Wager fulfilled

When the three of them walked into the Dawkins house they found that no one was at home, which is a good thing for them. Patrick, Marybeth and Faith made their way up to Marybeth’s room and closed the door behind them. Patrick wasn’t surprised that Marybeth and Faith started to kiss as soon as he turned around. The two of them had built up so much sexual tension during the mini-golf game that he knew that they were just waiting to get their hands on each other. Plus, it was a hot scene watching both of them making out.

The two girls started to get rid of their clothes and so did Patrick while he continued watching them. Soon all three of them were naked and he loved the way that Faith’s lean frame looked with her c cups and thick athletic ass. He couldn’t take his eyes off of Marybeth either. Her tits looked even larger when she wasn’t wearing clothes and her ass rivaled only Sasha’s when, which was the best ass he had before tonight.

“Are you going to join us or what?” Marybeth asked.

Patrick looked up at Marybeth’s face and smiled. “Yeah. I was just enjoying the view.” Patrick said as he walked up to his two naked girlfriends and Marybeth pulled him into a kiss first and he had to admit that this was an even better kiss than the one that they had shared on the couch earlier that day. Soon enough, he pulled back and turned to Faith and the two of them started making out. Patrick knew that she wasn’t as experienced as Marybeth, but who was? She was in a league of her own really.

“God, this is so hot.” Marybeth said as she watched the other two making out and started to stroke Patrick’s cock so that she knew that he was hard for Faith when they both started fucking her.

“Tell me about it.” Patrick said as he pulled back for a breath of air.

Marybeth went back to kissing Patrick and Faith dropped to her knees and took Patrick’s cock into her mouth. Faith was amazed at how Sasha had been able to take all of Patrick’s cock the other night. She was only able to take a little over half of it, but it was having the desired effect as Patrick was moaning in pleasure into Marybeth’s mouth.

“That’s right, baby, suck our man’s cock.” Marybeth said.

After a few more bobs of her head, Faith pulled away from Patrick’s cock and switched up with Marybeth. Marybeth was a very good cock sucker and she was taking Patrick all the way into her mouth and down her throat from the beginning. If Patrick didn’t have good stamina, watching his old crush blow him might have sent him over the edge right then and there.

To their surprise, Marybeth pulled away from Patrick’s cock but continued to stroke him. She moved her face over to Marybeth and started to eat her pussy so that she was nice and wet.

“Oh yes! Just like that!” Faith moaned into Patrick’s mouth as the two of them continued to kiss.

Marybeth also had her free hand between her legs and was getting herself wet as well. She was looking forward to railing Faith, but she was looking forward to what was going to happen after that even more. She wanted Patrick’s big cock inside of her as soon as possible. She turned back to Patrick and started to suck his cock again and he moaned into Faith’s mouth.

“Fuck! So good!” Patrick moaned into Faith’s mouth.

Marybeth soon pulled away from Patrick’s cock again and then she gave him a kiss and Faith one as well. “Let’s get this party started. You two can start while I’m getting ready.” Marybeth said as she walked over to one of her drawers and got something out.

Patrick and Faith made it to the bed and Patrick got on first and got on his back. He figured Faith would want to be on top of him during the double penetration. Faith then straddled him and reached down to grab his cock and line it up with her pussy so that she could sink down onto it while the two of them were kissing.

Faith started to move hard and fast in the way that she was riding Patrick. She wasn’t in this for intimacy yet. That would come later if this relationship worked out. Right now she just wanted to cum.

“Oh fuck! Right there!” Faith moaned.

Patrick and Faith kept on fucking for a minute longer and then they felt the bed shift a bit and saw Marybeth climb up on the bed. She then crawled up behind Faith and lined the lubed up cock that was about the size of Patrick's with Faith’s asshole and started to push in. “Please try to take it easy. This is my first double penetration.

“You got it, baby!” Marybeth said as the fake cock finally made its entrance into Faith's back hole.

Faith groaned as it hurt a bit, but it wasn’t too bad as Marybeth pushed further and further inside of her. Once she was as deep as she could go, Marybeth pulled out most of the cock and then pushed it back in. She and Patrick built up a rhythm and soon Faith was feeling nothing but pleasure now.

“Oh fuck! So tight!” Patrick moaned as Faith became even tighter than she was earlier because of the other cock.

“Fuck yeah. Her ass is so tight. I’m almost having a problem moving inside of her.” Marybeth said.

Marybeth was still moving slowly inside of Faith’s ass so that she could get used to things, but soon she was going to speed things up and see what her new favorite ass could take. She didn’t want to turn her off to the situation though, so she would wait for as long as she could.

Patrick was thrusting up into Faith’s pussy and she looked so good with Marybeth on top of her fucking her as well. He thought about it and wondered why he hadn’t tried to fuck Marybeth earlier. He knew that she would have let him. It was like a lot of wasted time on his part, but right now he was fucking his hot dancer so that is what he was going to focus on.

Faith was in a state of bliss now as she was loving both of her holes being filled for the first time. Faith was pretty much at their mercy, so she just laid on Patrick’s chest and let the other two take her holes in any way they wanted.

“Fuck! I’m close!” Faith moaned and that was all that Marybeth needed to hear as she sped up her pace along with Patrick.

The two of her were fucking her hard and fast now and Faith soon crossed the line of no return and she came hard for both of them. Patrick even felt himself getting wet while Faith was cumming too.

