Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 238 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Caleb, Check your Watch

Author's note: Please remember dear readers that when Caleb makes changes to reality that affect the past, everyone's memories and experiences change except for his. Lori is the only exception to that rule, but her memories get screwed up for a bit afterwards because she has two sets and she has to sort through them before she can recall past events correctly. Up till now, Kathy's memories change even if she knows it was a change Caleb made. In case you didn't catch the handful of references, I've hinted that there is an exception for Kathy as well.

Mary slid a hand under her pillow to silence her cellphone alarm. She wanted to stretch but the way they were laying made that impossible. She lay on her side while Caleb, as the ‘little spoon’, had his head nestled between her boobs using the lower one for a pillow. Amelia was behind her with one leg cocked up on Mary’s hip. Megumi lay with her head on Caleb’s arm, her lips gently suckling Mary’s nipple.

She walked her fingers down Caleb’s side and reached for his cock. June should be coming to wake her any minute, but first she wanted a feel of the object of so many women’s desires.

She slowly snaked her hand between Caleb and Megumi only to find their crotches pressed together. The moonlight coming in through the window allowed her to see that the cock that gave her so much pleasure was wedged between Megumi’s thighs, with her slit pressing against his shaft.

She quietly chuckled to herself. Megumi had beaten her to his cock, and she wasn’t even awake. Mary slowly and gently feathered her fingers along Megumi’s side, raising goose bumps along her skin. The sexy Japanese woman suckled a bit harder in her sleep and Mary felt her milk let down.

Mary gently stroked her and found that she could influence the speed of Megumi’s suckling with the speed of her hand. The fact that breastfeeding caused a tingle on her clit had been a wonderful surprise when Caleb made her a milky mommy. When Megumi opened her eyes, Mary gave her a loving smile and whispered, “Comfy?”

It took a moment for Megumi to realize what was between her legs. She let Mary’s nipple slip from her lips, smiled back and whispered, “Very. And thank you for breakfast.”

June tiptoed into the room only to find two of the beds occupants awake. She set the nut milk jars she was carrying on a nightstand. Seeing that Mary would not be able to extract herself without depriving Caleb of her flesh pillow, June whispered, “You stay here Mary. Megumi and I will make breakfast. Lori and my mother are up and they can help. Kathy wants Misty to learn how to harvest his morning loads, so I will send her in here in a bit. Kathy won’t be joining you. I think she feels a bit bad about letting her magic run wild last night.”

Mary said, “So you noticed that too.”

June smirked, “I’ve never seen my stud son cum so much before, and I’ve been blowing him everyday for months. That was way more cum than even his morning loads. I knew it had to be magically enhanced.”

Mary was curious about something and said, “June, has he always cum this much in the morning, or is this another one of his unique Stretcher King miracles?”

Megumi lifted her leg so that she could release Caleb’s cock from her thigh’s embrace. Already her pussy felt cold and lonely without it pressed against her. Mary’s hand gripped his cock gently as she began stroking him to hardness. She loved the feel of his hot cock.

June answered, “He’s always been this way. Imagine my surprise when I came to give him his first mother son blowjob on the morning of his eighteenth birthday, and discovered my son not only had a stretcher, and a big one at that, but he nearly drowned me in delicious jizz. I quickly learned to take the first load directly down my throat, and the second on my face and tits so that I could share it with Hazel. It wasn’t until he became a Stretcher King and began building his harem that I started eating breakfast again.”

June ran her hands over her belly and giggled, "For a while there, I was worried I would start gaining a ton of weight from all the cum I was eating, but I never did. I had never needed to buy it from the store, so I never read the nutrition facts on the labels. I didn't know how low it was in calories, or how many vitamins and minerals it contained. All that time I was worried about gaining weight, I had no idea my son was providing me with a very healthy morning meal."

"Honestly, I was starting to feel rejected when he went so long without asking if I'd like a stretch. I was blowing him every morning, and I wore my sexiest lingerie to do it, but he still didn't offer. It wasn't until just before he became a Stretcher King that I had enough and flirted with him hard. I practically threw myself at him. I should have done that from the start. Not only was he willing, he didn't think I would say yes if he asked. Imagine that? I love him, but he can be a silly boy sometimes. As if a mother wouldn't want a cock that big to stretch her pussy. I made that humongous cock, in my womb, with my genetics. He certainly didn't get it from his father. So of course it should get to revisit its home. He could have whipped it out at any time and I would have spread my legs for him." She quietly laughed and left the room with Megumi.

