Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by 11kestrels 11kestrels

Well, what does she mean?

Let the game begin!

You hesitate a bit before finally walking over, and standing by Bailey. Bailey smiles at you. "It's kind of fun, both of us being naked in front of Shawn, isn't it Maddie? To tell you the truth, you're not all that badly built, but you could use some help." She turns to Shawn. "Now Shawn, tell us your honest opinion, right now, which one of us is more fuckable. Me or our virgin wannabe slut right here?"

Shawn's mouth drops open in total surprise. He reminds you of a deer caught in someone's headlights. "Uh... Well... Uhm..."

"Come on, young man, spit it out. Which one of us would you like to fuck more, right here and right now?" Bailey placed her hands between her legs, and held them apart. "Look Shawn. My cunt is all wet and swollen for you right now. You can see how soft and wet it is. I have a great camel toe in tight pants, too."

Shawn looks at you, then lowers his head. "I would have to say it would be you, ma'am" he answers Bailey.

Bailey jumps up and down, her fantastic looking boobs bouncing for joy as she acts like a school girl who just made the cheerleading team. "See? Now that wasn't so hard to decide, was it? Now share with us why you find me more fuckable."

Shawn actually pinches himself in disbelief as he shakes his head. After he figures out it's not a nightmare, he begins his explanation for his choice. "Well, I'd like to start off by saying I find you both sexy in your own way. You both have some great qualities. With you," he says turning to Bailey, "it's your openness, and you do have a very hot body. Any man in his right mind wouldn't say you weren't fuckable."

Now Shawn turns to you, and smiles nervously. "What I like about you is, yes, you're a virgin. You're very smart in a sexy way. You're also beautiful in your own way. I love your cute little breasts, and I'd love to suck on your nice, thick nipples. Your ass doesn't look half bad either. But in the pussy department, most guys appreciate a patch of fur that is neatly trimmed. I happen to be one of them. Is that a Brazilian trim you have?" he asks, turning back to Bailey.

Bailey giggles. "You have a very discerning eye, and you're also a pussy connoisseur. Yes, that's a Brazilian trim." She turns to you. "He is right about you. You do have a cute little ass. It wiggles nicely when you walk. And your nipples? I wish my nipples were like yours. They look like a feast waiting to happen. But that's enough of this. It's time for the loser of the competition to receive their reward. I'm going to give you a makeover!"

You stand there in stunned disbelief. "A makeover?"

"Yes, I'm giving you a makeover. It's for your own good." Bailey puts her hand against your pubic mound. "You can't even see that lovely pussy of yours. I'm going to trim it up nice and neat for you, and dress you in something super sexy. I'll also do your hair, and your makeup. Then we'll both come back, and give Shawn a show, and let him pick between us again."

Exasperated by the entire thing, you let out a deep sigh. "Okay Bailey. I'll be your test dummy."

"There's no test or dummy about it. It's about making you more sensual and desirable." She takes you by the hand, and leads you off towards the bathroom. She throws a smile and a kiss Shawn's way. "Don't jerk off too much while we're gone. We're going to need what you got in those balls."

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)