Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by gscmar64 gscmar64

What Do I Tell Her?

Confrontation And Acknowledgement

Now I could have lied to her and said no, I could have turned her question back on her just by asking her what made her think that. But no i was actually quite proud of the fact that I fucked her, so I answered her question with one of my own, that caused her to lose all colour.

“When you say last night, do you mean at the frat party or before you woke up just now?”

Sadie blanched at that, so I knew it would be wrong to gloat about having sex with her but it was just such a perfect time to tell her that we crossed the friendship line, no make that nuked the line.

“Absolute truth Sadie, I didn’t know it was you at the frat party when I fucked you but before you passed out in your room I tried your pussy out again!” Then just to add shock value to my confession, “And I have to say I liked it as much as you liked it!”

Anger flared in Sadie’s eyes, her hands balled up into fists. With anger in her voice, “You fucked me when I was unable to defend myself, and there would be not way that I would let you fuck me again, so you must have taken advantage of me and basically **** me you fucking bastard!”

“Oh yeah and tell me how are you going to prove that when I play the recording of you screaming, “OH GOD YOU’RE SO FUCKING GOOD!”

Sadie still had a look of anger in her eyes but that was being replaced slowly with acknowledgement. Then anger once more. “You’re lying, you would never record me without asking my permission!”

“Hey whatever gets you through the day, Sadie!” Then I played a card that I never had any reason to use before. “But tell me what do you think your mom and dad will think when they hear you saying that?”

Sadie froze on the spot, then exactly what I expected to hear, “You wouldn’t dare!” Then as if answering her own statement, “Fuck you have always seemed to be the type to do anything to get your own way!” I have no idea where that came from! But if she decided to believe that then who was I to argue, as long as It got me back into her pussy!

Sadie lowered her eyes, staring at the floor in front of her, “Let me guess as long as I spread my legs for you, you’ll keep quiet?”

Pressing My Advantage!

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)