Start by toying with some of the girls

You'd asked them some questions about their likes and dislikes to mixed, and rather lackluster results, but now you could try whatever you wanted out and see how the girls would react. It certainly would be fun to play with all of them, but Astrid and Emma specifically were the most mysterious. Emma told you a little bit about what she thought she’d like, but she was either too embarrassed to say much, or just didn’t know enough about herself to give you a proper checklist to go through. And Astrid… you got the impression she didn’t like you a whole lot, she mostly just tolerated you.

Following that train of thought, you got off of Kari and pounced at Astrid who up until then had been watching you, looking somewhat bored. Astrid immediately recoiled and let out some unintelligible grunt, perhaps even a swedish curse for all you knew, as you bowled her onto her back.

With one hand on either side of her head, sinking deep into your bed, you leaned in for a kiss.

Astrid still seemed stunned by you crashing into her that it took her a moment to realize what you were after and when she did she tried to retreat into the mattress. It was fruitless, obviously, a moment later your lips were on hers.

Her crimson lips were closed tight, but that didn't stop you. You ran your tongue across the warm, tender wall and we're rewarded quickly by them parting to let your tongue inside. Without a moment's hesitation you snaked your tongue into her mouth and started feeling around. You ran your tongue over her lips and teeth and swabbed the inside of her cheek, you poked and prodded at her tongue and took in her flavour.

It wasn’t at all satisfying though. You could taste her, and it was arousing you to no end, but you weren’t satisfied. If you had to guess at why, you’d say it was probably the poorly masked look of disgust on her face, and her general lack of any reciprocation. If you wanted that you’d have just went straight between her legs.

At least you were learning something already. Astrid didn’t like being kissed. It compounded with what you already knew, just because you could do something, didn’t mean it had to be liked or even tolerated. All that meant to you though was that by the end of the night you wanted Astrid to be more than happy to kiss you back, maybe even let you hit on her after everything was said and done. Shit, if you could fuck her into dating you that would be the greatest success you could imagine! All things considered though you weren’t sure how comfortable you’d be going steady with anyone….

Before any of that even mattered though it would’ve been smart to stop making out with her.

Since Astrid didn’t like having your tongue in her mouth you pulled back and instead buried your face into her neck and pressed your entire naked form into her. Her reaction was nearly as bad as when you jumped her. As soon as you placed your lips on her neck she flinched, her head and shoulder squeezed together in a weak attempt at defending against you and she put a hand on your chest. She seemed to think better of pushing you off of her, but it was obvious she was considering it.

“So… uhm, Emma? You go to school around here too?” Astrid shakily asked, her nose wrinkled and her jaw tensed.

You moved up a little, pulling your lips off her neck with a wet smack, and pinched her earlobe between your lips.

“Well not here.” Emma coughed.

The feeling of the bed sinking slightly and shaking told you Emma had left the space between Nalini’s thighs and taken up a spot close to you, as did the volume of her continuation,

“I go to the high school across town. I’m in my last year.”

“R-right… I think you may have mentioned that….” Astrid’s voice was strained.

So she definitely didn’t like you slobbering on any part of her head, at least not yet, so you’d have to go lower. Not that you planned on going for her scalp next. You sat up, still straddling Astrid’s waist, and started looking for a way to undo her corset.

“So how’s that treating you?” Kari added to the conversation, smirking at you with a cocked eyebrow before rolling over and devoting her attention Emma.

You couldn’t find a way to undo her corset. The front of the garment had laces weaving back and forth like a spider web up the entire length, but you couldn't find any end to the string. Logically that probably meant you should check the back, but the more you thought, the more you considered that you’d just be doing more of the same. If she didn’t like your mouth near her face or neck would her breasts be all that different? Possibly. But maybe a complete change of tactics would be smarter. You had planned on getting her to like you after all.

“Uh… it’s not bad I suppose.” Emma bobbed her head from side to side, her attention was split between Kari and what you were doing.

Perhaps it would’ve been a bit on the nose, but you slid of Astrid and moved to expose her nethers. It was a tight fit, but you managed to squeeze your fingers underneath the waistband of her pants and slowly started to peel them down.

“You, uh, don’t have any troubles with any of your subjects?” Kari twitched in her makeshift bindings.

“Oh like you give a shit about that.” Astrid scoffed and lifted herself off the bed just enough to let you pull her pants down.

You could actually feel it separating from her skin, if the room was quiet you were sure you could hear it, it was like her pants were vacuum packed.

