Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17

What's Next?

The dawn of a new morning

It was late when George finally got around to sending his sister the picture of her cum-covered face. Had he not been fully spent, having orgasmed a total of three times this one day, he’d have rubbed another one out at the photo. Instead, he told her to enjoy herself and smiled when she enthusiastically replied that she planned on doing exactly that.

However, sending the picture reminded him of his other test -- the one with Sabina -- and the growing anxiety he felt at the fact that she hadn’t replied to his crotch shot. It was a stark contrast to how the rest of his day had gone.

Beginning with spying on his sister, he’d gone from renown pervert to your average student. He’d shared a washroom with Sabina, watched porn with Mrs. Lopez, corrupted modern dating, and came on his sister’s face. Following what was an absolute riot of a day, it crushed him that the reason why he’d initial ventured down this path hadn’t bared fruit.

By the time he decided to call it a night, the verdict was clear: Sabina did not return his affection.

Rejection was new to George. As a former social outcast, he was used to being shunned, but this was different. Asking someone out meant opening one’s self to vulnerability. While he’d gotten marvelous success with Alice, the fact that Sabina had read his message but chosen not to acknowledge it was a blow to his ego. One he hadn’t felt in a long time.

Despite the roundabout way he’s gone about to doing it, that had been the first time George had legitimately attempted to ask someone out; his date with Alice being more accidental than intentional. He recalled the bravado he’d felt when bragging to his friend and didn’t know how he’d face them come the morning.

It hurt more now that he was aware of his powers. When he sent her that dick pic, he felt like he could do anything and get away with it. And while that was still partially the case, it seems he couldn’t just expect results because he’d made it so.

Try as he might, George was unable to find solace that night. In his dreams, he re-experienced the shunning his peers had given him that afternoon, the chaotic nature of his subconscious mind amplifying the image to where it was magnitudes worse than what had actually transpired. And yet, he couldn’t do anything to stop them. More than once he woke up during the night, frantically checking his phone for any sign that he was being overly anxious for nothing, but the result never changed.

It was in the wee hours of the early morning that George finally understood the extent of what he’d put his sister through.

When he finally gave up and crawled out of bed, the sun still had only just begun cresting over the horizon. He checked his phone one final time and sighed deeply when the only message he saw was from Dave. The fact that his friend had managed to succeed where George had failed left a sour taste in his mouth. He knew he should be happy for his friend but George couldn’t muster the energy to do so. It wasn’t a promising start to the day.

Not knowing what to do, George decided to visit his sister, leaving the confines of his room and walking through their silent home. He didn’t know if his parents had returned and frankly he didn’t care; figuring out how his changesl had affected them was the last thing on his mind. He just wanted someone to talk too.

The sight of his sister’s discarded batman panties outside her room **** a chuckle out of him. He took a quick moment to inspect them and felt proud of the fact that they were crusted with dried cum - his. No doubt Alice had used them to wipe her face after their date, choosing to leave them soiled as evidence of their time together.

He wondered if she meant them to be his to masturabte with, George ultimately opting to ignore the dirty underwear in favor of entering his sister’s bedroom. There, he found her fast asleep, Alice’s shallow breathing the only thing breaking the morning’s perpetual silence.

Walking up to her bed as quietly as he could, George took a moment to admire his sister. She’d obviously tossed in her sleep, her pink sheets a disheveled mess that betrayed the fact that she wasn’t wearing anything below her waist. Her legs sprawled and wide open, he had an unobstructed view of her perfectly shaven mound, devoid of all hair, and her glistening sex.

And yet, even the way Alice was casually exposing herself wasn’t enough to cheer him up. This wasn’t the pussy he ultimately longed to see.

Standing next to his sleeping sister, George pondered his options. He knew he needed to act soon or else what he was doing would be normalized and the last thing he wanted was to encourage brothers everywhere to sneak into their sister’s rooms in order to watch them sleep. Admiring his sister’s delicate features, he couldn’t shake the image of her cum-covered face from his mind and despite himself felt a rush of pride as he recalled the mess he’d made.

Suddenly remembering a change he’d tried to instill, the only noise he made was the soft shuffling of his boxers as he fished out his dick. He wasn’t hard, but he didn’t need to be. Without any warning, he gripped it from its base and brought his shaft down on Alice’s face, slapping her with his cock.

