Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 215 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Around the mansion

Authors note: I haven't spoken Spanish in twenty years so it is very rusty, but I think I got my translations right. Spanish is not my first language so pardon me if it is terrible.

Sonia grunted as High Priestess Phong used a butt plug to lube Sonia’s rear.

Megumi patted her hand and said, “You don’t have to do this Sonia. Caleb will understand that his cock is just too big to fuck your ass.”

Sonia gasped as the High Priestess popped the butt plug into her rear again, “I can do this. More lube please, High Priestess.

The tiny high priestess patted Sonia on her big butt and said, “You can call me by name under the circumstances. Your friend is right though Sonia. It’s a wonderful thing that you want to give the Stretcher King your anal virginity, but he may just be too big for you. Remember when he first fucked me, you and Priestess Emma had to hold me down because I am so tight, and that was my pussy. There is no way I could take him in my back door.”

Gabbie finished donning a strap-on with a small cock on it and said, “I don’t get it. We are the ones that will be fucking her ass High Priestess, so how could she give Caleb her anal virginity? Won't we have already taken it?”

Phong smiled at the young convert as she very slowly worked more lube into Sonia’s big ass with the butt plug, “Think of it this way my child, when you became an adult and your mother gave you your first taste of cum, or licked and fingered your pussy for the first time, did she cheat on your father? The obvious answer is no. Sex between women, while wonderfully beautiful, does not count when it comes to things like virginity or fidelity. You haven’t truly given your virginity until you have a real hot cock inside one of your holes.”

Gabbie was confused and asked, “So lesbian sex isn’t real sex?”

Phong switched to a bigger butt plug while she spoke. “In a way, it is both yes and no, it is real, but not. Men are the ones that have always been more concerned over the supposed virginity of women. Very few care how many women their wives or girlfriends have been with, but they do care about how many men. Then again, a woman only experiences a physical change from a stretching, which requires a man with a stretcher. The increased wetness, increased vaginal sensitivity, ease of orgasm, and possibility of multiple orgasms, are all things that a proper stretching gives to a woman. Some members of the church argue that only a man with a stretcher can truly take a woman's virginity, and that a Stretcher King is the ultimate claimer of one's virginity."

"Now, that particular argument could be discussed all day, and has been many times among the leadership of the church, but there is no question that a woman can not take another woman's virginity. Since that is true, then the same holds true for when a mother gives her son his first blowjob when he becomes an adult. She is merely performing a form of self love. He is a part of her, born of her womb, so that particular sexual act between them isn’t the same as a man and woman that are unrelated. In a way, she earned the cum he gifts her by being a loving mother to him. She fed him from her breast as an infant, and then he feeds her from his cock once he becomes an adult. I see that Sonia has several of our religious texts on the bookshelf over there. Once we are done here, I will show you some passages that explain more fully.”

Gabbie watched as Phong twisted the butt plug to make sure Sonia's pucker was evenly coated. “So what you're saying is neither my own or Caleb's mother took our virginities, because we are a part of them. It doesn’t count just like sex between two women doesn't. I think I understand that now. My next question is, why is Sonia doing this, if she doesn’t even know if she likes anal? And why am I going first?”

Sonia tried to loosen her asshole more as she answered, “Several reasons. The chief reason being I am Caleb’s personal Priestess. Even though he is not a member of the church, he chose me and made it my duty when he claimed me. I must be prepared to perform any sexual acts he desires. He enjoyed fucking Tina in the butt, so I need to be ready in case he wants to use me. Also, I am the free use sex toy for the family. He isn’t the only person that can fuck me there. The reason why you are going first is because you have the least sexual experience. That’s why you have the strap-on with the smallest dildo. High Priestess Phong has the most experience, so she will go last and has the biggest one.”

Lottie cackled, “Who has the most experience is debatable. I may have only been with three men in my life, but I’ve been with dozens of women, and I’ve got quite a few years on all of you. How about we say that Phong has the most training?”

Phong smiled at Lottie. She was surprised to learn how old Lottie really was, but that was before she spoke with Sonia and learned of her suspicions. If Caleb truly was the Fountain of Youth, it would change the world. That was another reason for Sonia to give Caleb her ass, though Sonia was not devious enough to have thought of it. By giving the Stretcher King her ass, she would draw him closer to her, and by extension, the Sisterhood.

“Okay Sonia, I think you’re ready. What position would you like to start in?”

Sonia was already in the doggy position and that is the one she chose. Phong knelt beside Gabbie, applied lube to her dildo, and guided her into position. “Ok dear, grab your ‘cock’ and get ready to put the tip in as soon as I pull the butt plug out. Don’t try to put more than an inch or two in yet. Ready, go.”

