Apologize and give them some space

Even in the dim light of the living room, the two naked girls are a sight to behold. They both stand there, looking at you, open-mouthed, clearly astonished to find that their passionate make-out session has been viewed by you. They each reach down with one hand to cover their crotches, and with the other arm, each of them attempt to cover their breasts. They can’t cover up fast enough to prevent a clear picture of forming in your mind of the way their erect nipples reflect the moonlight.

“Who the fuck?” Jeni demands.

You quickly and awkwardly apologize and explain who you are. You apologize again and tell them you’ll return to your room and leave them alone.

Sam seems to have overcome her surprise faster than her friend, and after giving Jeni a sly look says, “You don’t really have to run off, do you? It looks like you enjoyed the show.” Her eyes look meaningfully between your legs, and you realize that your cock is still hanging out of the fly of your boxers. You awkwardly tuck it back into place as Jeni jabs her friend. “Sam! What are you doing?”

Sam playfully jabs her back. “C’mon, Jeni... You know how we’ve fantasized about a threesome with a cute guy, and you won’t let me make a move on your brother. Well....?”

You let her words hang out there for a moment as your brain fights with your dick to appropriately process what you just heard. A few months ago, you were a sexually-frustrated teen guy, who thought you were the only person on the planet who was perpetually horny. Having met Sarah and Kendra, you figured you had lucked out beyond belief, but you never really imagined there were other girls out there would would be as sexually open as them. Hearing Sam casually suggest a threesome with a guy she just met makes you wonder if you have just been living under a rock for 18 years.

Jeni looks back and forth between you and Sam. The expression on her face tells you that she is struggling with Sam’s suggestion.