“What the-” she called out, jerking awake just as his dick came down a second time. Unlike the previous night though, Alice didn’t immediately shift out of his way, his cock connecting with her face a third time as her eyes slowly opened and adjusted to the dim morning light.

“Oh, it’s just you. Morning George!” she said, recognizing him. She braced herself as his dick hit her a fourth time, Alice doing nothing to stop him from slapping her face with his cock. She even gave him a small smile as it connected. “Did you wake up bright and early in order to enjoy your new privilege?”

“Actually, I didn’t sleep well last night,” he admitted as he gave her one final smack, this time opting to keep his limp dick on her face. He didn’t even try to hide the tiredness from his voice. “I was hoping this would cheer me up.”

From his tone, she knew something was up. Instead of chiding him, she allowed him to have his way with her, George resting his crotch on her as she took a couple seconds to fully wake up. She rubbed her eyes with one hand, blinking them rapidly to get rid of her remaining drowsiness. “Everything alright?” she soon asked, fearing the worst.

“Sabina never replied to my crotch shot.”

“Oh.”

The siblings fell into a soft silence, neither choosing to speak before the other.

“Want to talk about it?” she prompted, quickly realizing that her brother wasn’t about to immediately provide additional information.

“Yeah,” he said, nodding once. “Yeah, I’d like that.”

Without saying another word, Alice shifted and made room on the bed, giving her brother the space he needed to sit down next to her. He took it without another word, struggling to figure out how to start. Having an honest discussion with someone regarding his feelings wasn’t something he was accustomed too.

“I asked Sabina out yesterday,” he began, choosing to jump right into the root of the matter. “I did it after I asked you but before you replied, so I didn’t do it because I was choosing her over you. It was more to prove a point to my friends than anything.” He paused, realizing he was rambling and avoiding the issue. “Anyway, I went to bed anxious because she hadn’t responded and had a hard time sleeping.”

“And I take it you hadn’t received anything when you woke up?” she finished, understanding the situation.

“Yeah…”

Alice let out a deep sigh, closing her eyes in thought. “Reminds me of yesterday” she admitted, looking down. George silently nodded, not knowing what to say. Her words stung, but he knew Alice wasn’t being malicious. If anything, her words were empathetic and understanding.

“What made you think she was into you?” she asked, looking back at him.

George blinked, trying his best to remember the events of the previous day. “Well, I ran into her in the men’s room and we chatted while she masturbated and she seemed friendlier to me than usual. She kept saying how she was into some streamer’s hands. She even sat close to the guys and I instead of her usual spot near the jocks! I dunno, it seemed like I had a shot.”

Alice snorted at his reasoning. “You asked her out because she’s turned on by a strong set of gaming hands? Most girls are turned on by that George, it’s a pretty normal thing to be into.”

His sister had a point. As George listed out his reasoning for texting Sabina, even he’d grown less convinced. “Still, she could’ve at least sent something! I at least came to talk to you after I got your message.”

“Yeah, after half a day!” Her point quieted him. “Who knows, maybe she was going to come talk to you during school today.” To that, he had nothing to say. “Or maybe she just isn’t interested. It’s like matching with someone on Tinder that you’re not really into. You don’t have to acknowledge the message. Hell, this way you can save face. You know how nasty rumors can be in highschool”

George knew his sister had a point, but her explanation wasn’t really making him feel any better. Not knowing what else to really say, he remained quiet. Despite what she was saying, the rejection still stung.

“Isn’t this a good thing though?” she eventually asked, her voice low and quiet.

Turning to look at her, George gave her a broken look. “What do you mean?”

At the question, she blushed, glancing away. “It’s just… we just started dating, right? I was sort of hoping things were becoming exclusive.”

“Exclusive?” he repeated, not having given the idea much consideration. “I thought you just wanted to keep it a secret?”

“I do!” she admitted, “Although considering it’s normal for siblings to experiment, I’m sure some people will suspect something anyway. But, my friends and I never talk about our sexuality to begin with, so it’s not like I’ll ever have to confirm or deny any accusations. Even so, now that you and I are starting to hook up, I’m not too keen that you’re trying to do the same with someone else.”