“What Kari really wants to know is how much shit you get for being a lesbian.” Astrid lowered herself back to the bed once you had her pants down to her knees. She had definitely relaxed some now that you didn’t have your lips on her.

She had practically been vacuum packed into her pants. No doubt that was the reason she had a gold g-string thong on instead of actually panties, there wasn’t enough room for anything more. The particular style of g-string even managed to put the one you had found in Nalini’s hotel to shame.

“It’s called tact you bitch, learn it!” Kari looked over her shoulder and scowled at Astrid.

“It’s fine, I don’t care!” Emma sat up straight, her eyes nearly popping from her head.

“She’s right though, I want the juicy deets.” Kari no longer sounded the least bit upset.

“Uh…oh… um.” Emma sucked on her lips for a moment, then looked up at you and blinked a few times.

All you could do was smile and shrug at her. You were getting used to Kari’s boisterous personality, and Emma would have to as well. It stood to reason Astrid had a very similar disposition as her friend.

“I mean, sure. Or well… I… don’t get bullied… so….”

“Seriously? High school must’ve changed since I was your age.” Astrid's eyebrows crept up her head.

“Well… no one really knows I like girls.” Emma’s eyes dropped back down to where you were working on Astrid’s crotch, but her eyes were narrowed and her nose was wrinkled. She seemed lost in thought.

You slipped your hand beneath the top of the panties and pinched Astrid’s lower lips between the sides of your first and middle finger. Her reaction this time was far less violent. Her back arched ever so slightly, her nostrils flared and her chest rose as she sucked in a deep breath, but beyond that there was nothing. You seriously doubted it was entirely because she was now paying attention to Emma. This was a good sign.

“I’m not buying it.” Kari clicked her tongue.

“Complete bullshit.” Astrid made a show of clearing her throat.

“I have to agree. If a girl as cute as you didn’t date any guys for three years, in high school no less, people would suspect something.” Nalini let out a wistful sigh, sprawled out and spent beside Emma, “No way hormonal teenagers you stay away from you.”

Astrid and Kari voiced their agreement. When Emma looked around and met your gaze you gave her a wink and a bob of your eyebrows.

“Oh… um… I have guy friends.” Emma’s gaze dropped to the rooms carpet, her face turning beet red.

Now that you knew Astrid was a bit more comfortable without your spit being involved, you had a thread of follow. Keeping up the pressure, you slowly pulled your hand back and tracing the outer edge of her slit. No matter how much you rubbed her though, her reaction was nonexistent unless you counted the increase in moisture. You’d have to do something about that.

“I… uh, also had a couple boyfriends.” Emma murmured, just above a whisper, rubbing her hands up and down her thighs.

“No shit?” Kari lifted her head of the bed in a show of interest, before letting it bounce back down.

Nalini too looked interested as she sat part way up, supporting herself by throwing her arms behind her.

Astrid seemed to be trying to do the same as Nalini, but you reached back and pressed into her chest with one hand. With the hand still buried in her panties you felt around for her clit, once you found it, you braced one finger beside it and with the other started to trace over it. Just as you hoped, Astrid was having much more trouble keeping her composure. Her body went limp and her eyes shot open wide. It still wasn’t quite what you were after though.

“Yeah, I dated a couple of my friends -- I mean now they’re friends.” Emma took a deep breath.

“This before you figured out you like girls? Or were you just putting on a show?” Kari’s question was met with a grunt of agreement from Nalini.

You were still focused on trying to get Astrid to squirm though. You increased the pressure you were using and slowly extended your finger, running the length of it over her clit. That caused her to squeeze her eyes shut for a moment and suck on her lips.

“Um, sort of.” Emma took another deep breath and flopped backwards onto your bed, “I liked these guys that’s why we're’ still friends, and well… I thought dating them would work but… it just didn’t feel right. Y’know?”

You took a few more moments to trace your fingers around the edge of Astrid’s slit, but she seemed to be getting used to whatever you did to her, as she was starting to rein in her reactions considerably, she was even back up to asking questions,

“Didn’t feel right how? Like with sex or…?”

“No, not exactly.” Emma shook her head frantically, “Like, we kissed and stuff, but it just didn’t feel right. I’m not sure how to describe it.”

“Maybe they just sucked at kissing.” Kari sniffed loudly.

It seemed like making Astrid squirm with just your hands was going to be an uphill battle from here on, so you decided to go back to finding out what else she liked. As soon as you pulled your hands from her panties you could swear she let out a sigh, but her expression hadn’t changed from the friendly smile she was giving Emma. You decided to keep on with your plans, rolling down her panties to her knees for later and went to flip her over,

“That’s an idea. How’d they kiss you?” Astrid nodded her head at Emma, and gave you a momentary look you couldn’t quite decipher, her brow was furrowed slightly, but she was still smiling as she helped you flip her onto her stomach.

