They Argue

Haley was still flustered and confused, but when Alex started to move to straddle me she pushed Alex aside "Me first."

Alex smiled to herself, it had worked. Haley straddles my waist, grabbing my cock and lining it up to her pussy. She had it at her opening, slowly lowering herself on my cock. Alex knelt beside her, help her keep her balance.

Haley's eyes went wide as she felt my cock enter her. She was about to scream. Alex lifted a tit and put it in her mouth. Haley took in, screaming into her younger sister massive tit.

Haley, with Alex's help, started to ride my cock, her orgasm building. Alex was rubbing her clit as Haley sucked on her tit.

After few minutes, Haley was about to exploded. She lost complete control. She flung her head back as she impaled herself on my cock and came hard and long.

She came down from the massive orgasm, her head coming back to face me. Then she notice that I was wide awake, my arm around Penny, who was also awake, on her side, staring at Haley riding my cock. Alex was still helping her with her balance, now with a shit eating grin on her face.

"Oh god. What did I do."

"From what I saw, you had one hell of an orgasm." Penny said. "Can't blame you, that cock's made me cum several times."

"Me too" Alex said

"What? You what?"

Alex moved closer to her sister's head "He fucked my brains out this afternoon, with that busty blond, Bernie. It was incredible. Told me if I did this, he would fuck me again, so I agreed."

"What?"

Alex pulled Haley off my cock, laid her on the bed beside me. She looked at all of us, so confused, but too tired to move. Alex knelt between her legs and moved her mouth to her well fucked pussy.

"Now, I am going to fuck Alex, because she was an obedient little slut. She is going to eat your cunt. I'm going to fuck all three of you all night, unless you want to leave. I'm good with just fucking the two of them.

Haley was too far gone. She pulled me in for a kiss, a long passionate one. She moved Alex's head into her crotch. "You promise to fuck me again?"

"Just do everything I tell you."

She nodded and I got behind Alex's plump little ass and started to fuck her. Penny leaned into Haley and kissed her.

As promised I fucked them all, all night. I came twice in the bed, first on Alex's tits, then on Haley's face, and again in the shower, on all three faces, before we all went to sleep naked.

As I lay in bed, Alex on side, Haley on the other, Penny spooning Haley, I felt like I was in heaven.