Mary continued to run her hand up and down Caleb's shaft, smearing his precum around as she did. Like June, Mary was late in making love to her daughters, so she sympathized with her. If June hadn’t taken the step to seduce her son, none of the wonderful things Mary had experienced would have happened.

She managed to get Caleb rock hard when Misty and Lottie walked in. Misty stopped at the edge of the bed and licked her lips at the sight of Mary stroking him. Lottie climbed in bed and lay opposite Mary. She lifted one breast off the other and said, “Here, slide him over and he can use me for a pillow so you can harvest his cum.”

Mary was always amazed at how deep Caleb slept. They manhandled him over to Lottie’s tits and rolled him so he was on his back. Lottie rolled slightly and cocked one knee to steady herself so that when she released her other boob, it didn’t cover his face. Whenever Caleb slept on his back, this was a common position for the women with boobs big enough to spent the night as his pillows. Not the most comfortable way for the women to lay, but being the lucky woman to spend the night as Caleb's pillow was worth a little discomfort. He was their king, and they all wished to please him. They were also all a little thankful that Caleb didn't often sleep on his back.

Amanda walked in looking fresh and well rested. April and Emily trailed behind her and looked dead on their feet. Amanda pushed Misty to get her to climb into the bed. April sat down gingerly. Her pussy was red and sore. Amanda had put April on the milking table and left her there with the fucking machine running for two hours while Amanda spent the time devouring Emily’s cunt. April was ready to collapse when Amanda turned the machine off, but that was only the beginning of a very exhausting and very orgasmic night. If anyone asked her, April would swear Amanda’s fat hucow tongue was long enough to lick her womb.

Heather was the last to arrive. Everyone else was either cooking or getting a little more sleep. As she climbed into bed she remarked, “You missed out on one hell of a show Amanda. Caleb fucked the hell out of Betty and then absolutely wrecked Kathy and Chris. He even made June and Lori lick his cum off the floor. I thought June was going to have kittens, she was so proud of what a stud he is. When we went to bed she kept going on and on about how hot it was to be ordered around like that. I’m pretty sure Melissa has a new student when it comes to being submissive to our master.”

Amelia blearily looked around and asked, “Where’s Sonia? She never misses a morning cum load.”

April stretched and yawned while she said, “Gabbie is teaching Sonia how to cook. Mary’s in charge since her, Kathy, and June aren’t here.”

Mary looked around at the girls and said, “How about a deep throat competition this time? Since those three aren’t here, one of us has a chance of winning for a change.”

After a quiet chorus of agreement Amelia got up and said, “I’ll get the lipstick.”

After each woman chose a color and applied it, Mary said, “Misty, since this is your first time, you get to pick your spot first. The most popular choice is laying over him so he wakes up with your pussy in his face. He’ll eat you to orgasm before he does anything else. It also gives you a good angle to get his cock really deep. We all enjoy that position, but we also like to switch it up. Some of us love licking and sucking his balls so they prefer being between his legs. It’s the worst angle for deep throating him, but the benefit of that spot is you don’t have to stop playing with his balls until it’s your turn to suck his cock. The other two choices are being over one of his legs or next to his arms. He has bony shins which is great for rubbing your clit with, or you could suck his cock from the side and he will play with your pussy when he wakes.”

Misty felt her body heating as she whispered, “Wow, so that means six women can take turns sucking him off. That’s so awesome. Caleb is such a… a MAN!”

Amelia put her hand over Misty’s mouth and shushed her. “We don’t want to wake him. Part of the fun is seeing how long we can go before he does. It’s great when he cums right as he wakes, but sometimes he sleeps through the first round. Kathy loves it when we do that to him, so he can get a bit more sleep. Also, whenever we have more than six girls, someone will switch off as soon as they cum. Whoever is the ‘out’ girl keeps the nut milk jars ready.”

Misty chose the favorite position laying over Caleb. Lottie got next pick and she chose a leg. Her huge milk cans smushed around his thigh as she pressed her cunt against his shin. They continued to chose their spots in the order they arrived. Mary and Amelia had last pick because they got to sleep with him. That meant Mary got to lick and suck his balls, leaving Amelia holding the nut milk jars.

