Yes, But Not How She Wants

"You're right. I want you." You moan, "I've been fantasizing about bending you over the counter since you came home."

"Oh yeah?" She giggles pulling away from you, having pulled your cock out of your pants. "Then bend me over big boy." She taunts.

Without hesitation you grab her by the back of the neck and slam her down on the breakfast nook.

"So rough." Your sister purrs, wiggling her juicy ass. She looks back at you with a sly grin and says, "You're not going to be that rough when you're fucking me are you?"

"Tease." You hiss yanking her yoga pants down to reveal a pale, bare, ass and a wet pink slit. "How is a little slut like you still a virgin?"

Her body grows tense as you rub your cockhead against her slit. "Virginity's a commodity." She moans. "I was saving it for someone important."

"A commodity huh?" You grin wickedly, grabbing a wrist in one hand using the other to press her face against the marble. "I never thought of it like that." You line your cock up with puckered pink asshole and press against your sister's back door.

"What are you doing?" She says, a panicked tone to her voice now. "Wrong hole!"

As you slowly work your tip into her anus you groan in pleasure. "Feels right to me."

"No! Please. This hurts." She cries, struggling futally. She's in much better shape than you and almost certainly stronger, but you have so much leverage it doesn't matter. You lean forward, pressing her face down hard.

"Sorry, Caitlin." You groan as your full tip enters her rear. "But your cunt is a commodity. I'm saving it." You thrust into the painfully tight hole and feel some of the fight go out of her body.

"I hate you." She cries.

Ignoring her you pull most of your cock out then thrust into her hard. She cries out in pain which just motivates you to thrust even harder on your next go. By the time your fully lodged in her ass she's gone limp. Taking advantage of that you reposition your hands, placing one on her hip, using the other grab a handful of blond hair, giving it a good yank. You start fucking her, gradually building up speed. It only takes few minutes before you're at your limit. "Take it slut!" You taunt as you approach orgasm, panting heavily. Your sister's only reply is cry of pain as you roughly pull her hair, forcing her to hold herself up on the counter. Leaning forward you bite her shoulder as you cum inside of her.

Panting you shove her back down onto the counter before pulling out, enjoying the sight of her gaping asshole leaking your sticky cum. You take a seat and chuckle. "I'm glad you put on that little seduction act. I never would have done something like that if you hadn't."

Caitlin wipes the tears from her eyes and pulls her pants up, shooting you a glare. The side of her face you shoved down on the countertop is still red and her light makeup is ruined. "You better give me rights back after that, asshole." She growls.

You shake your head. "You said it yourself, your virginity is a commodity. So what are you going to give me for that commodity?"