how he'd store them in air tight bags to keep them fresh. He confessed how he'd jerk off while smelling some. He confessed how he'd rub his dick on some of them and then cum on them. He even confessed to how he'd occasionally wear a pair to feel closer to Megan when they'd hang out sometimes. He confessed to absolutely every last humiliating morally corrupt dirty perverted thing he did with them. Then right as he was about to be jerked off to the edge, right before he was guaranteed to cum, Kaitlyn took her hand off his dick, denying him yet another chance to cum. "Boys are so gullible when they're horny, you couldn't even tell I was lying through my teeth," she said. "As if I, or any girl for that matter, would be interested in you after finding out what a dirty pervert you are." Then she stood up, turned to the rest of the girls, and said "time for the next turn, who's going next?'