Quickly the two women moved, though Gabbie was a little slow. Phong put her hand on Gabbie’s ass to steady her and said, “Good, now stay still and let Sonia push her ass back to you. Megumi, would you get on the other side of us and play with Sonia’s pussy. That will help. While she is doing that, Gabbie, grab her ass cheeks and spread them.”

Slowly Sonia eased her ass toward Gabbie, the dildo sliding smooth and easy up her back passage. Phong had done an excellent job of lubing her up. "Ok, Gabbie, now grab her hips and fuck her nice and slow. Let her get used to having your 'cock' in her. Pay attention to Sonia's responses, and speed up or slow down based on them."

Gabbie found fucking Sonia's huge ass was fun. She tried out a couple hard slams and got a nice moan out of her roommate/lover. She grinned and reared her hand back and smacked Sonia’s fat butt. Her cheeks jiggled and Sonia gripped the sheets of their bed.

"Fuck me Gabbie. Fuck my ass and spank it too." Sonia thrust her ass back at Gabbie while Megumi's fingers flew across her clit. She wasn't sure if she would like anal, but she knew now, at least with the small cock Gabbie wore.

Gabbie sped up her thrusts and Sonia matched her pace. They began to make a slapping noise every time Sonia's ass hit Gabbie's hips. Megumi couldn't keep her fingers in contact with Sonia's clit but it was clear the older woman didn't need the help. She was moaning as Gabbie pounded her ass, spanking it every half dozen or so thrusts.

Gabbie grabbed Sonia's hair and pulled her head back. "You like that Mamacita? You like it when I pound your grasa culo? Buena, casa puta? Respóndeme!"

Translation *You like that pretty lady? You like it when I pound your fat ass? Well, house whore? Answer me!*

"Si! Mios Dios! Follame el culo! Soy el orgasmo!"

Translation *Yes! My God! Fuck my ass! I'm orgasming!*

Sonia's body became uncoordinated as she tried to keep slamming her ass back at Gabbie. Gabbie laughed, she never had so much fun during sex. Sonia stood on her knees, forcing the dildo out of her ass. She turned and tackled Gabbie to the bed. Her face descended upon Gabbie and she whispered, "Te mantendré para siempre." Then she kissed her deeply.

Translation *I will keep you forever*

When the two broke their kiss Megumi grinned and waved her slightly larger strap-on at Sonia. "My turn."


Melissa opened a couple bottles of wine and poured glasses for the women in the bomb shelter. It was still early, but a half dozen guests had already made their way down, along with Katie and Amelia. Lu, Holly, Cora, Brandy, and Melissa had spent the last two hours getting the games for the orgy set up.

They brought robes for any women that wished to wear one, the bar was fully stocked, several pink platters of food had been laid out on a banquet table, and another table contained an obscene amount of sex toys and accessories.

Joan, the channel 2 new host, put her arms around Melissa and said, "Stop working and come sit with us. Tell us what games you all have planned."

Melissa could smell the **** on her breath. By now, half the guests were tipsy. Once seated Melissa told the group, "We have lots of things we can play. There's 'Substitute Cock' and 'Guess the Lube Flavor' and 'What's in my Pussy'. We also have the usual lesbian party games like 'Deepthroat Dildo' and 'Guess Who'. We also have 'Twister', which is a staple of all lesbian parties, or we can sing karaoke."

Joan laughed and said, "I haven't played 'What's in my Pussy' since college. What kind of things do you have?"

Amelia answered her, "Oh the usual, some fruits, some kitchen utensils, empty bottles, pretty much any penis like object. Since some of the women aren't stretched, we have lots of small items for them and the big stuff like the bottles are for us stretched girls. Back in college I lost a game once because I couldn't figure out that the girl I was up against had a toy car in her kitty."

Katie laughed and said, "That's nothing. My mom won when no one in her lesbian club could figure out she had an entire thermos bottle shoved in her twat. One of her ex-boyfriends had a class four stretcher and stretched her out to the max. I can fit my arm in her all the way past my elbow."

Melissa shuddered, "Oh my. That is way too stretched. Caleb's cock is perfect for me. I wouldn't want one any bigger. He's big enough that he rearranges your guts and maybe gives you a belly bulge, but not so big he hits your diaphragm and makes it impossible to breathe. Besides which, how do you suck a cock that huge? No thank you. I love Caleb's thickness, it's just enough that you have to fight to get it in your throat, but you still can, you know what I mean?"

