Not great

Alex sits on the floor, her breaths coming out hard and shuddering. With each one, she can feel her breasts rise and fall. She can still hear movement from within Nate's room, mostly Rena's own post-orgasmic noises.

It takes a few moments for Alex to be able to stand, strength returning to her legs. She slowly makes her way back from Nate's door, only to hear heavy footsteps from within as she moved. She turned and saw Nate coming out of his room, completely naked. His eyes scan her new body, forcing her to realize that the robe she was wearing was completely open, her breasts and pussy on full display.

"Well, you must be Alex's new girl," Nate said. "What was your name?"

"Ella," Alex says, blurting out the first name that comes to mind.

"Ella. Cute," Nate said, walking over. His dick was hardening with each step, to Alex's amazement. He had just fucked Rena and he was already set to go again? "This is quite the situation. Here Rena wanted to protect your innocence or whatever, and I catch you clearly getting off on spying on us? Very interesting."

"I wasn't..." Alex is cut off as Nate reaches her and reaches down, running a finger along her pussy. She gasps, and watches as he raises the finger up to her, showing how wet it is.

"You don't have to lie, babe. I get it. You're looking for something you can't find with Alex, right?"

Alex furrowed her brows, looking at Nate, then his fluid covered finger, then down to his fully hardened cock. It brought back the memory of her earlier fantasies when she had been masturbating.

Nate grinned, and reached for her hand. He lowered it until it was at his dick, then wrapped her fingers around it. It felt so warm, so... thick and hard. She squeezed it, then stroked slightly.

"Well? I told Rena I'd leave you alone unless you made the first move. It's up to you, babe."