Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by LiteraryLover LiteraryLover

What to do now? Fuck Heather, have everyone eat together as nude friends or fuck Rachel's ass?

Take a short break

(A/N: creative criticism in the comments as well as chapter additions are both welcome and encouraged)

My stomach growled and I saw my birthday cake had still gone uneaten. "How does everyone feel about eating some cake really quick?" I ask.

Jess pulls herself away from Rachel's pussy "That sounds good." Rachel agrees as does Melissa and Heather. Melissa walks to the kitchen to get my candles and a lighter and I can't help but stare at her beautiful thick bubble butt. She returns and bends over in front of me to put the candles in and light them, giving me a front and center view of her pussy lips and asshole. In a split second impulse, I grab a few of the small and thin candles, putting them into Melissa's free asshole, her only response is to giggle. When she's done, she hands me the cake and tells me to make a wish as her and the others sing me happy birthday.

A wish? I'm already surrounded by my four best friends who are naked and totally willing to do whatever I ask of them. The only thing I could wish for is 'Make this last more than one night.' I wish as I blow out my candles.

Me and my naked friends sit down and eat, having normal conversation almost like we weren't all naked at all, as if Jess didn't still have globs of cum on her and Melissa wasn't housing birthday candles up her ass. "Melissa, rub your strawberry on your pussy and eat it and then put some frosting on your pussy and have Heather lick it off." I watch as Melissa takes the strawberry from on top of her slice and rubs it up her slit coating with her juices before eating it, then smears frosting from top of her cake onto her pussy lips. Heather then walked over to her sister and knelt down, and began to lick the combination of frosting and pussy juices off. As I whatched I began to grow hard again as any man would. Maybe cake would have to wait for just now.

Fuck Heather from behind or Jess says your wish comes true?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)