You relent, but there are conditions.

The two of you look at Valerie coldly as she grovels pathetically, frantically begging to stay and make amends. You stay silent, forcing your face into a stern unsmiling mask of remorseless justice while secretly loving to see the formerly arrogant young bitch pleading for mercy.

She crawls to you, sobbing pitifully, reaching her slender hands out to clutch at your calves.

"Please Daddy, I'll do anything to make it up, please let me prove to you that I'm not that wicked girl anymore. You beat it out of me Daddy, both of you did, both my Daddies. You beat and fucked the wicked girl out of me. And only the good girl is left. Oh please Daddy, let me stay. Let me stay and I'll be so good for both of you. So good always. Please Daddies don't send me away! I couldn't stand it! I couldn't!" She holds your legs, her sobs shaking her body with unrelenting grief.

Brian looks at you, obviously letting you take the lead in dealing with the broken teen. You smile and reach down to grab a handful of her brown hair, pulling her face up to look at you.

"You have one chance Valerie," you say coldly. "One chance and one chance only. You're going to text Sondra that you're ok. You're also going to text her that you've been a stupid bitch and that it's too dangerous and too mean to try to hurt Mr. Watts or me. Mr. Watts will dictate the text and read it before you send it. If you do anything else, we will send you away tonight, and recommend to Ms. Naylor that you be expelled." She nods her agreement as she looks up at you with wide tearful eyes that have a faint glimmer of hope in them.

"Secondly, you will write a letter to Ms. Naylor admitting that you lied about what happened earlier today when you were hazing the girls. You will take full responsibility for it and say that you have admitted your actions to us, and offered to make full repentance. We will dictate the letter and you will write it and sign it."

"If you do these things exactly as we tell you, we will consider speaking to Ms. Naylor and having her restore your eligibility to play."

"Oh Thank You!" she says with tearful joy, hugging your knees. "Thank You Daddy! Thank you both my Daddies! I'll do everything you say! Everything! Oh Thank You so much! I'll be such a good girl for my Daddies!"

You give a smile of triumph to your roommate as you pry the clutching girl off your knees and push her towards him.

"Dictate the text and make sure you see it. You send it, not her." He nods agreement as Valerie kneels at his feet, pressing her face against his leg and looking up at him with obedient eyes. You smile again and go upstairs to look for something and make a few preparations.