Time for the talk

The two of you dry off and get dressed in the bedroom (your clothes became visible when you did earlier). Elena is done first and leaves the room. From the kitchen, you can hear the sound of the coffee machine brewing and the clanging of mugs being taken from a cabinet.

When you join Elena in the kitchen, she's sipping from the mug at the counter. The other mug is across from her and you take your place there.

After standing there in silence together for a couple of minutes, Elena asks, "So. Who are you?"

You're surprised at how calm her demeanor is, given what has happened to her since last night. You get ready to activate your magic rings, but decide to hold off on any additional use of magic unless you need to. Or if Elena tries to kill you.

You take a deep breath and take the plunge. You know you'd screwed up, but you really like Elena. If she can't handle the truth, you can make her. You also need someone to share your secret with. You tell her everything that has transpired since you came into possession of the magic rings a few days ago. She glances at the trinkets on your fingers briefly, but her focus stays on you. You decide not to leave out anything, including the blackmailing for the job, the mansion, and Olivia. And last night.

Throughout the conversation, you can't read Elena's expression. It's completely neutral. When you finish, you say, "So that's it..."

A long pause.

"That.... was you last night?" she asks quietly.

"Yes."

"Why did you **** me?"

"I... I... I couldn't help myself. I know that it was wrong, but you looked so beautiful and I just couldn't resist. I'm sorry."

She's stunned. She just had sex with her assaulter within half a day.

"Will you forgive me?" you ask.