Decisions, Decisions

You made your way into the kitchen and started looking through the cupboards, scanning the items inside, after a moment you grabbed some pasta and some tomato sauce, ready to make a little spaghetti. You filled up a pot with some water and turned on the stove, letting the pasta start to cook, "Hey, I'm making spaghetti if anyone wants some!" You called out to the three girls in the house,

"Wow, doing something for someone else for once?" Rachel's annoying voice said from the right, you glanced over and saw your cute little sister sitting on the couch with a cold look on her face, "So what, you put sleeping pills in it, to knock us out or did you straight up cum in it?" She spat out,

"Uh no, just a little salt," You easily replied while lifting up the salt shaker and sprinkling some inside, "I'm not some monster Rachel,"

"Could've fooled me," Rachel muttered back,

You let out a long sigh and walked over to the counter, leaning over it, "Listen, I know things were a little messed up yesterday, I went crazy when I got home and saw you."

"Yeah no shit, you facefucked me! I'm your sister for fuck sakes!" Rachel shot back while jumping up and storming towards you, "I was **** on your cock, and you didn't give a flying fuck!"

"I know, and I'm sorry," You calmly replied, "I really wanted to cum, and I just did what I wanted which wasn't cool,"

"David, you know I have to do that if you want me too, but you don't have to be such a piece of shit about it!" Rachel shot out, "And just so you fucking know, that was my first time trying that so thanks for ruining it!"

"Seriously?" You quickly asked back as Rachel started to leave, though the question stopped her in place,

"Yes, David, believe it or not, I don't go around sucking guys cocks!" She sarcastically exclaimed,

"Wow, knowing that I'd say you actually did pretty fucking good," You merely replied causing Rachel to blink a few times, surprised by the sudden compliment,

Rachel quickly shook her head, "Yeah, well it's not like I wanted to do that, I had too! And maybe I'd have done better if you didn't keep fucking my throat when I wasn't ready!"

"That's fair; I'm sure you would have," You agreed once again causing Rachel to look surprised,

"What are you trying to do, if you have to have me suck you off just say so!" Rachel suspiciously replied, unsure why you were suddenly so agreeable to her,

"No, I'm pretty handled on that front," You chuckled back, "I was just talking, I was hoping that you and I could at least start doing that again, seeing as you've been avoiding me for almost the whole day,"

"Can you figure out why?" Rachel grumbled back,

"Completely," You nodded back with a grin, "But like I said, I'm sorry, so I guess you can take that for what it's worth." You tacked on while turning around and returning to the stove,

"So that's it? You're not gonna try and make me do anything else?" Rachel asked sounding a bit hopeful,

"I mean I got Mel if I'm **** and she's always eager to help," You replied with a shrug. Rachel had a shocked smile on her face while turned around, wandering towards her room. You glanced back and smirked slightly, "I have to imagine that would be step one of Melanie's plan, she'll have to let me know the rest later." You mumbled to yourself.

Minutes past as you cooked, stirring the pasta occasionally while flipping through your phone. You smirked a bit each time you thought of Taylor probably fingering herself to your video, and you did wish the beautiful punk girl was inside your room, just waiting for you and your cock. Suddenly you were shaken out of your thoughts when you felt Claire's arms around your stomach and her hot breath on your neck, "You've had a busy day," She whispered into your ear,

"Have I?" You smirked back, growing hard just from her voice and scent,

"If you think I couldn't tell you came in my soaps and lotions, you're in for a surprise," Claire replied with a murmuring laugh, "Did you want your step mommy to rub in your cum into her skin and hair?" She asked in a sultry voice,

"Claire if you had it my way, you'd have nothing but my cum on you all day," You huskily replied as you felt her hands pawing at your cock,

"Hmm, I wouldn't mind, I love the way cum feels on my skin," She nearly moaned into your ear, "I still haven't moisturized my face, maybe you should let me use your little...'lotion dispenser' tonight," She said while squeezing your bulge,

"Cumming on your face so you can rub it in...that's pretty slutty Claire," You pointed out while turning around,

"Sure is, but if you want that as much as I do, then it's just us this time." Claire nearly growled out, "I don't want Melanie there, getting in the way,"

"I don't know Claire, my cock might be in use tonight," You replied with a cock of your head, teasing her slightly,

"It's okay, just come in whenever and wake me up." Claire softly replied as her hands finally pulled away from you, "I'll be ready and willing, sweetie."

You grinned as you watched your stepmom walk away, her juicy ass actively swinging for you causing your dick to twitch. You leaned back against the counter and shut your eyes just imagine painting your blonde stepmom's face in thick ropes of cum, then watching her rub it into her skin. It was a more than a tempting offer. Before you could even open your eyes you felt a pair of plump lips pressing against yours while smooth fingers ran through your hair, you slowly opened your eyes and saw Melanie hungrily kissing you.

"Mel?" You asked as she finally pulled away with a smile,

"Hi," She murmured back with a pleased sigh, "What do you think about spending the night with me tonight?"

"Spending the night as in?" You asked back with a small grin,

"We could stay up watching some movies...any kind of movie," She said with a little raise of her brow, immediately making you grin as you thought of watching porn with your sister, "Then, well, I guess I could always..." Melanie whispered out while moving closer to your ear, "Snack on your cum whenever I got hungry,"

"What if I get hungry?" You almost groaned back as Melanie's large breasts pushed against your chest, making your feel her erect nipples,

"Oh trust me, David, you can snack on anything of mine you want." She sighed back, "I might even have a few surprises for you later on," She hinted with a grin, "So, you let me know if you're free and no one else is having the luxury of your company tonight,"

"Will do, Mel," You assured her as she leaned in again and planted a long, wet kiss on your lips before slipping out of the kitchen.

(Alright, everyone, I wanted to switch it up for this chapter and actually have some real interactivity! I want to write what you guys want to see, so that means you all get a vote! So, below I'll list some options for David to pick from and you all just comment which one you want to see the most! Also, if you wanted to, leave a like if you not only enjoyed the chapter but like this idea of really being able to pick what happens next!)

(A) Despite all the open offers, you want to spend some more time with Rachel tonight.

(B) Covering Claire in cum is way too tempting to pass up on.

(C) A romantic, sex filled night with Melanie sounds fantastic to you.

(D) Taylor did want you to come over, and the night is young after all.