The women in the room agreed, even the ones that hadn't had Caleb's cock in them yet. Katie nodded and said, "Oh, I totally agree with you. Mom kinda regrets getting stretched that far. They broke up because she couldn't fit more than his cockhead in her mouth. I mean, what girl wants a guy whose cock they can't suck?"

Once again the women in the room indicated their agreement. Holly asked, "What's 'Substitute Cock'? I've never heard of it before."

Lu clapped her hands and said, "Oh! I've played that. It's hilarious if you're drunk. You have a bag with the names of all kinds of random objects in the room in it. One girl draws the name of an object and then she has to treat that object like it's a cock. She can lick it, fuck it, suck it, worship it, whatever. The rest of the girls each rate her performance one through ten. The girl with the highest score wins a prize. We have a little plastic trophy for the winner, but the real prize is they get to wake Caleb tomorrow morning, however they like. Kathy decided that if a harem member wins, they have to pick a girl from the orgy to help them."

Brandy and Cora were looking through the sex toy table when Cora asked, "Why did you get so many huge dildos that all look exactly the same? Is it for 'Deepthroat Dildo'? I've never played that with more than one."

Melissa got up and went over to join them at the table. "No. We'll only use one for that too. These are all replicas of Caleb's cock. Sonia taught us how to make them. Pick one up and have a taste."

Cora did. She licked around the head and her eyes went wide. "Holy shit. It tastes just like his cum. How the hell did you do that?"

Amelia proudly stated, "We put a small amount of his cum into the mix. When they are fresh out of the mold they even smell like him. It took hours to make enough, but all the women that attend the housewarming will get one to take home. Make sure you two get fresh ones before you go back to college. If we have any extras, you can take some to give to your friends. Because some of his cum is in each one, if they stretch themselves on them, the effect will last longer than if they stretched themselves with a regular dildo. Sonia said that instead of a coupe hours ,they will stay stretched for a few days. Don't tell them, let them find out on their own."


"Mom! Please! Take it off! It fucking hurts!"

Donna leaned toward her son and angrily shouted, "Zachary! Stop asking! This is a punishment. You are supposed to be repenting for your sins. It hasn't even been two hours yet. You can't go two hours without a hard on? Your whining is not going to change anything. It's your fault that Alice and Christie didn't get stretched, and none of those poor girls got to taste Caleb's cum or even get a cum covering."

Christie growled, "Yeah Zack. If you hadn't been jerking it, none of this would have happened. For someone that is supposed to be sorry, you sure aren't acting like it."

Alice bit her finger in lieu of responding, she agreed with Donna and Christie, but didn't want to verbally go against her boyfriend. Instead Megan came to Zack's defense. "He is sorry Donna. He won't ever do it again. I know he won't."

Donna softened and said, "Megan dear, I know you love him, but you don't get a say in this. You did get stretched. Until Caleb stretches Alice and Christie, Zack has to wear the cage. I'll let him out so that he can feed you girls, but then he goes right back in. And he will keep wearing it until I'm sure he truly is sorry."

Zack had tears in his eyes as he said, "But Mom, that's not fair. You could let me out now. I haven't fed them any cum since this morning."

She whipped her head back to Zack and snapped, "I'm tired of your whining. It is fair, and they don't need your cum. There is plenty of Caleb's in the party food. Go home Zachary. Take my car and come get us in the morning. I'm keeping your girls with me. June invited me to attend the orgy in the bomb shelter, and I've barely gotten to play with your girlfriends at all since you first brought them to our house. I'll unlock you in the morning so we can give you a blowjob, but then right back in the cage you go. Tell your father that I'll call him tonight and give him the details if Caleb fucks me again. If he doesn't hear from me, then I stayed with the girls at the orgy. Now, go Zack."

Donna led the three young women toward the gym entrance, leaving Zack behind and in pain. He made the mistake of watching their bikini clad asses undulate as they walked away, and his cock tried to get hard again. When they reached the hallway leading to the harem wing she heard the unmistakable sounds of a woman having an orgasm in the yoga room. She smiled and guided the girls to that room instead.

The Lotus Sister guarding the hall grinned as Donna opened the door and stepped inside. All of the Lotus Sisters knew who the mother was. Several of the younger harem members had talked about her more than once. The guard could see why she was one of the Stretcher King's fantasy women. She was beautiful, had an amazing ass, thick thighs, and nice big jiggly titties. The guard wondered why he hadn't claimed her. She was definitely what the Harem Queen would call 'Caleb Worthy'. She looked down at her own much smaller bust and sighed. She knew that the Stretcher King didn't discriminate based on body type. He had sex with women of all shapes and sizes, but it was clear he preferred big tits.

It wasn't long before more cries of ecstasy floated through the door to the yoga room, this time from the throats of several different women at once.


Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)