Keep her

"No," you say as you activate the mind control ring.

Jane had laid down on her side and looked to be passed out from the exertion and ****, and you reach down and give her breasts a couple more squeezes. She groans, but doesn't look like she'll be waking up anytime soon.

You give the driver the address and order him to bring you back to the mansion and the car starts to move again. Sitting on the long seat, you admire Jane's naked form. She may not be the brightest girl, but her body is made for sex and you decide that you want to keep her around. You hope Elena wouldn't mind.

You shake Jane by the shoulder until she wakes up, and then you use your power to influence her mind. According to you, Jane decided that she couldn't go through with the wedding and that she was going to live with you so that she could fuck you anytime. She'll call her fiance in the morning to break the news. You also made sure that she wouldn't mind sharing you with other women, and in fact would be open to engaging in sexual activity with them. After that, you let Jane sleep on the peaceful ride back to the mansion.

Sometime during the way, you come to the realization that you're inadvertently building your own harem. Olivia had been a means to an end. Elena was by chance. And Jane, well, you just wanted to fuck Jane. You think back about the encounters you've had since gaining the magic rings to see if there was anyone you wanted to add to the harem. Maybe one of the actresses from earlier today? No, too obvious and people would get suspicious. It probably went against the superhero code to have a harem, if there was one, but your cock overruled all codes.

After a while, the limousine pulls up in the driveway of the mansion. The front door is open and it appears Olivia had just gotten home. She comes out wearing a sparkly black dress and is amused to see you step out of the car naked.

She gives you a hug and kiss, not minding your nakedness. She peers into the vehicle and sees the naked Jane. "Who's this?" she asks.

"The girl inside is Jane. She'll be staying with us from now on. Put her up in a nice room, will you?"

"Sure, I'll get to it right now. Ooh, she's pretty!" Olivia sounds excited as she hurries into the mansion. You activate the super strength ring and carry Jane in, sending the driver home and wiping his memory of the night.