Melanie Gets What She Wants After all

***Voting Outcome: Right, so thanks to everyone for voting on the last chapter, really happy to see that people are getting involved! Anyway, the winner is C, leaving Rachel and going back to Melaine with thirteen votes. Claire came in second with eleven followed by throat fucking Rachel with nine and lastly only one vote to let Rachel keep control. Hope you all enjoy the chapter! ***

You stared at your younger sister for nearly two minutes in complete silence, your heart was pounding hard, and your mind was swimming. You wet your lips as your cock pressed against your pants, just trying to get free and into her beautiful tight blonde throat. Suddenly you heard Melanie's voice in your head, Once she asks you, leave, deny her. She'll become confused then fixated on you before you know it she'll be asking you to throat fuck her. You blinked a few times and let out a shaky breath, "David? You did hear me right? I said I'll suck your cock," Rachel pipped in, curious why you were being so tentative to push forward,

You shook your head from your lust filled thoughts, well, at least the ones about Rachel, "That's okay Rach, a promise is a promise, I'm not making you do that." You hardly replied while quickly getting up,

"What?" Rachel asked while raising her head, finally looking at you, in complete confusion,

"I told you I wasn't going to make you suck me off anymore," You replied with a shrug, internally smiling as she was reacting much more upset than you thought she would,

"But...that doesn't make any sense!" She said while jumping up, "Look I see that you're hard, you obviously want me to, is it because I asked you not to throat fuck me? Is that really such a big deal breaker for you David?" She nearly spat out,

You let out a half smirk and shook your head, "No, I let Mel just suck my cock sometimes, I just don't want to get head from you right now." You replied causing Rachel's lips to slightly part and a small broken noise to escape her throat, she almost looked hurt, "I'm just gonna go have Melanie handle me, she did ask me to do this earlier anyway,"

"So you're saying, that you won't let me blow you, but you'll let Melanie?" She asked with narrowed eyes,

You tilted your head, pretending to think for a moment, "Uh...yeah, that's about right." You nodded back while Rachel glared at you, "Why are you so pissed off, I thought you were happy about me leaving you alone."

Rachel's eyes quickly widened, "I-I am! I just...I just got confused by your reasoning, that's all. Um, thank you, David, I appreciate your self-control." She said flashing you a weak smile,

You nodded, and turned around, pressing your tongue against your cheek you stopped in place. You need to milk this just a little more before you left, "Honestly, it's no trouble Rach, Melanie's got such a good throat, and she can swallow my cock with ease." You explained causing you sister to nod understandingly, though her eyes showed clear anger, "Like you said, you don't even do this stuff, so it'd make sense for me to pass up on you. So no worries, me and you are set, back to normal, no more my cock and your mouth...ever,"

Rachel swallowed slowly before forcing a smile for you, "Sounds great, David," She said, almost pushing the words from her mouth. You walked over and gave her a quick hug, making sure to press your hard-on against her leg before leaving her room. You stopped and waited for a moment, quickly heard her muttering to herself, "Oh, Melanie's such a great cocksucker, Rachel. I don't need your mouth because you're crap at it. I even offer to blow the fucker, and he says no, who does that? I'm hot, and...and I can learn how to take his cock if he'd just left me. But oooooh, no, David needs masterful Melanie...you know what good, fuck 'em, I don't care. I don't need to suck his dick ever again, that's great." She told herself, sounding weakly convincing, "I don't care, really, I don't. It's fine, Claire gets him too, but who cares. I don't have to deal with that anymore. Better them than me...yep, better them than me," She lowly finished before you finally walked away from her door.

Hearing Rachel become so resentful over Claire and Melanie because they have access to you, only because you denied her made you dick pulse. You rushed to Melanie's room, knowing that if you didn't get this handled soon, you might have turned around and given Rachel exactly what she wanted...or what you wanted, she still needed time to be converted. You unzipped your pants and pushed into Melanie's room, seeing her laying out on her bed, "Hey there, little bro, how'd dinner go?" She innocently asked as you slammed the door and dropped your pants to the ground.

Melanie's eyes were gleaming at you while you closed the distance to her bed and pulled yourself onto her chest, "I need to cum right fucking now," You grunted out,

"Here, sit here, you can fuck my face easier," Melanie immediately replied causing you to take your dipping cock away from her mouth and do as she asked. You said on the bed next to her while Melanie repositioned herself, so she was lower on the bed, her body at an angle while her head rested on your stomach. You wrapped one arm around Melanie's head, keeping her in place, while you grabbed your cock with the other. You pressed your oozing head against her lips and Melanie instantly parted them, letting your cock sink deep into her mouth.

