More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 20 by fantaghiro

What's next?

Allison's parents

Saturday afternoon. Tim's sitting in the living room pretending to study when the doorbell rings. He hears Allison answer it, hears a woman's voice—Linda's voice—trembling with barely contained emotion.

He could leave. Should leave. Give them privacy.

Instead, he creeps to the kitchen doorway and watches.

Linda's holding flowers—a gesture so painfully innocent it hurts to see. Tony stands behind her, his jaw tight, his eyes red-rimmed. They look like they haven't slept in days.

"Hi, Mom," Allison says, and her voice is different. More careful. More Jennifer and less Allison than Tim's ever heard it. "Dad. I wasn't expecting you."

"We needed to see you," Tony says quietly. "It's been two weeks since—since we talked last."

Allison leads them into the living room, and Tim ducks back to avoid being seen. But he stays close enough to hear.

"How are you?" Linda asks, and there's a plea in the question. Please tell us you're okay. Please tell us you're still our daughter.

"I'm good. Really good." Allison's voice is bright, almost brittle. "Don and I are—we're really making it work. He's been so wonderful, and the kids have been so supportive, and—"

"Allison," Tony interrupts, and his voice cracks on her name. "We need to talk about what you said. About Jennifer. About... becoming her."

There's a long pause.

"I'm not Allison anymore," Allison says quietly.

The silence that follows is devastating.

"What are you talking about?" Linda's voice rises slightly. "Of course you're Allison. You're our daughter. You're—"

"I'm forty years old. I have a forty-year-old body with eighteen years of consciousness trapped inside it. I'm legally dead. My bank accounts are closed. My social security number is suspended. And I have a man who loves me and a family who needs me." Allison's voice is steady, but Tim can hear the tremor underneath. "I can't be Allison, Mom. Allison doesn't exist anymore. Allison is buried in the ground."

"No." Linda stands abruptly. "No, sweetheart, listen to yourself. You're still you. You're still our baby. Just because the outside changed doesn't mean—"

"The outside didn't just change!" Allison's voice cracks. "The body remembers things. It responds in ways I don't control. It has reflexes and instincts and sexual responses that aren't mine. And every day I wake up and I look in the mirror and I see a stranger, and every day I have to decide: do I fight to be Allison, or do I accept that Jennifer is who I have to be now?"

Tony sits down heavily. "What are you saying?"

"I'm saying that I've decided." Allison's voice is hollow. "I can't keep living in this limbo. I can't keep pretending to be a ghost inside someone else's body. So I'm choosing to become Jennifer. Fully. Completely. I'm going to let Don love me. I'm going to be the mother figure David and Tabitha need. And I'm going to stop fighting the fact that this body is who I am now."

"But you love Tim," Linda says desperately. "You love him. You told us—you said you were still in love with him, that he was your anchor to who you really are—"

Allison's voice wavers slightly. "I do love Tim. And that doesn't change because I'm becoming Jennifer. It just—it changes the shape of that love. The form it takes."

"What do you mean?" Linda leans forward. "What are you saying?"

"I'm saying I can't be Allison to him anymore." Allison's voice breaks. "But maybe—maybe I can be Jennifer to him. A different kind of Jennifer than I am to Don. And maybe that's enough. Maybe that's what we're becoming—something neither of us expected, but something real nonetheless."

Tony's face contorts. "You're talking about—"

"I'm not going to explain myself to you," Allison says gently but firmly. "I'm not going to make sense of this in a way that makes you comfortable. Because there is no comfortable way to explain this. What I'm telling you is: I love you. I will always love you. But I need you to let me go so I can figure out who I'm supposed to be now. And that person—Jennifer, or whoever I become—she's going to have a life that doesn't include me being your daughter. At least not in the way you want."

Linda makes a sound like she's been physically struck. "Sweetheart, no—"

"Mom." Allison stands, and her voice is gentle but resolute. "I'm Jennifer. And Jennifer's life moves forward from here."

"What about us?" Tony's voice is raw. "We're your parents. We love our daughter. We want our daughter back."

"I know." Allison's voice cracks, and Tim can hear the tears now. "And I love you. I will always love you. But I can't be the daughter you want because that daughter doesn't exist anymore. I'm sorry. I'm so, so sorry. But this is the reality now."

Tim hears Linda crying—not quietly, but the kind of sobbing that comes from a place of absolute devastation. The sound of a mother grieving a child who's still alive but will never come home.

"I can't accept this," Tony says hoarsely.

"I know," Allison repeats. "But you're going to have to. Because I'm Jennifer now. And I need you to let me go."

There's the sound of movement—someone standing, maybe reaching for a hug that doesn't happen. Footsteps. The door opening.

"Allison—" Linda's voice, one last **** plea.

"It's Jennifer," Allison says gently. "You can call me Jennifer."

Tim hears the front door close. Hears Linda's keening wail from the porch. Hears Tony's murmured comfort, futile and empty.

And then silence.

________________________________________

That night, Tim waits until his dad falls asleep, until the house settles into that heavy, post-evening quiet. Then she comes to him, moving through the darkness like a ghost.