Sure as shit, the laces to her corset were on the back.

“I don’t know.” Emma laughed nervously, “I guess they were really gentle, loving maybe….” Emma laughed and brought a hand to her chin, “I told one of them I liked the idea of having my neck sucked on though, and he tried that a few times…” Emma cleared her throat but no one was stopping her so she pressed on, “but I had the girl I dated do it and I nearly came right there.” Emma started laughing again and squeezed her eyes shut while shaking her head.

Once you peeled the corset off Astrid, as well as a matching black tube top that she had been wearing underneath it, you took a moment to admire her back. She must’ve worked out, that much you were vaguely aware of.

You were reminded of something. Your college had a lot of rotating workshops available and one year you got a masseuser certification. It had been a lust filled attempt at getting to rub down attractive women. The truth ended up being that most of the other students that you had to practice with were either old, hairy, or men though. Still, there had been a few attractive students that you had the luck of being paired with a few times but you couldn’t remember a damn thing about their back.

If someone asked you what you thought about a woman’s back you probably wouldn’t have been able to answer. Here and now though you found something irresistible about Astrid’s toned and defined back. The definition of her shoulder blades and the gentle valley in the middle of her spine that spoke of the size of some abdominal muscles you didn’t know the name of. Having her before you, completely free to do what you willed with, you didn’t hesitate to trace every curve and line on her back. To your pleasant surprise you felt her shiver, more than once. You got the biggest reaction when you ran your fingers down the length of the crease in the middle of her back, but you also got a bit of a reaction when you traced the large dimples she had right above each of her tight and defined cheeks.

“Oh, w-well maybe they did suck then.” Astrid cleared her throat and clenched her cheeks together, really showing you how toned they were as well, “how many people have you dated?”

“Uhhh, two guys and one girl.” Emma sat up, her flush finally starting to die down as she was beginning to get into the rhythm of things.

“Sound’s like my last threesome.” Kari fought and struggled for a moment until she managed to sit up, despite the stunted use of her arms and legs.

“So maybe you just haven't met the right guy then.” Astrid sucked in a deep breath ending with a grunt as you dug your thumbs in between her clenched cheeks and started to pry.

‘Pry’ was the perfect word for it as well. It was pretty clear she worked out, just by appearances, Nalini had a nice ass and Kari was just naturally thick, but Astrid’s rear looked like it had been sculpted from marble, and now that you were trying to spread her cheeks they felt like marble too.

“I’m not trying to sounds homophobic or anything!” Astrid quickly added, relaxing enough for you to finally get her cheeks apart, “I just mean if you’ve got doubts maybe -- eep -- there’s a reason.” Astrid looked over her shoulder to glare at you after you had brushed your thumb over her backdoor and gotten her to squeal.

“I’ve gotta agree with Miss Piggy. You said your boyfriends were ‘gentle’ but in my opinion, if you’re trying to compare the two, there’s one thing you want men for over women in the bed, it's a good brutal pounding.”

Astrid had immediately reached out to give Kari a jab to the shoulder, just as you had thrusted your thumb into her ass. You immediately felt her entire body tense underneath you.

“Fucking shit! What the hell?” Kari yelped and rolled away from Astrid, a grimace on her face.

Emma immediately scoot away, into Nalini who was sitting up straight now, both looked stunned.

“Will you just pick a goddamn hole already!” Astrid buried her face into the bed and groaned.

With a pained smile, Kari let out a brief chuckle and glanced down at the thumb you had sunk into Astrid’s ass.

“Eventually.” You made no move to stop however, you actually started working your thumb in deeper.

“Astrid here doesn’t like being teased.” Kari shook her head slowly.

As Kari’s tone and demeanor softened, Emma and Nalini both exhaled slowly and slumped over. Nalini still kept a wary eye on Astrid, but Emma had her eyes locked on Nalini’s naked form and was shuffling away frantically.

“How’s she feel about having things up her butt?” You flexed your thumb one last time and then slowly pulled it out.

“Kari!” Astrid snapped her head to the side and glared at her friend.

Kari made no attempt to hide her vicious smile though,

“How about you try something bigger and find out?”

Astrid immediately let out a hiss and pushed off the bed, nearly knocking you over as she got on her knees and towered over Kari.

“Fuck off, you slugged me out of nowhere, now you’ve got to pay for it.”

