Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 24 by fyreant fyreant

It's going to get messy, isn't it?

Masquerade Orgy part 1

You hadn't seen Tanya this aroused since that day she had you tied up on her bed in the schoolgirl uniform... now that you know her fetishes you realize that it must be taking all of her willpower not to start gushing excitedly about how every dick in the room would soon be firing off unprotected loads into all of you.

Tanya had put on a light plastic dragon mask that more fully covered her identity now, and had given you a 'Disney Princess' mask to put on. You weren't sure why it was so important for you and her to wear masks - Anna still wasn't wearing one, and neither was Vanessa, the girl in the witch costume. It was the guys who needed to worry about their identity, right? But Tanya had been insistent on it.

The scene of the 'play' Tanya had described was just the living room with a couch, a loveseat, and a nice thick blanket on the floor all in close proximity. At the moment there was only one guy per woman, a total of five, but you wouldn't be surprised if Tanya started enthusiastically beckoning more into the fuck-frenzy she'd been building towards. For the moment it looked like mostly the guys you'd seen talking to Tanya earlier.

Making the first move fearlessly, the buff black guy in the superhero outfit (with briefs desgined to be tugged aside of course) stepped up close as soon as Tanya got within reach and grabbed her round, bouncy ass-cheeks in his hands, sliding up her dragon-patterned minidress. Tanya giggled and lightly pushed him away, giving his huge, hardening package a stroke but keeping him at arms length for the moment. "Whoah, hey! Just a second guy. You should let me, fairy-girl and Princess get each-other warmed up first, I think you all will enjoy the show. That goes for the rest of you too, no need to rush... we have all night and all day tomorrow."

"Buuut," Tanya says, turning around and giving all the other girls a wave of her 'tail' (both the one on her costume and her perfect behind), "you know how I asked you to help put on a special show here?" she asked Vanessa and Willow. "Well, I want this to look as hot as it feels, and to be as authentic as possible. What I mean is, there were no rubbers in medieval fantasy times, right? So we'll all be doing it bare."

You saw the girl in the witch costume do a quick double-take at Tanya, and both you and Anna had to bite down on a giggle. Willow, in the sexy knight costume with the chainmail-pattern minidress and the leather boots, had her face mostly hidden inside the barred plastic helmet she was wearing but clearly wasn't pleased either, wringing her hands in concern.

Both of them started to raise objections... but Tanya steamrolled them just like she always did you. She had a knack for that. "C'mon, it will feel better. And you can just make sure they're in a position so you can make them pull out." she cajoled. Over on the sidelines, the drunk girl in the bunny costume laughed and cheered, egging Tanya on and encouraging the girls to go along with it. Thanks to the magic of peer pressure and having drank enough to get a little buzz going, Willow and Vanessa agreed.

Tanya motioned for you to lie down on the couch and flipped your skirt up, starting to tease your lower lips and licking at your petals, waving and presenting her butt to the crowd with her skirt riding up over it. The guy in the superhero outfit was drawn to her again - in a flash he had his impressively large cock out and was slapping it on Tanya's asscheeks and reaching down to squeeze both of her big glorious tits as she ate you out. Anna liked this, and the beautiful, buxom, pink-haired punk girl skipped over, making her tits bounce and her fake fairy wings swish in the air. Soon Tanya was servicing both of you at once. She broke away from your cunt to stick her fingers in both of you, and then whispered a few commands back over her shoulder while you and Anna moaned your pleasure.

A couple of guys stepped forward. One of them was a tan-skinned, hairy-chested guy wearing a wifebeater and a very cheap-looking goblin mask, a very simple excuse for a costume. He sat on one end of the loveseat and pulled Annabelle down onto his lap, grinding her booty against his clothed manhood and starting to squeeze her enviable tits aggressively.

The other one was... vaguely familiar somehow. You first felt like you'd seen his costume before, earlier in the party, but you couldn't place exactly where. All of the giddiness of the sexy atmosphere was making it hard for you to think very rationally anyway. Unlike most of the others in the group, this young man was actually wearing an appropriate fantasy costume, a 'King Arthur' style outfit complete with a crown. Also like you it included a plastic mask, hiding all of his features except for his red hair. He was especially eager, yet also notably tender when he slid into the seat and pulled you sideways into his lap, cradling your right breast with one hand and sliding the other between your thighs, treating you to both his and Tanya's fingers toying with you at once.

Out of the corner of your eye you saw that the other couch included Vanessa the dark-skinned witch getting bent over the armrest and having her exposed butt lightly spanked by a guy in a 'nutcracker' costume who was already getting his cock out. Willow, meanwhile, was pulled into a sitting position on the lap of a man in a farmer costume with simple overalls (with a flap open for his manhood to poke through, of course), but facing him rather than facing away like you and Anna were on your respective guys. It was the calm before the storm as all five males started lubricating themselves up with the tubes that Tanya had provided - the kind marketed as improving the chances of conception.

The man behind Tanya let out a loud, exultant groan as he started to slide his oversized meat into Tanya's juicy pussy. You slid one of your feet forward to feel the wonderful sensation of her tits starting to sway and bounce back and forth as the man began softly slapping his hips against hers.

"Ohhh damn, ohh!" the big man groaned excitedly, eyes rolling back as he probed Tanya's steamy depths with his lengthy cock. "It feels... so much better without a rubber, hell yes - I don't think I can go back after this." He rested one of his hands on top of Tanya's short spiky blue hair, right between her costume horns.

Rather than respond verbally, Tanya reached over to stroke the balls and shaft of the guy underneath Anna... helping to flip the frilly green skirt of the busty punk-girl's fairy costume up so that the fat dick-head could start rubbing up against her pussy-lips, finally sliding into her when the eager guy pulled her down onto his lap.

"Nnnh... Oooh... Now doesn't that look fun Princess? Having me stroke and lick your clit while you bounce up and down on a bare cock?" she purred at you. "I was thinking about stealing your 'partner' there for myself, but I decided that the best cock of the event should go to you, since you've been so good."

The 'King Arthur' under you whimpered with just as he stroked both hands and fingers over your slippery slit and mound, the prize royal rod that Tanya spoke up poking your thigh. You swallowed heavily and raised up, shoving your ass in the guy's face for a moment, before slowly sitting down onto the rock-hard pillar and guiding it up into your folds, letting out shrill squeals and gasps as you did so.

Luckily, Willow and Vanessa were too far away and not at an angle to see the impregnation themed tattoos that you and Anna were showing off now that you started riding the cocks of the two guys on the loveseat with you, reverse-cowgirl style. Otherwise, they might be more apprehensive about the throbbing dicks being lined up with their own pussies.

Who's the first to get a creampie?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)