She's still in the clothes she wore to dinner with Don—a black dress that clings to her body, her hair styled the way he likes it. But her makeup is smudged, her eyes red from crying, and she looks devastated and beautiful and lost.

"Hi," she whispers, closing the door behind her.

He doesn't pull her into bed immediately. Instead, they sit on the edge of the mattress, shoulders almost touching but not quite.

"I heard what you said to your parents," Tim says quietly.

She nods slowly. "I figured you might have."

"Did you mean it? About Jennifer and you—about what you're becoming?"

"I don't know." She takes a shaky breath. "I meant the part about becoming Jennifer. That's real. But the part about you—about us—I'm still figuring out."

"So what are we?" Tim asks, and the vulnerability in his voice breaks something in both of them. "What is this thing between us?"

She's quiet for a long time. "I don't know if we're Allison and Tim anymore. That girl is gone—or she's becoming something else, at least." She turns to look at him. "But Jennifer and Tim—I don't know what that is yet. Something new. Something that doesn't have a name or a precedent or any kind of societal framework to exist in."

"Something illegal," Tim says quietly.

"Yes." She doesn't sugarcoat it. "Something illegal and immoral and deeply, deeply fucked up. But also—" Her voice wavers. "Also something real. Isn't it? When you're inside me and you call me 'mom' and I come harder than I've ever come—that's real. When you look at me like I'm the most beautiful thing you've ever seen and it has nothing to do with loving Allison and everything to do with wanting Jennifer—that's real."

"It's also sick," Tim says, but he's already reaching for her, already pulling her down onto the bed.

"I know." She straddles him, presses her forehead to his. "But I think I'm sick now. I think whatever this is—whatever happened to me when I got this body—it broke something fundamental about who I was. And maybe that's a tragedy, or maybe it's just—a new version of myself that I have to learn to live with."

"What about Dad?" Tim asks, his hands already working at the zipper of her dress. "Don't you feel guilty?"

"Every second," she whispers. "But not enough to stop. Is that terrible?"

"Yes." He pulls the dress over her head, takes a moment to just look at her—her body, her breasts, the soft curve of her stomach. "But I don't care anymore. I want you. This version of you. Jennifer and Allison and whoever else you're becoming."

She kisses him then, deep and ****, and when she guides him inside her, they both groan at the familiarity of it. This has become their language—the only way they know how to communicate what they feel.

"I have to ask," she says as he begins to move. "Are you in love with me? Or are you in love with this body?"

Tim stills. "I don't know anymore. Does it matter?"

"It matters to me." She pulls his face up to hers. "Because I need to know if you're staying because you love me, or if you're staying because I'm Jennifer and this body does things that—"

He cuts her off by kissing her. "I love Allison. And I'm attracted to my mom. And I don't know how to separate those things anymore, and I don't think I can. So I'm staying because I love both of her. All of her. Everything she is and everything she's becoming."

"That's beautiful," she whispers. "And completely delusional."

"I know."

She starts to move again, and the conversation fades into sensation. Into the rhythm of their bodies, the way they fit together, the whispered words that are equal parts confession and obscenity.

Midway through, as she's close to coming, she leans down and whispers in his ear:

"What if I get pregnant?"

Tim freezes. "What?"

"Don wants more kids. He's talked about it. And my body—Jennifer's body—she's fertile, and he wants me to stop my birth control, and—" She stops, gasps as he resumes, deeper now. "What would you do if I got pregnant with his child?"

"I don't know," Tim says roughly, and he doesn't stop moving. If anything, the thought spurs him on. "I don't fucking know."

"But you'd stay," she says. It's not a question.

"Yes." He's close now, can feel it building. "I'd stay. I'd stay through all of it. The baby, the marriage, all of it. I'd stay."

She comes at that—hard and fast, clenching around him—and Tim follows her over, spilling into her with a groan that's half pleasure, half anguish.

After, they lie tangled in the sheets, and she traces patterns on his chest.

"I'm scared," she whispers.

"Of what?"

"Of what I'm becoming. Of what we're becoming. Of the fact that I'm not sure where Jennifer ends and Allison begins anymore, and I'm also not sure I care."

Tim pulls her closer. "Then we'll figure it out together. Whatever this is."

"Whatever this is," she repeats, and there's a note of resignation in her voice. "Jennifer and Tim. The mother-son lovers. The most fucked-up love story that ever existed."

"Probably."

She sits up, looks down at him. In the dim light, her face is unreadable. "Do you think this ends well?"

"No," Tim says honestly. "I think this ends in catastrophe. But I also think it's the only choice we have left."

She nods slowly, like she's accepted something she's been fighting against for weeks. Then she gets up, finds her dress, puts it back on.

"I have to go back," she says. "He'll wake up and wonder where I am."

"I know."

She pauses at the door. "Tim?"

"Yeah?"

"I love you. I need you to know that. Whatever identity I'm wearing, whatever body I'm in—that part is still true."

"I know," he says. "And I love you too."

She leaves, and he lies there in the dark, listening to her footsteps fade down the hallway, knowing that they're creating something together that has no name, no future, no redemption.

And not caring enough to stop.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)