A taste of the forbidden fruit

"What took you so damn long?" Olive asked. Dangerously close to breaking the fourth wall.

"I was... uhh... there was a line..." I sat back down at the table. Eyes glued to Candi and my sister.

Candi was still holding her. Squeezing her tight against her chest. Working her cum covered tongue deep into Sam's mouth. Forcing her to taste my seed. To taste her own brother's freshly sucked out load. In public, with all of her friends watching.

God this was so fucked up. So what did it say about me? That I couldn't take my eyes away from them. There was this mixing of thrill and guilt swirling around inside me. Each one making the other more intense. I hadn't known Candi was going to do something this fucked up... but if I had? Would I have stopped her? I honestly didn't know.

"I ordered you a cheese burger, with no pickles, extra onions and a heaping load of ketchup!" Tandi said. Leaning in close enough to me that I could feel her breath of my cheeks. "From your aura, it seemed like you would want that."

"That... that actually is what I wanted." The surprising accuracy of her prediction was enough to make me turn to look at her. "How the hell did you know that?"

"Like I said." She ran her finger over my chin. Smiling at me. "Your aura told me~"

"She asked Sam what you liked while you were gone." Olive said. Taking a bite out of her burger.

"Olliveee!" Tandi groaned. "Don't spoil the magic!"

"He just looked like he was actually going to believe you is all." Olive tried to hide a smile behind the burger she held in her hands.

"Yeah I probably would have..." I admitted.

"You're ruining my credibility." Tandi pouted.

"I can't have you corrupting such an innocent, gullible mind." Olive said. Leaning back, she turned to look at Candi and Sam. "Are you two planning on joining us, like, ever?"

Still making out with my sister, Candi raised her middle finger at Olive as an answer. But still broke off the kiss a moment later. Wiping away the heavy amount of drool that covered her mouth.

"Just giving my girlfriend a taste of something sweet." Candi smirked. Moving across the table, she pushed me to the side, against Tandi. Claiming the spot next to me.

"Take a seat, sweeite." Candi told Sam with an overly sugary voice. "Or was the taste on my tongue so good it's left you paralysed?"

I couldn't help but notice the choice of her words. The taste on her tongue. Not of. She was directly asking her if the taste of my cum was good, without any of the others realising it.

Wordlessly, with clenched fists, Sam sat down across from us. Glaring at me with murderous intent.

I picked up my burger and took a bite. Looking away. I wasn't sure I regretted letting Candi suck me off in the bathroom, but I didn't still feel some guilt about it.

"Answer the question babe." Candi said, more firmly than before.

"You tasted fine." Sam crossed her arms and furrowed her brows. Glaring at Candi now.

"Just fine?" Candi pushed her. "Be honest puppy."

The fury on her face cracked a little. Her pale cheeks beginning to lightly blush pink. She broke off her stare and looked at the ground, her voice barely above a whisper.

"It was... it wasn't bad..." She admitted.

"Be more honest." Candi licked her lips. Gleefully twisting and toying with her emotions. "Tell us how you really-"

"Oh my fucking god!" Olive pounded the table. "Would you two just shut the fuck up and eat already. Do you have to do this fetish shit during lunch?"

"Someone's feeling a little feisty today, don't you think so Finn?" Candi rubbed shoulders with me. Moving in as close as Tandi had. Forcing my sister to watch us from across the table.

"I don't really umm..." I gulped. Suddenly feeling like I was caught in the spiders web. Surrounded on all sides by varying degrees of unhinged women. "Don't really know her well enough to say..."

"Hmm..." Candi leaned back and started eating her own lunch. While Olive and Tandi started discussing some Anime they were watching, Candi seemed to notice that Sam hadn't touched her food yet.

"What's the matter little puppy? Not hungry? Did you fill up on something thick and delicious already?" She innocently smiled at her. "Or maybe you just want to keep a certain taste in your mouth?"

Sam started to say something, but stopped herself. Swiping her drink, she started sucking on the straw forcefully.

"Oh look at that." Candi said to me, gesturing to Sam. "I think she's trying to show off..."

"Okay!" I blurted out. "I think maybe we should all just-"

Mid sentence, I nearly jolted high enough to knock the table over as I felt Candi squeeze my thigh.

"What the fuck is wrong with you." Sam snarled. Using my speech flub as an excuse to day what she really wanted to.

"I... I didn't mean to do... that." I tried to explain without saying too much. "I didn't know-"

"But you did enjoy it~" Candi purred. Reaching down my thigh and lifting my leg up onto her lap. "Almost as much as she did..."

"Don't fucking put words in my mouth Candi." Sam growled. But despite her protest, her cheeks were only getting redder.

"But putting something else in there is fine?" Candi grinned right back at her. "We can always get more... I'm sure Finn would love to-"

"Please leave me out of this." I gulped. Glancing over to Tandi and Olive, checking to see if they were following any of this.

Luckily they weren't. They were arguing about relative power levels between differing universes. They seemed pretty engrossed, but I really didn't want to risk them overhearing the wrong thing.

"How 'bout the both of you just shut the fuck up." Sam spat out.

"Okay... tensions are high. I can see that." Candi calmly explained. Looking between me and Sam, while under the table she untitled my shoe and took it off.

I didn't know what the hell she was doing, but I figured it wouldn't be good. At the same time though, bringing attention to it would likely just make things worse. I couldn't even try and leave, being sandwiched between the two girls, so I had to resign myself to Candi's whims.

Or that's what I told myself. But a part of me, the worst part of me, wanted to see just what fucked up idea Candi was planning.

"I think I owe you an apology Sam." Candi's words almost sounded sincere. "I've pushed you too far, without any... release..."

As more of the anger started to fade from Sam's face, panic set into mine. Candi took hold of my foot with a grip so tight I was worried it would pop. She she directed my sock covered foot away from her lap, over to the other side of the table...

"I want you to feel good." Candi spoke softly and gently. Lovingly staring at her girlfriend while caressing her inner thighs. Not with her hands... but with my foot...

"You want to feel good? Don't you?" She asked while slowly moving my foot deeper under her skirt. "Nod of you want me to make you feel good babe."

Sam scrunched up her face. Eyes darting around the room as Candi rubbed my foot in circles around her thighs. It was clear that she was still mad, but wanted the pleasure all the same.

I meanwhile, didn't know what to fucking do. My heart was racing like crazy, and as fucked up as it was, I started to get hard again.

I knew that Sam would probably kill me if she found out what was happening. she obviously thought that was Candi's foot teasing her right now, not mine. Not her own Brother's...

I should have tried to resist, but trying to escape Candi's grip would only reveal what was happening. Better to pretend like I was Candi. To tease her further, reach deeper between her thighs... just... just to make sure that she wouldn't realise what was going on...

Yeah... that was definitely the only reason I was letting this happen.

After a few more moments of seductively rubbing her with my feet, Sam finally nodded. She rested her elbow on the table, and her face on the palm of her hand. Coving up her mouth, preemptively stopping herself from letting any moans escape.

"That's a good puppy. Now lets make you feel good."