Amy

It still took me a while to come to my senses. What could possibly be hotter than fucking my sister? Well, it couldn’t really involve either me or her, so I had to come up with something new for my sister’s three bff’s. Finally, an idea came to me, going somewhere we hadn’t gone yet tonight.

“Amy!” I announced. "I dare you to kiss and lick Beth’s and Carly’s asses and finger fuck their asses with two fingers for two minutes. Then they each have to do the same to you.”

There was an audible gasp from all four of the girls in the room. Which was immediately followed by more giggling.

“God, David, are you some kind of a pervert or something?” Amy shot back at me. “You been watching too may pornos? You really think we would do something like that?”

“Hey, a dare’s a dare,” I came back just as quick. “Nobody set any limits. What’s the matter? You girls aren’t anal virgins, are you?” More goddam giggling. Good thing I was getting used to it.

“Well, what about Susie?” Amy asked. “Why isn’t she included in this little asshole dare?”

“I think we can all agree that she and I need to rest for a little bit right now,” I pointed out. “After all, we did give each other quite a workout there,” I grinned. “So if you other girls have to do two minutes each on each of the other two girls, that should give us at least eight minutes to rest. So you have to go first, Amy, since you’re the daree. I’ll keep the time.”

Amy sighed and gave me a dirty look but turned to Beth sitting next to her. “So I guess you need to turn around and show me your ass, girlfriend,” she told her.

“My pleasure,” Beth replied. “I’ve always liked having my ass played with.” The other girls giggled, my sister included.

“Yeah, we know what a horn dog you are, Beth,” Susie laughed.

Beth turned around sort of kneeling on the sofa with her ass up in the air. Amy got down on her knees on the floor in front of her. She looked back over her shoulder at me. “Ready to start the timer?” she asked.

“Just a minute,” I stopped her. “You’re kind of far away, you know. It’s my dare so I think I should get a better look. Why don’t you get down on the floor here in front of my chair? I want a better view of Beth’s tight little ass.”

Amy shot me another dirty look but both girls got up and positioned themselves in front of me as I had requested. I nodded at Amy and started the timer on my phone.

Amy bent her head forward and started tonguing Beth's cute round ass. She licked all over both cheeks then she rimmed her asshole with her tongue. She spit onto her little pucker and spread the wetness around her tight hole. Then she pushed one finger into the tight brownie working it back and forth until it started to loosen up a little. Then she **** a second finger in. I could tell it was really tight. Obviously, I was already stroking my still rigid rod. Watching Amy work Beth’s ass like that was really really hot. As Amy penetrated Beth’s hole she resumed licking and kissing her ass cheeks, alternating between the two. Beth was moaning softly, obviously enjoying the attention.

“Yeah, I can tell that neither one of you have any experience with this,” I said sarcastically. “By the way, time’s up. Next!”

Amy withdrew her fingers and actually put them in her mouth while Beth reluctantly got up from the floor. Carly got up from the sofa as she sat back down. She got down on all fours in front of me with Amy lined up behind her full round ass.

“Actually, I really haven’t done this before,” she looked at me.

“Just relax, is all you have to do,” I instructed her. “Maybe you’ll find out you like it.”

Amy bent forward and started licking and kissing Carly’s ass like she had done to Beth. Carly wiggled her ass a little and went “mmmm.” Apparently she liked it so far. Amy slid her fingers back and forth in her crack, then slid them forward and discovered her slit was wet. She stuck two fingers into her cunt, using her cunt juice as a lubricant for Carly’s asshole. Apparently, Carly wasn’t as tight as she thought because Amy was able to get two fingers in rather easily. Carly squealed a little at the first penetration but then relaxed and seemed to be enjoying it. Unfortunately, I had to call “time!” again.

Carly got up and went back to the sofa. Amy started to get up too. “All done, right?”

“Hold on just a minute. You’re only half done. Now each one of them gets to play with your ass. Get back down on all fours.”

She frowned slightly but did as she was told. Actually I think she was turned on from playing with the other two girls’ asses. It looked like her pussy was a little shiny from moisture.

“Ok, Beth. You’re up.”

Beth got up from the sofa and knelt behind Amy’s smooth ass. She started giving her the same treatment she had been given. She licked and kissed all over her round butt, getting it slippery wet. Then I noticed Carly getting up. They were going to double-team Amy. Wasn’t exactly the way the dare went but I wasn’t going to complain. Beth kept planting tons of tiny kisses on Amy’s right cheek while Carly went to work on her left. Then Beth stuck two fingers into Carly’s mouth to get them wet before plunging them into Amy’s tight asshole. While she was busy pumping in and out of her brownie, Carly stuck her fingers in Beth’s mouth and got them wet too. The next time Beth pulled her fingers out of Amy’s butthole, Carly rammed her fingers in instead. They started alternating back and forth that way, taking turns finger fucking her now stretched asshole.

I was busy stroking my long rod, this was a really exciting sight. I was afraid I was going to cum before they were finished. I looked at my phone and realized I wasn’t sure whether to call time after two minutes or four minutes. But I guess it didn’t matter anyway. I had been so busy getting myself off and enjoying the show that actually five minutes had passed already.

“Time!” I called out with shortened breath. The three girls looked over at me, all three of them now on their knees facing me. “That was so fucking hot, girls! I’m going to cum!”

None of them moved, if anything they leaned in closer. My cock erupted like Mount Vesuvius as it sent rope after rope of my steaming hot jizz straight out in front of me landing all over all three of their faces. It was probably my biggest load of the night yet. My cum was dripping from their foreheads and noses down onto their chests and tits. As soon as I had finished they all started giggling uncontrollably. I couldn’t help but actually join them.

Their giggling finally subsided, then they began to clean themselves up. They started by using their fingers to wipe their own faces and suck my jizz off their fingers, but then they started licking each other’s faces. That was so fucking hot too that I started getting hard again.

Finally, they went back to the sofa and just sat there with vacant looks on their faces. I looked over at my sister and she was just sitting there grinning. “Did you enjoy the show, sis?” I asked her. She spread her legs and pushed her pussy lips apart with her fingers and I could see how wet she was too.

Amy, next to my sister, spoke up. “So I guess I get to pick someone now, right? Gee, who can I pick who hasn’t been involved in the recent activity?” she asked in an innocent tone, looking straight at Susie. “Hmmm, I just don’t know….”