Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by Shl33 Shl33

What's next?

Lust?

Steve’s grip on the mechanical pencil tightened, the plastic creaking faintly under his fingers as he stared at the blank Post-it note. His mind churned, sifting through possibilities. If this was a prank, he’d play along—just enough to test it without looking like a fool. If it was real… well, that was a dangerous thought he wasn’t ready to entertain. He needed something simple, something that could pass as a coincidence if it failed, but bold enough to satisfy the dark, ambitious corners of his mind. A smirk flickered across his lips as an idea took shape, one that catered to his baser instincts while still feeling like a safe bet.

He pressed the pencil to the note, the lead scratching softly as he wrote in his tight, deliberate scrawl: *Any woman I am attracted to is 100 times more attracted to me, whatever that means.*

He paused, rereading the words, the vague phrasing a deliberate hedge against disappointment. He capped the sentence with a flourish, then leaned back in his chair, waiting. For what, he wasn’t sure—a flash of light, a surge of energy, some cinematic confirmation that the universe had bent to his will. But nothing came. No spark, no tingle, no cosmic fanfare. Just the droning voice of the professor and the faint rustle of pages turning around him.

“All that for nothing?” Steve hissed under his breath, irritation flaring. He crumpled the Post-it into a tight ball, the paper crackling in his fist, and tossed it over his shoulder. It hit the floor with a barely audible *thwack*, lost somewhere behind him in the classroom’s clutter. He slouched deeper into his seat, arms crossed, ready to dismiss the whole thing as a stupid prank—until something shifted.

It was subtle at first, like a ripple in the air, a wave of *something* that washed over the room. Steve felt it before he could name it—a prickling sensation that raised the hairs on his neck, as if a ghost had brushed past him. His heart stuttered, and he whipped around to look at the spot where he’d thrown the note. It was gone. No crumpled yellow wad, no trace of it among the scuffed tiles and scattered pencil shavings. His pulse quickened, a mix of dread and exhilaration. “Did someone pick it up?” he muttered, his mind racing. “What if they read what I wrote?”

The thought sent a jolt of panic through him. What if someone saw his words, that embarrassingly specific wish scrawled in his own handwriting? He turned back to his desk, ready to bury himself in his textbook and pretend nothing had happened—when he noticed them.

Three pairs of eyes locked on him, unblinking, intense. Kerry, Savannah, and Amber. The girls he’d been quietly, shamefully fixated on for weeks, each for reasons he’d never admit out loud.

Kerry sat two rows ahead, her pale skin stark against her jet-black hair, dyed to an almost unnatural sheen. At five-foot-five, she carried herself with a fiery edge, her ripped fishnets and studded choker a silent dare to anyone who dared judge her. Rumors swirled about her—whispers of wild nights and a string of broken hearts—but Steve suspected most of it was just jealous gossip from guys she’d shot down. Her dark eyes bored into him now, sharp and unreadable.

Savannah, seated closer to the front, was impossible to ignore. Five-foot-nine like Steve, her curvy frame was a study in contrasts: a soft belly, thick legs, and a round, unmistakable ass that her tight jeans and hoodie seemed to cling to like a second skin. Her clothes, always a little smudged or wrinkled, never dulled her raw, effortless charm. Steve had caught himself staring too long more than once, his body reacting in ways that made him shift uncomfortably in his seat. Now, her hazel eyes were fixed on him, a faint flush creeping up her neck.

And then there was Amber, the five-foot blonde dynamo to his right. Her petite frame was almost comically mismatched with her H-cup chest, a feature that drew stares she seemed oblivious to. Her natural blonde hair fell in loose waves, framing a face that was all wide eyes and dimpled smiles—until now. Her gaze was intense, almost predatory, as she leaned slightly toward him.

Steve blinked, rubbed his eyes, but the scene didn’t change. They were *still* staring. His throat tightened, a nervous laugh bubbling up only to die in his chest. Before he could process it, Kerry stood, her chair scraping softly against the floor. Without a word, she crossed the room and slid into the empty seat beside him, her movements deliberate, almost graceful. She didn’t look at him, just settled in, her black-painted nails tapping lightly on the desk. The faint scent of clove cigarettes clung to her, mingling with the classroom’s stale air.

Steve’s mind reeled. “Maybe it worked?” he whispered to himself, the thought slipping out before he could stop it. He shook his head, trying to dislodge the idea. This was ridiculous. It had to be a coincidence, a prank orchestrated by someone who’d found the note and texted these girls to mess with him. But then Savannah stood, her hoodie shifting to reveal the curve of her hips as she moved. She plopped into the seat in front of him, turning slightly so her profile—and that distractingly perfect backside—were impossible to ignore. Amber followed, claiming the seat to his right, her small frame somehow commanding the space as she leaned closer, her elbow brushing his.

None of them spoke. The silence was deafening, unnatural, and it sent a shiver down Steve’s spine. His logical mind kicked into overdrive, searching for an explanation. If someone had picked up the Post-it, how could they know *these* three girls were the ones he was into? He hadn’t told anyone about his private musings, his stolen glances during class. The odds didn’t add up. His gaze darted between them—Kerry’s cool detachment, Savannah’s flushed intensity, Amber’s unnerving focus.

He swallowed hard, his fingers twitching toward his pencil. The Post-it was gone, but its absence felt heavier than its presence ever had. Had it really worked? Or was this some elaborate setup, a cruel joke waiting to unravel? Steve’s heart pounded as he realized he was surrounded, caught in a triangle of attention that felt both thrilling and terrifying. Whatever this was, it was only the beginning.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)