Doh, he’s not totally stupid

“Ok, look, I’m not stupid,” Tommy answered. “Sure I want to stay. But I’m already late getting back to work.”

“Here’s what you need to do, Tommy,” I told him. “Call your store and tell them you made the delivery but got a flat tire and will be back as soon as you can get it changed. “That’ll work, won’t it?”

“Yeah, it might,” he agreed. He retrieved his phone from his jeans on the floor and called in and gave them his story. Apparently they bought it. “Ok, so now what?” he asked.

“Now we get to share the girls,” I grinned. “You get two and I get two. Then we fuck them or have them do whatever we want them to do. You’ll find they’re pretty agreeable.”

The four girls positioned themselves in a nice line in front of us, all still totally naked, of course (in case you have forgotten… lol). The night had gotten so wild that they were all ready and willing to keep playing our sex games.

“So let me see, I’m usually pretty good with names and faces,” he smiled. “Or in this case tits and asses,” he laughed. “So I think we have Susie,” he pointed to the left, “then Carly, Amy and Beth. Did I get them right?”

“Yes,” the girls all giggled and wiggled their hot little bodies for him.

“So who do you want?” I asked.

Tommy looked them all up and down again, carefully studying their boobs and pussies. They watched him looking at them and they turned around simultaneously without him even asking to show him their hot little asses too.

“Mmmm. this is better than the lunch buffet, like the best buffet in the world. Well, definitely Susie there on the end, she’s got a perfect bod. And I guess I’ll go with Beth on the other end, she’s a little skinny but has nice tits.”

The girls giggled and Susie and Beth moved over to stand on either side of him. He put his arms around their bare waists.

“I guess that leaves Amy and Carly for me,” I smiled, moving over to the two girls and putting my arms around them. “Which is cool because these two are my favorites,” I smiled at each of them and gave them a squeeze. “Besides, Susie is my sister and I’ve probably fucked her enough already tonight.”

Tommy looked at my sister then back at me with wide eyes. “Wow, man. You guys really are a wild bunch, aren’t you?” The girls all giggled yet again.

“Come on, let’s go back to the rec room and have some fun,” I said.

I lead the way with Amy and Carly on my arms and Tommy followed right behind with Susie and Beth. Tommy didn’t waste any time, pushing my sister down onto the couch on her back. Then he jumped between her legs and spread them wide open to enjoy the view. My sister batted her eyes at him and licked her lips, as if he needed any further enticement.

“No offense, Beth, but I just gotta have me some of this guy’s hot sister first.” He bent down and actually kissed Susie first then took hold of her hips and guided his hard meat into her soft folds. “Uhhhhh,” he grunted. “God that feels so good.” He started pistoning back and forth in obvious enjoyment. “Hey,” he motioned to Beth. “Come over here in front of us so I can play with your pretty boobs while I fuck her.”

Tommy stretched out his hands and began mauling Beth’s full round boobs but he was buried too deep in my sister’s cunny to be able to reach them with his mouth.

Meanwhile, Amy and Carly had already noted my preferences and had gotten down on the floor on all fours with the asses pointing at me and wiggling them invitingly. My cock was still rock hard from jerking while watching them seduce Tommy, so I didn’t hesitate to plunge it straight into Amy’s warm kitty while reaching over and sliding a couple of fingers up into Carly. After a minute I pulled my dick out of Amy and plunged it into Carly’s hot cunt while fingering Amy now.

“God, I can’t believe I’m fucking some guy’s sister right in front of him!” Tommy exclaimed as he pumped faster and harder inside Susie’s love hole. “I wish my sister was this hot!” He paused for a moment as he tried to drive his steel rod right through Susie’s body. “Well, actually she is pretty damn hot too, I just wish I could fuck her like this too. You sure this is really your sister?”

“Oh yeah, she’s my hot little sister all right,” I confirmed. “But I think you need a little help there, my friend. I think my sister needs to be spit-roasted. “If you’ll excuse me, girls,” I addressed Amy and Carly, “I’m going to lend my services to Tommy and Susie for a moment.”

I got up and went to the end of the couch above Susie’s head, moving Beth aside. “Maybe you girls could get Tommy to lick your pretty pussies while I feed my meat to Susie,” I suggested. I moved forward right against the sofa and my bobbing cock hung right in front of her face. “Suck my cock, sis,” I ordered her. She grabbed my thick meat with one hand and pulled it against her lips. Then she slowly sucked it in until she had my whole length inside her warm wet mouth. “Ummm, that feels good, Susie,” I moaned. “What do you think, Tommy, does my little sister feel good or what?”

Tommy had difficulty answering as his mouth was sucking on Beth’s pussy. “Umm, yeah,” he agreed. Amy playfully pushed Beth aside and bent over in front of Tommy's face, shaking her ass, her pussy poking out between her cheeks. Tommy obliged by squeezing her ass with one hand and slipping his tongue into her tight pudenda. I felt my balls tighten and knew I was about to shoot a load.

“I’m almost there, man,” I told him. “You ready?”

“God yeah. I don’t think I can hold back any longer.

“Ok, let’s do it!” I started coming inside Susie’s mouth and saw Tommy's hips jerking as he started coming inside her pussy. Susie thrashed and moaned loudly and her body started shaking as her orgasm hit her too. We both pulled out and sprayed her from both ends with the final jets of our combined jizz.

Everybody sort of collapsed where they were. Tommy was breathing heavily from the unexpected exercise and release. “Wow, that was hot,” he said between breaths. “It sure would be hot if we did my sister like that too. But I’ve never even seen her naked. But god, that would be a trip!”

“Is your sister as hot as Susie?” I asked.

“Oh yeah, pretty much,” he replied. “Here, I’ve got a pic of her on my phone.” He scrambled for his phone and hit a few buttons then handed it to me. “That’s her at the beach last summer.”

Oh yeah, she was a cutie all right. Long wavy blonde hair on a petite frame, probably shorter than any of the girls here. But with nice-sized tits and a nice booty to boot.

“What’s her name?” I asked. I wasn’t sure why I was looking at another girl with four naked hotties already surrounding me. But hey, you can never get too much of a good thing, right?

“Jenny,” he answered.

“What do you think she’s up to tonight? Why don’t you call her and invite her over?” I suggested.