“Ahh…” It was amazing to George how a concept like monogamy was able to persist after corrupting the world to the extent he already had. People were masturbating with one another in washrooms and supply closets, but Alice wanted their sex lives to be an exclusive thing?

Granted, he’d never made any direct attempts to subvert monogamy since his date with Alice. For that, he’d have to go on an entirely separate date with someone else - something he was planning on doing after changing Sabina a little more. As such, it pained him to experience a bit of backlash to the idea from his sister, especially after they’d grown close.

Silence fell between the siblings once more, George unable to meet his sister’s gaze as he struggled to maintain his mask before her. He felt a little guilty knowing he was betraying the care and trust she was giving him but he knew that when it came down to it, he wouldn’t be able to prevent himself from manipulating things to get with Sabina. It was hard to be fully ashamed when he knew that whatever change he brought would be normalized in Alice’s eyes.

“George?”

The question shook him from his thoughts, and he did his best to be as sincere as he could while answering. “Yeah, I understand. Okay, I promise I’ll drop things with Sabina.”

Alice gave him a long stare, long enough for George to understand she was deciding whether she believed him. She then nodded once, making her decision.

“Okay” she eventually said, “If you’re telling me you’re going to move on from it, than that’s all I needed to hear. Relationships are built on trust and… I trust you. I think there’s potential for us to get a good thing going.” She admitted that last bit with a blush, finally breaking away from his gaze as she spoke her mind.

“Why do you say that?” he asked, legitimately curious.

“After yesterday, I’m pretty certain you’re as much of a pervert as I am.”

Her honestly surprised him, the extent of his normalizations always catching him off guard. Despite everything, she truly believed it was normal for siblings to experiment with each other and was fully ready to commit to it.

“You know what you make me feel better?” he asked, hoping to change the topic of conversation topic and lean into this discovery. Alice didn’t answer, but the grin she tried to hide betrayed the fact that she likely knew exactly where he was going.

He pretended not to notice anyway, perfectly happy to act coy and play along. “If I could slap your face with my dick.”

She bit her lip as she nodded, her eyes sparkling with a desire he wasn’t used to seeing. He wondered if Alice was remembering the photo they’d taken together during their date yesterday. With his dick coming so close to her face, he figured it would be hard not too.

Giving him what was now his exclusive right, Alice rolled onto her back, shifting in order to allow George the room he needed to straddle her. He placed his knees on either side of her chest, standing up until he loomed far above her, his dick hanging freely inches above her face.

George took a deep breath, trying to calm his racing nerves. He still felt a huge rush whenever he watched his powers at hand. It likely felt similar to whatever Alice was currently experiencing, giving the way she was staring up at him.

Her eyes had immediately locked onto his cock, his sister mesmerized by the appendage. “I still can’t believe I’m really this close to your dick,” she stated, her hands moving up to grasp it.

He waved her aside, instead gripping his shaft with a hand of his own. He waved it in front of her, enjoying the way her gaze moved in tandem each time it swung. “Yeah?” he redundantly asked, feeling the initial waves of arousal begin to course through him. “How long have you wanted this?”

“Since I first started spying on you while you showered,” she admitted, a deep blush coloring her cheeks. “I know it’s normal for siblings to explore their sexuality together but even with mom and dad encouraging us, you never seemed interested and I didn’t have the courage to send you a picture of my dickhole. That’s why I was nervous when you sent me a crotch shot yesterday.”

Hearing Alice casually use the term ‘dickhole’ made him throb, his cock immediately hardening as his arousal spiked. Alice let out a silent gasp as she watched it grow, the girl fascinated by the display before her.

“Did you touch your dickhole while looking at the mess I made of your face last night?” he asked, slowing jacking his dick.

“I couldn’t stop!” she gasped, her heavy breathing evidence of how excited she was getting. “I was so nervous at first, when you said you wanted to cum on my face. I didn’t know if I was ready to give you the right to slap my face whenever you want too so early in our relationship. ...but I’m glad I did.”