Amelia should have gotten the position between his legs since Mary had gotten to be Caleb's pillow and Amelia's boobs were too small for it. But the harem had naturally fallen into a hierarchy, and the spot between his legs was reserved for the highest ranked harem member present. In the harem Mary was subordinate only to Kathy their harem queen, Sonia as second in charge of the harem, and June the holy mother.

Mary and Lori were considered equals by the harem. Mary as Kathy's mother, and Lori as Caleb's beloved aunt. Amelia, Chris, Angie, Megumi, Gabbie, and Katie were somewhere just below Mary and Lori, with the rest of the harem, Chloe, Melissa, April, Cora, Brandy, Amanda, Marilyn, Lu, Lottie, and Holly being under them. Hazel, Tina, Emily, Betty, Misty, Ramona, and Linda were all possible future members of the harem, though only Betty and Misty were currently candidates.

Hazel herself was a special case, with Caleb and June as the only ones she answered to. As far as the rest of the harem was concerned, Hazel rated one very small step below Kathy or June in importance.

Once everyone was in their positions Mary explained the rules. “Ok, you each get twenty seconds to use your mouth and tongue however you like before you must close your mouth and mark his cock with your lipstick. Time starts as soon as his tip passes your lips, or your lips or tongue touches his cock. When you have five seconds to go, Amelia or I will quietly count down to one. You may hold him steady with your hands, but no jerking him off. We keep going until he cums. The winner gets a triple helping of cum with breakfast, and the person in last place gets a mandatory training session with Sonia.”

The harem members that had played before grinned. A training session with Sonia consisted of her giving you tips on taking a cock down your throat while she used one of the replica cocks on you. She was a great teacher, but she was also relentless. You would get the replica in your throat or she would just schedule you for another session. Kathy had asked Sonia to teach them how to be a good harem and that included pleasuring Caleb. Sonia took her duty very seriously, to Kathy's delight. Their queen was adamant that they all work hard to please their king, not that the harem wasn't also well motivated.

"Okay Misty, begin whenever you're ready."

Misty hesitated for a second as Mary held it pointed at her face. It looked much bigger and scarier than the first time she sucked it. The smell of his precum was heavenly, and she reached out with her tongue licking up the dollop forming on the tip. She moaned and felt her pussy moisten as she enjoyed the taste. She continued to swirl her tongue around the head of his cock when suddenly Mary tapped her and held up a hand, slowly counting down the seconds remaining. Misty hurriedly pushed her head down engulfing the top half of his shaft when Mary’s fist closed indicating that it was time to mark Caleb with her blue lips.

When she pulled her mouth off, Mary quietly remarked, “That was a good first effort. It’s easy to get mesmerized by how wonderful he tastes, but you did good. Re-apply your lipstick for your next turn. Amanda, you’re next.”

Amanda grinned at Misty and said, “Not bad, but watch this.” She stuck out her tongue and it just kept coming. The beautiful hucow wrapped her tongue around Caleb’s cock and ran it up and down as if jerking him off. She then leaned forward and pulled his cock to her mouth, engulfing the tip. Down she took his tongue wrapped cock. At the halfway point she coughed a little, then began to gag with just a quarter of him still to go. Mary counted down while Amanda struggled to take him deeper.

Amanda left a purple lipstick ring about four fifth’s down his shaft. She commented, “I could have taken the whole thing if I had your spot Misty, but that’s why we switch thing up. No one is allowed to win twice in a row, and the newest or worst player gets to pick their spot first.”

With that, Mary signaled Lottie that it was her turn, and the game continued going clockwise around Caleb’s body.

Caleb woke as his cock was firing off. He opened his eyes and knew that it was Misty above him by the brown bunny tail at the top of the ass crack in front of him. Of the twenty members of his harem, only five were shifters, and only one of them was a bunny girl. Melissa's ear, tail, and leg fur were white, Misty's was brown.

He wondered how many women were tending to his cock as he spurted his load. He felt more than one hand on his cock and a body on each leg grinding up and down. A foot kicked his arm so he reached out in each direction. He found a leg on his other side and followed both bodies until he found their cunnies.