Astrid immediately deflated and her eyes fell to your rock hard cock. It was difficult to read her expression, her body language screamed crestfallen, but her in her eyes popped with liveliness. On the one hand none of her reactions was anything like when you tried to kiss her, but on the other hand she looked ready to slug Kari on purpose for recommending you take her ass.

Scary as it was to even consider trying anything she might not like after nearly breaking your thumbs trying to pry her buns apart, it was incredibly tempting.

“Maybe in a little bit.” You gave Astrid a broad smile.

Her face was still blank. No disappointment, no relief, no scowl, no anything. That didn’t help.

“Since you had your chance to tell me what you liked and disliked earlier.” Your smiled faltered.

This time Astrid gave a wry smile, and swayed her head from side to side.

Heading back to the doorway from among Nalini’s sextoys, you pulled out one of the other supplies you had gathered together, the moisturizer you had bought from Christina earlier in the afternoon.

“For now though, you think you could hold her down and lube her up for me?” You jiggled the pink bottle towards Astrid and flicked your eyes towards Kari.

“The fuck did I do?”

Astrid seemed unimpressed by both you and her friend’s protests, still not helping you figure out how she was feeling.

“Y’know, before I take you for a spin?” You tried to do something to get a read on her.

Her response was to smile, but also to snatch the bottle from your hands and pounce on Kari. Immediately, the two started to wrestle. Kari was losing, badly, in large part due to her being bound. It was to your surprise that the shoelaces were holding up tremendously well. You were a bit disappointed though that you couldn’t tell if Astrid was smiling because you had told her you wanted her ass, or because she wanted to give Kari a hard time.

Within moments Astrid had Kari on her stomach and dropped a knee onto her head, shoving it deep into your mattress. For a moment you froze with concern at how violent it looked, but a moment later a muffled grumble washed away your fears,

“You better hope he fucks me stupid or the second I get these things off--” Kari was immediately cut off by a hard downward slap against one of her cheeks from Astrid, and she gave a muffled squeal.

“Who’s Miss Piggy now? You look and sound like a pig!” Astrid let out a short laugh, but quickly sobered up as Kari started to buck and squirm underneath her while cursing up a storm.

Astrid was **** to move her knee from the back of Kari’s head and instead use both her knees to hold Kari’s head in place, while leaning over and grabbing onto her wrists.

“You don’t mind helping me with this, do you?” Astrid was looking straight at Emma.

“Uh… no.” Emma swallowed audibly.

“Just get her pants off and spread her cheeks for me.”

Kari had calmed down as soon as Emma grabbed her pants but Astrid didn’t let go.

You turned to Nalini, who up until this point was just watching things with a mildly amused look on her face, and you bought one finger to your mouth and with the other gestured for her to roll over herself.

Nalini’s eyes went wide and her jaw went slack, she looked like she wanted to say something, but after a beat she shut her mouth and did as you asked. As you reached for Nalini you heard an audible creak and a pop as Astrid opened the plastic bottle you had given her.

“What is that? It smells pretty good.” Emma coughed, one of Kari’s generous cheeks in each hand.

“Says it's some tropical bullshit.” Astrid barely even glanced at the label before pressed the opening against Kari’s opening and started to squeeze.

“Fuck that’s cold!”

You couldn’t say the same about the vibrator you had begun to extract from Nalini. It was warmed to her body temperature.

Nalini collapsed against the bed and bit onto the covers in an attempt to muffle her sigh of relief once the toy was finally removed from her. You didn’t know the exact feeling, but you did know that after a while you could get used to a constant sensation to the point where having it stop was a shock of its own.

“Why do you even have this?” Astrid looked up at you and pulled the bottle away from Kari’s hole.

Emma was completely focused on tenderly spreading the cream around with her thumbs.

“For lube.” You coughed and twirled the vibrator around.

“Why not get actual lube?”

“This is less conspicuous.”

“Do you even have a roommate?”

What the fuck were you supposed to tell her? You bought it so a stranger would fuck you and you could avoid looking like a sexual predator?

The best you could do was shake your head and try to change the subject.

“Hey, Emma, that’s enough I think, I can do the rest.”

It took until you placed a hand on her shoulder, causing her to jump, before she got the message.

To your pleasure you noticed that Kari couldn’t really see with Astrid pinning her head.

Once Emma got out of the way, you straddled Kari’s hips and readied the currently silent vibrator. You smiled broadly at what you saw. You had left a somewhat impressive bruise on one of Kari’s cheeks from the night before, and by coincidence that was what Astrid had hit and caused Kari to squeal.

