Melissa resolves the situation

"No wonder Melissa was not at her apartment even though she does not have any training classes this afternoon. Did you two go on a date?" Judy asks, placing her hands at her hips.

"I met John when I went out for a short stroll. He just invited me for lunch and we ended up going to do some shopping." Melissa hurriedly intervenes.

You feel an invisible tension in the air. You are not clueless and know that Judy is not happy. "Is she jealous of Melissa for going out with me?" You ask yourself.

"It was not a date. I got promoted and went to treat myself. Since I met Melissa, I just invited her to join in." You explain but it does not help in appeasing Judy.

The beautiful blonde pouts unhappily. "Hmmp. How is that any different? You know where I work, you could have stopped by. These last few days, you have been spending a lot more time with Melissa."

"Have I?" You mutter out. Thinking about it for a little bit, you indeed realise that it is the case. The two girls have different personalities. While Judy acts strong and often teases you, Melissa is milder and more approachable. Furthermore, compared to Judy who only performs vanilla sex and blowjobs at best with you, Melissa is open to trying kinky plays.

But the real reason behind the dynamics between you three is simply the girls' other relationships. Judy remains cold sometimes and still chats with her boyfriend, Ryan occasionally. On the other hand, Melissa has just experienced a breakup and wholeheartedly enjoys her time with you. You are slowly replacing the person that occupied her heart but Judy's heart still remains closed to you. You just naturally went with the flow and it ended up in this situation.

"Sorry. I did not think it was such a big deal... I thought you were alright with it since the conditions of us becoming friends with benefits also mention that you would support me in getting other women."

"Yes, I support you in spending time with Melissa but that does not mean you can forget about me. I am your first friend with benefits, I should have been the first one on your mind! Don't even think about getting other women, just Melissa is enough or else, you will completely forget about us." Judy snorts in annoyance.

You scratch your head awkwardly, not knowing how to defend yourself. That beautiful neighbour of yours is unexpectedly so jealous.

Fortunately, Melissa comes to your rescue. "John, go to my apartment to drop off what we bought. I will speak with Judy and clear off the misunderstanding."

"Eh?" You look at Judy but she crosses her arms and refuses to look at you.

You can only bitterly lower your head and leave the apartment, leaving Melissa to deal with the furious Judy.

When you come back a few minutes later, the raging storm seems to have passed. Judy and Melissa are sitting in the living room quietly, watching the tv. You cannot believe that Melissa really succeeded. You join the girls and although the situation is a bit awkward, Judy does not push you away. She seems to be lost in thoughts.

For dinner, you order some takeaways online and you are lucky enough to have it delivered by a woman. You eat with the two women then go to shower. At some point, Judy disappears in your bedroom, leaving only you and Melissa in the living room.

"What did you say to her?" You ask.

"It is our secret." She winks playfully. "I hope you are completely recharged down there, because tonight is going to really test your limit."

"What do you mean?" You have a bad feeling about this.

"I think Judy is going to prove that she likes you as much as I do tonight. She is probably waiting for you in the bedroom. How about you go and have a look?"

You hesitate for a moment but eventually agrees. It is pointless to delay the inevitable.

You enter the bedroom, and find Judy wearing the same lingerie. She seems to be waiting for you and as soon as you enter, she walks toward you without a word.