Lifting his head he licked Misty’s labia as he fingered the other two pussies he had found. Misty’s juices had an earthy flavor unlike any of the other women. It was slightly sweet but with a hint of something he couldn’t figure out. His girls had begun using flavored lubes recently and he wracked his brain trying to guess what it was.

Misty sat up giving him easier access to her cunt. Her juices flowed quicker and the flavor became stronger. It was then that he remembered the normality he created that made each harem members pussy juice taste like their favorite candy. Caleb wondered at that though. Misty wasn’t in the harem yet, but she was Angie’s pet, so maybe the watch thought she qualified.

As Misty orgasmed and sprayed his face, he figured out what the flavor was. As she slumped forward he gleefully called out, “It’s Carrots!”


Amanda washed Misty’s ass as they showered in the master bathroom. Amanda had won the game in the third round when she finally left a purple ring at the base of Caleb’s cock. Despite having the best position, Misty had done the worst, but just barely behind Emily.

“Hey Carrots, you wanna take a turn on my table after school? I’d love to give you a romp.”

Emily warned her, “Be careful Carrots, she won’t let you up until she is done with you. I’m gonna walk bowlegged all damn day.”

Amanda scoffed, “Eh, you’re a normie. Us shifters can handle getting our kitties beat all night. Just look at April, she lasted all night, and she is fine.”

April growled, “Fuck no I’m not! My fucking clit is numb, and even Caleb doesn’t pound pussy as hard as you. Misty, if you wanna play with Amanda, I won’t tell you don’t. Honestly, it was fan-fucking-tastic. I’ve never been tossed around and fucked like that before. But I’m going to pay for it today. You want my advice, make sure you’re in charge before you agree to play with her. There is a reason they chain hucows to their milking tables. I love you Amanda, but you get way too rough when you cum.”

Emily chimed in with, “Amen sister!”

Amanda looked down and pouted, “I’m sorry. I thought you both liked it.”

Emily lifted Amanda’s head and kissed her softly, “We did. Holy shit did we enjoy it. But you got to be gentle with us. Our pussies can’t take the **** yours can.”

Holly poked her head into the room and said, “Hey Misty, shake a leg or you’ll miss breakfast. Kathy wants you to join her, me, and Katie to sexercise at school this morning.”

Emily grinned and said, “Better get a move on Carrots. You don’t wanna keep your queen waiting.”

Holly gave them a funny look and quizzically asked, “Carrots?”

Misty stepped out of the shower while saying, “Apparently that’s my new nickname. Caleb called me that when he ate my pussy this morning, and they think it’s funny. Ever since Kathy claimed me for her harem, my pussy has tasted like the carrot cake candies my mom makes. No one warned me about that part of being in a harem. I thought that was only for the harems of Stretcher Kings. Not that I’m complaining you understand, I love being in Kathy's harem, and I really really love to taste myself on another girl's lips after she goes down on me.”

Holly laughed and said, “That’s better than Lottie I guess. Her favorite candy is black licorice. Believe me when I say I hope she finds a new favorite candy soon.”

Holly called out to Lottie as the black woman rubbed her soapy boobs against Mary's back, “I love you girl, but I can only eat you to one orgasm before it’s too much.”

Lottie gave her a grin while Misty finished running a towel over her hair and asked, “What flavor are you?”

Holly smiled and exclaimed, “Bubble gum!”


As he was walking down the hallway, Lori pulled Caleb into her room. Inside he found Kathy biting her finger and looking worried. Lori grabbed his wrist and lifted it to look at his watch. “Shit. Caleb, when did you create your last normality?”

He gave her a funny look and said, “Yesterday with you and Kat. The candy flavored pussies one.” He then looked down at his watch and saw the seconds hand still spinning rapidly. He looked back up at Lori and said, “What’s going on?”

Lori grunted, “My memories are still fucked up from yesterday. And with your watch still going nuts, that means one of the normalities you created yesterday has a conflict. And it hasn’t been resolved yet.”

Kathy rushed over and hugged him, pleading, “I’m sorry Caleb. I didn’t know I wasn’t supposed to have my own harem. Please forgive me. I… I don’t know what to do. I don’t know how to fix this. Please don’t be mad.”

Caleb felt as if his brain just broke. “Wait? What? Your own harem?”

Lori guided them to sit on her bed and said, “Sit down and let’s figure out exactly what screwy shit is happening this time.”


Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)