“Oh shit! I’m cumming!” Faith moaned as she came hard and squirted all over Patrick’s cock and abs.

Patrick and Marybeth continued to fuck Faith through her orgasm. When she came down from her high, the two of them slowed down and nodded to each other as they pulled the cock out of Faith and helped to flip her around so that Patrick could now fuck her ass and Marybeth fuck her pussy. The two of them lined their cocks up with her again and pushed in with no trouble this time.

“Yes! Fuck me!” Faith moaned out as both of them started to fuck her hard.

She loved the way that both of them were fucking her hard right now that she was used to everything. She also liked the way that Patrick had his arms wrapped around her from behind which made her feel safe in this situation.

Patrick couldn’t help but feel the end coming for him right now. Faith’s ass was so tight that he just couldn’t help it. He still had some time left, but he knew that his time was running out though. He would take advantage of the time he had though and fuck the shit out of Faith’s ass while he could.

Marybeth loved looking down on her two lovers whose faces were contorted in pleasure like they were both getting ready to cum. It was unfortunate that she wasn’t feeling the pleasure that they were, but she would be soon and she was looking forward to that.

“Such a nice pussy.” Marybeth said as she reached down and started to rub Faith’s clit as well.

“Oh fuck! So good!” Faith moaned as Marybeth rubbed her clit.

“I’m getting close!” Patrick moaned.

“Me too!” Faith moaned.

Patrick and Marybeth continued to fuck Faith in her holes. It only took another minute or two and Faith fell over the edge and came hard as she squirted up toward Marybeth. “Oh God! I’m cumming!” Faith moaned as she shot a bit of squirt all the way up to Marybeth’s big tits.

The way that she clamped down on him, Patrick couldn’t last any longer. The next thing he knew, he was cumming deep inside of Faith’s ass hole. Once he had finished cumming and both he and Marybeth knew that Faith had come down from her high, Marybeth pulled away from Faith and then helped Patrick move Faith off of him so that she could relax as she was just about passed out right now.

Marybeth then came over to Patrick and took his cock in her mouth. She loved the way that it tasted of Faith’s ass and it turned her on that she was tasting such a hot girl's ass. It didn’t take much longer for Marybeth to get Patrick hard, so when he was rock hard again, she pulled back and got on her hands and knees with her ass turned toward him.

Patrick got up from his laying position and moved up behind Marybeth and lined his cock up with her wet pussy and pushed in. Marybeth’s eyes opened wide. She knew that Patrick was big, but it felt even bigger when it was inside of her.

“Oh god! So big!” Marybeth moaned as Patrick gave it to her hard and fast. He had plenty of time left now that he had his stamina back and it also helped that he had already cummed to.

Patrick had been dreaming of doing this for his whole life and now that he was getting his chance, he wasn’t going to let anything get in his way of pleasuring his biggest crush from his youth. He was in a position that many guys would love to be in so he wasn’t going to take it for granted.

“Fuck! So good!” Patrick moaned.

Marybeth had to admit it. Patrick was really good. Not that it should have surprised her, being that he had three girlfriends and what looked like it would be five after tonight. She had made a good decision obviously by picking Patrick. Would she settle down now? Hell no, but she could see it happening sooner or later. She wasn’t in a hurry for that though.

“Right there, baby! That’s the spot!” Marybeth moaned

As much as Patrick was loving fucking Marybeth’s pussy, he wanted in her thick ass even more. He pulled out of her pussy and Marybeth moaned in disappointment until she felt him line up with her ass. Marybeth looked over her shoulder and smirked at him, which was enough for Patrick to know she was ready. He pushed forward and entered her ass pretty easily.

“Damn, you’re tight!” Patrick moaned, even though it wasn’t hard for him to push inside of her, she was still tight.

“Fuck yeah! Stretch my ass, baby!” Marybeth moaned and since she asked, he gave her what she wanted and fucked her ass hard.

Patrick knew that he wasn’t going to last much longer because of the speed he was fucking Marybeth and how tight she was around his cock. He was giving her everything he had right now and he hoped that she was getting close too.

Marybeth knew she wasn’t going to last much longer either so she reached her hand back to her pussy and started to rub her clit which gave her even more pleasure. Marybeth also started thrusting back into Patrick which brought both of them even more pleasure.

“Oh yes! I’m close!” Marybeth moaned a minute later.

“Me too!” Patrick moaned.

They kept going at it just like they had been and it only took them about another two minutes and then they were both cumming together.

“Oh fuck! I’m cumming!” Patrick moaned as he filled up Marybeth’s ass.

“I’m cumming!” Marybeth moaned as she came hard when she felt Patrick’s cum splashing all over the walls of her asshole.

Marybeth collapsed on her stomach and Patrick pulled out of her and laid down beside Faith who was watching them closely as they fucked.

“Damn, that was hot.” Faith said and Patrick rolled so that he could kiss her.

Not long after, Marybeth had moved to his other side and they were all laying on the pillows. He turned her way and kissed her as well. He soon laid down on his back and he wrapped each of his arms around his girls and pulled them close so that they were all comfortable.

“Good night.” Faith said as she was already falling asleep.

“Good night.” Patrick said as he kissed her head and then turned to Marybeth and kissed her again and then said, “Good night.”

“Good night.” Marybeth said as she kissed him back as her eyelids started to sag closed as well.

Soon after, both of the girls were sleeping and Patrick smiled to himself. “Two more girls to the harem.” Patrick thought to himself as he fell into a deep sleep as well.