"Oooooh, god, I need this so bad," You groaned out as you began to thrust up, sinking your cock far into Melanie's mouth, just hitting the back of her throat, "She offered just like you said," You explained while Melanie slipped a hand into her panties, rubbing herself as you worked your cock in and out of her mouth, "Do you know how hard it is to deny a blonde offering to suck my cock?! Fuck Mel, take it! Suck my fucking cock!" Melanie let out a long moan as you roughly grabbed her head with both hands, shoving her down your length, forcing it all to enter her, slipping right into her throat.

You moaned out and let your head drop back, laying still while pushing and pulling Melanie's head, making her fuck her cock with her throat instead. After just four full pumps, you pushed Melanie to your base and held her there, "Oh just hold it there Mel, oh god, that's it, Mel. Just let my cock sit in your throat," You sighed as Melanie adamantly began to lick your lower shaft and balls, all the while working her throat on your buried cock. "You're such a good girl, Mel, such a good girl," You whispered out while started to stroke her hair with one hand,

Melanie let her eyes drift shut, if it had been anyone else holding her for this long, she would have panicked. But Melanie trusted you completely, so she waited the full minute before you finally pulled her up from your now dripping shaft. She instantly sucked in a large gasping breath, filling her lungs with desperately needed air, You absently stroked your shaft, letting your sister breath for a minute, before you started to rub your slimly, spit covered cock over her cheeks, "I'm-I'm so...so proud of you, David," Melanie coughed out, nuzzling her face against your sliding shaft, "You did the right thing, and I'll make you feel so good tonight," She warmly said as her hand continued to rub her now dripping slit,

"C'mere," You grunted while hopping off the bed and pulling Melanie's head towards the edge. Melanie grinned as you lay her flat on her back, "This is getting in the way," You muttered out while grabbing her shirt and roughly ripping it open, letting her large breasts pour out for you to see, "That's better,"

"Mhm, it sure was, glad you handled that," Melanie nearly moaned back as you groped her breasts for a few seconds,

"Keep touching yourself, Mel, I love knowing you get so hot by doing this," You groaned out as Melanie dutifully began to lick and suck at your heavy balls,

"Yes sir," She hummed back while continuing to slowly work her lips, more focused on pleasing you than herself,

You marveled at your masturbating sister for almost a minute while she continued to work your sack with her tongue before you reached down and pulled her body towards you, letting her head hang off the bed, "Here we go," You said under your breath while bringing your cock back to your sister's mouth. Melanie let it hang open without a second thought, allowing you to bury yourself right back into her throat. "I'm gonna cum right down your fucking throat," You hissed out while thrusting forward, pressing your balls right over her nose occasionally. Even with completely blocking her airway at points, Melanie stayed calm, trusting you while never once breaking away from her soaked cunt, letting you enjoy a show.

"Mmmm, Mhm, Mmmm" Melanie moaned around your throat fucking shaft, as you started to feel your balls contracting. You reached down and grabbed two handfuls of her massive tits, squeezing and pinching her nipples causing her to let out pleased moans, her hand now moving quicker over her slit. With a long guttural groan, you slammed forward, hilting yourself while unleashing your pent up load right into Melanie's stomach. "Mmmmm!" Melanie cried out as she felt your pulsing cock unleashing down her throat,

"God, I love you," You grunted while lightly pumping your spewing cock in and out of her working throat. "Don't stop Mel, keep going sis," You sighed while reaching forward, making her slowing hand return to her rubbing her pussy. After a good thirty seconds you slid back out of Melanie's mouth, looking down at her spit covered face, "You look so fucking hot like that," You murmured out as she let out coughs and wheezing breaths, just a bit of your cum leaked out the corner of her mouth, "Oops, lost a little," You whispered while bringing a finger to her mouth, scooping up your spunk and pushing it back into her mouth.

Melanie wrapped her lips around your finger and sucked it clean from your spunk while intently staring at you, her hand still ceasing to stop masturbating for you. "What do you want to do now, little bro? How can big sis keep making you feel better for doing such a good job earlier?" She innocently asked while sitting up on her knees, "Anything you want David, I'll do it," She huskily said while lightly bouncing up and down at her now fingering hand.

A) You aren't done with her throat by a long shot! Lay her back down!

B) Help Melanie get a release while she works on getting you to your second.

C) Leave Melanie be, you still want to pay a visit to Claire tonight.

D) Why not bring Taylor over? Two hot older girls worshipping your cock all night sounds amazing!