You began pushing the vibrator in. Surprisingly, she was taking it just as well as Nalini had.

“Jesus, how much of you is there.” Kari grumbled from between Astrid’s legs.

It took everything you had not to burst out laughing, Astrid went as far as biting her lip to keep quiet.

Once you had the toy deep enough, you turned it on low.

“And where the fuck did you learn that!” Kari let out a gasp, and you definitely heard a bit of a chuckle.

The jig was clearly up and Astrid burst out laughing as she released Kari.

You only needed a moment to decide to up the power some more.

“Jesus!” Kari wiggled underneath you in a superficial attempt to get away, but putting your hands on her ass and pressing down was enough to stop it entirely, “This feels weird. I don’t think I’ve ever had a vibrator this far up my ass before.”

You were somewhat surprised, your impression of Kari thus far was that she was a wild and experienced party girl, at least at one point. Then again, she said ‘this far.’

“Well consider this a treat then.” You started to knead her cheeks then squeezed them together around the vibrator, “After all, you told me you wanted me to break you, right?”

“Oh, is that what this is about?” Kari lifted her head from the bed and looked back at you, “Well it feels weird but you’re going to need more--”

You flicked the toy up to max.

“--Turn it the fuck off!” Kari’s tune changed in an instance and she buried her face back into your bed with a low groan.

“You thought it was funny when you did it to Nalini.” You followed up with a mighty crack across her, so far, unbruised cheek.

Kari arched her back and moaned, then shakily added,

“I thought, ungh, she was overreacting.”

You quickly got off Kari and slipped a hand under her, lifting her onto her knees by her neck, forcing her to look up at you as you towered over her, then squeezed,

“Oh, so you’re broken already, bitch?” You gave her another hard slap across her pale ass.

“Fuck you.” She wheezed.

You started to squeeze harder and gave her another harder smack, this one forcing Kari’s jaw to work soundlessly for a moment.

“I think I should give you a matching set.”

“I think… I’m starting to like you.” Kari gasped out with what little air you hadn’t cut off yet.

With a smirk of your own you leaned in and started to viciously tongue her mouth. She was kissing you back almost instantly. When you drew back a moment later there was a trail of spit connecting you. You didn’t let her go until you spat your mixed saliva back into her mouth, then you tossed her back against the bed.

You were starting to really want to bone her, but at the same time you had other plans.

“Hey Emma, where are we on that roughing you up idea?”

Emma just stared at you, her eyes periodically flicked between your rock hard cock pointed straight at her and Kari who was recovering from a short coughing fit.

“There’s a middle ground, I don’t need to do all that.” You quickly added.

“Umm… sure, I guess.” Emma let out a half cough half chuckle and started to pull her shirt off over her head.

She barely tossed the shirt to the side before you shoved her onto her back and pinned her beneath you. Emma’s reaction was to squeak and go limp. She clearly wasn’t a fighter like Astrid or Kari. Her natural submissiveness made it easy to treat her ‘like a toy’ as she had mentioned liking the idea of earlier in the afternoon.

You pressed into her and grabbed a fistful of her soft hair, tilting her head back forcefully and slipped her your tongue. After a moment's hesitation she tried to kiss you back, but even that was limp.

You tightened your grip on her hair and pulled her in deeper, taking a moment to bite her lip and pulled it back. Despite her meek reciprocations, she responded by let out a moan between breaths and placing a hand on the back of your head.

As she ran her hands through your hair, you moved your free hand down to her chest and rolled up her bra, exposing her adorably small breasts. Taking to heart the suggestion she might like thing’s rough you pinched one of her nipples tight and yanked back on it.

Emma froze and yelped. The reaction shocked you into stopping and letting her breast go. You started to pull back, but Emma quickly grabbed a fistful of your hair and growled at you,

“Do it again!” She then pulled your face towards hers and started kissing you with far more vigor than before.

You couldn’t tell if she had just gotten over her nerves or if you awoke something in her, but you weren’t going to complain. You pushed your hips between her legs and started to grind against her through her pants and kneaded her breasts with reckless abandon. No matter how rough you got though, Emma didn’t pull her tongue out of your mouth for more than a second.

Eventually you felt Emmas thighs clamp around yours as one of her hands snaked down into her pants.

That was certainly an idea. Exploring Astrid ended up being more of an experiment and an appreciation for her body than anything, but Emma was getting you real hot and heavy. Experimentation was fun in its own way, but there would be time for that later. Then again, there’d be time for sex later too.

Decisions, decisions.