Taking her words to heart, George brought his dick down on her face, the sound of skin hitting skin echoing throughout her small bedroom. Unlike the previous night, Alice smiled as she leaned into the hit instead of attempting to avoid it, the girl obviously enjoying the power she’d given her brother over her.

He slapped her a couple more times, Alice angling her head so that he could hit different parts of her face. Cheeks, lips, nose, forehead - nothing was safe from his onslaught. Soon, George was giggling at the absurdity of the situation, relishing the fact that he’d corrupted reality to such a degree.

“Thank you for this,” he said between hits, “Already, I’m starting to feel a little better.”

That send Alice into a fit of giggles of her own, the girl happily taking another blow to the face as George refused to stop. “I’m glad!” she sighed with a smile, thrilled to see her brother’s mood improve.

“Stick your tongue out!”

She complied without any hesitation, putting her tongue in his dick’s path. The result produced a loud wet slap, distinctively different from the dry ones that preceded it. He laughed at the noise and Alice let out a muffled groan, each enjoying the moment. The siblings continued like this, George’s cock now fully hard while Alice squirmed beneath him, both consumed by their ever-growing arousal.

As George slapped her tongue, he turned to admire the shifting body beneath him. Remembering she was bottomless, his gaze quickly found her hips and the glistening pussy between her open legs. He thought back to last night, at the very start of their date, and the refrain he’d **** upon himself when initially attempted to grope her. Realizing that such behavior would now be normalized, he moved his free hand behind him to her groin and gently cupped her mound, feeling her lust radiating from her core.

“What are you-” she tried to ask between slaps, George’s falling dick cutting her question short.

“I think it’s safe to say that this evolved into a follow-up date” he exclaimed, feeling power and lust coursing through him. “And you look phenomenal. It’s only fair that I show you my appreciation.”

“As a gentleman should!” she blushed, fully encouraging his new normalized behavior. “Ahh… I’m more naked than dressed though.”

“Shush!” he chided, bringing his dick back down. At the same time, he made the commitment and brushed her pussy with his fingers, coating his digits with her arousal and touching the first vagina of his life.

Alice practically cooed at the sensation, raising her hips to meet him in a subconscious attempt to get him to touch her even more. George however was more than happy to oblige, running his fingers across her slick nether lips as he began masturbating his sister.

“Oh fuck,” she groaned, her eyes closing as a rush a pleasure hit her hard. “Fuck, I’ve never had anyone touch me there before.”

“No?” he asked, eyebrow raised even though she couldn’t see it.

“No. Fuck. It feels so different when you do it.”

Taking that as a sign that he was doing something right, George felt pride swell within him and doubled his efforts, stroking his sister’s cunt as he continued to slap her face with his cock. It was soon his turn to be surprised however. In a shocking move, Alice anticipated his falling dick and met him with her tongue, deliberately licking the entire length of his shaft in a single movement.

“Fuck!” he echoed, caught off guard. Alice took the opportunity provided by his brief pause to swat his hand and grab his cock in its place, bringing it back to her mouth so she could give him another long lick.

...then a third.

Before he knew it, Alice popped the tip into her mouth and began sucking him off, their shared moment of dick slapping transcending into a proper blowjob. George’s knees buckled as his cock was suddenly engulfed in a warm wetness, Alice using her tongue to lick beneath his cock as he slid on it. After a few initial attempts, she managed to comfortably get most of his dick into her mouth.

He groaned as Alice did something particularly pleasurable, sending a shiver down his spine. “How are you so good at this?” he gasped, unable to focus on anything else but the sensations coming from his crotch.

His sister giggled at the question, popping his cock out of her mouth just long enough to answer. “I sometimes practice on my toys.”

“Fuuuck,” he repeated, settling back down to continue his attack on her pussy, rubbing two fingers on either side of her clit while he brushed her lips. Her moans reverberated around his cock, heightening his pleasure. Doubling his own ****, he relished how slick his sister’s cunt felt. He’d never touched a pussy before, so the whole experience was entirely new to him. It felt like a warm, wet velvet, one he was sure would feel phenomenal surrounding his cock.

That’s when he felt something tapping his leg, bringing him back to the moment at hand. Looking down, he immediately noticed what was causing the new sensation: Alice was hitting him with her phone, having no doubt reached over to grab it from her nightstand while he was lost in his thoughts.

