Amy’s wish is your command

Amy bends over the copier, skirt rucked up around her waist, soaked panties pulled to the side. Her perfect ass and dripping pussy are on full display. You don’t hesitate. You free your cock again and push into her in one smooth thrust, groaning at how unbelievably wet and hot she is.

“Fuck, Amy… you’re soaked,” you grunt, gripping her hips and starting to pound her hard, just like she demanded.

She moans loudly, pushing back against you. But after only a few deep strokes, something feels… off. Different.

You slow down, confused. There’s an unusual firmness inside her.

“Amy… what the -?”

She looks back over her shoulder with a wicked, almost shy smile you’ve never seen on her before.

“Keep going,” she whispers. “Feel it.”

You thrust again, deeper, and that’s when you feel it - something hard, thick, and unmistakably there, pressing against your cock through the thin wall separating her pussy from her ass.

Amy reaches back, grabs your hand, and guides your fingers to her asshole. Your eyes widen as you feel the flared base of a massive, heavy butt plug stretching her tight ring.

“I put it in this morning,” she confesses, voice trembling with lust and embarrassment. “It’s been inside me all day. Every time I sat down, every time I crossed my legs in front of you… it was pressing deeper. I’ve been clenching around it for hours thinking about you.”

You groan at the filthy revelation and start fucking her harder, your cock rubbing against the huge plug with every thrust.

But that’s not the real twist.

Amy bites her lip, eyes glassy, and drops the bomb.

“…And it’s not empty.”

You freeze mid-thrust.

“What?”

“I filled it,” she whispers, almost whimpering as you start moving again. “It’s a hollow plug. I pumped warm cum into it before work. It’s been slowly leaking into my ass every time I moved. I’ve been walking around the bullpen all day with another man’s load slowly filling my ass while I smiled at you.”

Your cock throbs violently inside her.

“Whose?” you ask, voice hoarse.

Amy’s pussy clenches hard around you. She looks back with a dirty, guilty little smile.

“Captain Holt’s.”

The words hit you like a freight train. Your straight-laced, rule-obsessed girlfriend has had Raymond Holt’s cum plugged deep in her ass the entire day.

Before you can even process it, Amy pushes back onto you harder.

“I let him fuck me in his office before the morning briefing,” she moans, voice shaking. “He bent me over his desk and came in my ass… then plugged it. He told me to keep it inside all day like a good little detective.”

She reaches back and spreads her ass wider, showing you the thick black base of the plug.

“Now fuck me while his cum is still inside me, Jake. I want you to feel it when you cum.”

The twisted revelation breaks something in you. You slam into her pussy like an animal, the plug making her unbelievably tight as you fuck her right next to the warm copies slowly printing out underneath her.

Amy cums hard within seconds, shaking and moaning your name while her holes clench around both your cock and Holt’s plug.