Ellie goes upstairs to get something.

"Now what?" Loretta whines. "Amie and I still haven't been fucked yet!"

"Don't worry, sweetie, we have all night," you assure her. You wish you could stay hard for hours and take all five girls at once but fantasize all you want the reality is that you have your limits to your stamina.

"Wait here," Ellie pipes up and dashes up the stairs.

"Where is she going?" the young Asian girl asks.

"I think she's going to get her toys," Connie suggests and as if on cue her sister's footsteps is heard.

"Ta-da!" the bartender cheers, appearing back in the rec room with a nondescript cardboard box and places it on the coffee table. The girls circle around the table as Ellie opens up the box with a proud smile.

"That's a nice collection of dildos," Val compliments, taking out a massively long and thick black plastic cock. She winks at you and mumbles, "I prefer the real thing though."

"So do I but your father isn't the town sheriff," Ellie replies, sticking her tongue out while she takes out a small vibrator.

"What's this?" Loretta asks, picking up a long double ended dildo. "How's does this fit all in me?"

"It doesn't, honey," Ellie answers. "You stick it in both you and another girl."

"At the same time?" the blonde gasps. You smile that despite being a nymphomaniac now she is still naive and innocent in certain things.

"Why don't you and Connie try it out?" Val suggests. The younger redhead blushes to almost the same color as her hair. She looks at you and you nod in approval. Of course you have no opposition to seeing the two girls fucking each other knowing full well their lesbian encounter in the barn last night!

The two girls giggle uncontrollably as they walk to the sheepskin rug and lie in front of you, facing each other. "Let me help," you offer, taking the dildo in your hand and slipping one end into Connie's wet snatch and then the other end into Loretta's hungry pussy. The girls' nervous laughter turns into moans as they experiment by gyrating and thrusting their hips.

You feel your cock tingle back to life as you watch the two best friends fuck each other.

"What about this, Amy?" Ellie suggests, showing the petite Chinese girl a short but thick dildo.

"No," Amie shakes her head and looks at you. "I want the first cock in me to be a real cock."

"You're still a virgin?" Val gasps, hugging the Asian girl. "There's no shame in that, honey!"

"My father wants me to wait until I'm married," Amy whispers.

"So did our dad," Ellie said, looking down at her sister.

"Mine too," Loretta moans. "But John took my virginity last night."

"Our virginity," Connie corrected as she rubbed her clit. "He fucked me for hours last night."

The other girls stare at the redhead on the revelation and then to you. You cannot help but grin at your newfound reputation.

"Well, he is an amazing fuck," Val laughs, trying on a strap-on dildo and pushes Ellie over one of the armrest of the chair.

"He has a nice thick cock too," Ellie agrees then grunts when she feels the dildo suddenly fills her cunt.

Amie looks at your rejuvenated erection nervously now that the other four girls are occupied.

"Shall we go upstairs to a bedroom?" you ask, offering your hand to her.