He took the device and noticed it was not only unlocked but displaying her camera app. Grinning at he understood, he turned back to Alice, briefly enjoying the sight of his dick disappearing into her mouth, and raised her phone up for her to see.

“I guess you want me to take more photos?”

Her nod showed an **** eagerness, and George was more than happy to oblige, photographing the first of what would hopefully be many blowjobs between the siblings.

He took a couple more and looked back to admire his work. The shots weren’t the greatest, but they showed his sister dutifully sucking his dick with a passion he hadn’t anticipated being able to capture. Clearly Alice was making sure the blowjob felt incredible despite her inexperience, and the pictures reflected that. With the changes he’d made the night before, no doubt Alice would be thrilled to see the porn they were making together.

Suddenly remembering what she’s told him the night before, George swiped and changed the app from photo to video capture. He then angled the shot and hit record, marking the start of Alice’s transformation into a porn star.

He would’ve felt bad had she not mentioned this herself at the end of their date. She’d hinted at make porn with him, and the fact that she handed him her phone indicated it was still something she wanted. He kept it a secret from her however, wanting her to discover the footage on her own later.

He grinned to himself behind the device. This would surely lead to some incredible changes in behavior. If George was able to make it into someone’s phone, what wonders would he know find? The possibilities made him throb.

“You like sucking my dick?” he asked as the video began, reminded of the porn they’d watched together.

“I do baby,” she moaned back, her every word oozing with arousal. “Your dick tastes delicious.”

“Fuuck,” he groaned as she dived back onto his cock, George attempting to keep steady in order to capture everything he could. “You’re so wet babe.”

“Yeah, my dickhole is soaked,” she confirmed for the camera, the deliberate use of ‘dickhole’ making George throb. “My hole wants your dick George. Please, give it its namesake.”

George wasn’t sure if Alice was actually giving him her consent, or whether she was just getting into the moment. Either way, her dirty talk was hot and it was making his arousal spike. Already he could feel his approaching orgasm growing within him and he wanted to make sure to commit to at least one more change before exploding all over her face.

Thankfully, her moaning gave him the perfect segue to continue perverting the English language for his liking.

“Yeah? You want me to put my dick in your hole and start making babies with you?” he asked, shifting his fingers so that they played with what he hoped was her clit. “Or at least practice?”

“Fuck! Yes!” she yelled, her hips attempting to match his every move. She dove back down onto his dick, Alice attacking it with the dedicated of a woman fully committed to making him cum. From the way her body was squirming, George suspected she was getting closer to her growing climax as well. “Yes! Let’s try making a baby!”

She was actually getting off on his dirty talk. Alice truly had become as much of a pervert as he did. Gone was the girl who’d once chided for leaving soiled underwear in the hallway; now she was actually getting off at the idea of making babies with her brother. While his goal had only been to have Alice refer to sex as “baby making”, he also recognized the possibility that this might normalize a breeding fetish. George was excited, wondering which one would happen.

Still, the situation became too much and soon George felt his orgasm consume him. Just like he’d normalized, George gave his sister absolutely no warning as he exploded, his first spurs of cum shooting deep into her mouth. Alice gagged, having no way of anticipating the salty surprise that had just coated her tongue, and immediately spat his dick out, causing him to shoot over her smiling face instead.

Camera still rolling, George caught her as one of her hands left the frame, disappearing beneath him to replace his own at her pussy, rubbing her clit furiously as he painted her. Alice was definitely a cumslut, succumbing to an orgasm of her own almost immediately. Her yell was as loud as his.

Soon, the siblings died down and the only sound left coming from the pair was their shared heavy breathing. By now, George had ended the video and raised the camera once more to take one final shot. Unlike yesterday’s, this facial showed a girl having worked hard for her reward. If the memento of their first date captured Alice’s excitement at being covered in cum, this one showcased her dedication to it.

“Girls really do look better covered in cum” he stated, breathless.

Beneath him, Alice just flashed him a huge cum-stained grin. “Thank you!” she said, genuinely thankful for both his compliment and his semen. But George knew that he’d **** that behavior from her. George knew the truth.

And it made him excited for more.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)