Put them side by side

"Get up!" you snap at Valerie, who rolls off your lap whimpering and rubbing her bare ass, looking at you with tearful eyes. You stand and strip her shorts off, then make her kneel on the couch and put her hands on the back.

"What are you going to do Daddy?" she asks in a quavering voice, looking over her shoulder at you.

"Shut up Valerie. Put Grace beside her," you say to Brian who has already got the sobbing red head to her feet and pushed her shorts to her ankles. He pushes her into place beside Valerie, the two girls looking at each other with trepidation that doesn't hide their distaste for each other. At least the two little bitches aren't clawing and spitting at each other, you think as you grin at Brian.

"This one wants to be spanked by me," you say gesturing to Grace's rosy rump, "And the other one wants it from both of us. This makes it easier to give the both what they have coming." You smack Grace's ass hard for emphasis, making her squeal and arch her back.

"Sounds good to me," Brian smirks, landing a resounding slap across Valerie's rump.

"Daddies! Please! Please Stop!" she wails, "Please! Let me be good! Let Me Be Your Good Girl!"

"Owwwwwwwwww! Mr. Carter! Oh God it stings! Please! I'm So Sorry!" Grace whines, squirming as she looks back at you, her eyes heated. The voices of the two penitent girls are like a chorus of dismay as you and Brian paddle their rumps, alternating between the two of them.

"Please Mr. Carter....No more! Please! I'm begging you," Grace whimpers, raising her ass as she arches her back.

"Please Daddies, please make me a good girl! Please!" Valerie wails squirming her own rump as she looks back with tearful, wanton eyes. The aroma of their arousal is thick in the air, and your cock is hard and straining in your pants. You smack Valerie's ass again and she yelps, grabbing one of Grace's hands and squeezing it, their fingers twining as if in support of each other's pain.

"How much more Mr. Carter? Oh God...how much more?" Grace moans as she spreads her knees, exposing herself more fully, her puffy labia glistening with dew. "Please Sir...take me....please....punish me...punish me with your cock..."

Brian glances at you with a smile as the redhead whimpers in submission. Beside her Valerie is arching her back and raising her ass, her own thighs parting to show the nectar flowing from her flowering pussy.

"Yes Daddies, yes...please let me be good for you...so good...please...." the brunette moans, pressing her face against the couch, her soft lips parted as she gasps.

"Which one do you want?" Brian asks with a wolfish smile, nodding at the two broken teens.