Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 162 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

The orgy is coming

“I’m sorry Caleb, but she forbid us from telling you until after she left.” Sonia looked contrite, her tone apologetic.

Her loyalty to the man she loved was warring with the religion she had spent her entire life a part of. That war was playing out in her expression. She still had not told him about the Lotus Sisters or her suspicions about why Mark really left Mary. Now was not the time for that though.

Chloe came to Sonia's defense, "It’s your own fault Caleb. If you had allowed me to make introductions, the Mother Superior could not have played your game. I've known Helena for decades. Her going along with your request is exactly like something she would do."

“Sit down my love, you look a little pale.” Kathy said. She motioned Angie and Gabbie to get his cock out. The two young women smiled at each other as they took turns licking and sucking his cock.

Caleb put his hands on their heads and said, “You mean to tell me I **** fucked the leader of the sisterhood. I used her like a cum dump last night. Holy fuck, I'm a dead man.”

June laughed. “She loved it Caleb. She told me this morning that it was the first time in over a decade she had been properly fucked. Some women like being used like that. Don’t worry about it. Now eat your breakfast, your food's getting cold.” June dug into her own plate as Mary began feeding him.

Chloe leaned down, kissed him on the top of his head and said, "I very much doubt she will ever allow you to call her by anything other than her first name now. And you can guarantee she will be back. You've basically given her carte blanche to play hooky from her duties in your home. The fact that you fucked her like a stallion will just make her even more eager to return."

Between the bites Mary fed him, he told Chloe, “I’m sorry you didn’t get your reward last night.”

Chloe winked at Kathy and said, “Oh, I did, I just haven’t received my reward from you yet. Kathy, on the other hand, was delicious.”

Kathy leaned over and whispered in June's ear, "He didn't just fuck Helena like a stallion. When I walked in, Caleb was making her lick his cum off the floor while he fucked her doggy style."

June's nipples rapidly hardened, her pussy clenching as the mental image popped into her head. Her body shivered in delight at the prospect of her son doing the same to her. June whispered back, "No shit? That's so fucking hot. Did he spank her too?"

Kathy shrugged, "Not that I know of. I wish you could have seen it though. There was cum everywhere, on everyone and everything. Helena must have taken a shower before she joined us this morning, because last night her hair was caked in it."

June sighed, "Damn. That would have made a fantastic picture to hang in the business office. Next time she comes over, we have to get one. Hopefully he can make another big cummy mess of her."

While they were whispering, the rest of the group were discussing the taste virtues between Caleb's cum and Mary and Kathy's breast milk, and what recipes would go best with each.

Hazel stood up and walked over to Kathy saying, "Speaking of delicious. We need to drain your boobs before school Kat. Pop one of those milk jugs out, cuz I'm still hungry."

She looked around the room and added, "Anyone wanna join me?"

June, Chris, and Tina all said, "I will," at the same time. Laughter broke out around the room at their eagerness.

Mary looked over at Amelia and asked, "Would you be a dear and take over feeding Caleb so that I can help my daughter feed these poor starving women?"

Amelia moved to switch seats when Caleb said, "I can feed myself you know."

June smiled at him as she moved over to Mary, knelt before her and said, "We know baby, but that would mean Angie and Gabbie would have to get under the table, and we couldn't watch them sucking your cock. Besides, it would be kinda cramped under there for them with that massive meat missile you've got. Get used to being fed by your harem honey. It's going to happen a lot."

Kathy smiled as Hazel and Tina latched onto her breasts. She closed her eyes as her milk began to flow, a tingle of pleasure shooting down to her clit.

Kathy held the two women at her breasts lovingly as she said, "Caleb my love, this is your life now. You are a Stretcher King. You will forever be surrounded by women that love you, and want to please you. I want that for you. I want your harem and family to treat you like a King. If I must be saddled with this Harem Effect curse, I'm going to make it work for me. I want women to love you. I want women to desire you. I want you to have sex with and breed every woman that catches your eye, every woman that is worthy of you. If you want someone, just let me know and I will get her for you. I will want her to want you, and she will be yours."

Sonia and Chloe exchanged a look, a small smile on their lips, knowing the power of a Harem Queen's desires.

Kathy words painted a mental picture for Caleb of him seated on a throne in a huge castle's great hall as thousands of beautiful naked women prostrated themselves before him, begging him to fuck and breed them.

The sexy image was too much for him. A flood of cum came rushing up his shaft and rained down upon Angie and Gabbie as they licked the sides of his shaft. Gabbie was partially under the table and hit it as she moved to grab a nut milk jar. Angie tilted her head up and watched his cum arc high into the air. Only Amelia kept a level head, grabbing a jar and collected his cum. Once she filled that one, Chloe handed her another.

Angie laughed as she wiped cum out her eye and said, "Damn it Caleb. Do you always have to get me in the eye?"

More laughter broke out around the room as Lori said, "Yes. It seems like a certain someone is always getting cum in our eyes."

Emily giggled, "Not me. He's never got cum in my eye."

June deadpanned, "Yet."


Caleb’s day passed fairly quickly. Everyone seemed to be talking about the orgy after school and Caleb was bombarded with requests for an invitation. He quickly learned if a woman wanted to talk to him, there was only one reason. He came up with a standard response for all of them.

Each member of his harem and family were only allowed to invite a certain number of people, and he had already invited his limit. It was a little lie, but it kept anyone from getting mad. He promised to have another orgy soon, and that seemed to placate most of them.

His teachers were another matter. Mr. Edwards was in an excellent mood. He hinted that he’d appreciate Caleb coming by the teacher's lounge, but Kathy wanted Caleb well rested for the orgy, and Caleb had promised Emma that he wouldn’t invite the man anymore. He reminded himself that he needed to find out when the room the school was setting aside for him to use would be ready.

Mrs. Lee was also in an excellent mood. She showed the class her positive pregnancy test and again thanked Caleb for breeding her. When one student asked why she took the test since Caleb had bred her, she was certainly pregnant and didn't need proof. Mrs. Lee told them she didn't need proof for herself, she wanted it to show other people.

Caleb noted Deanna’s continued absence but Shannon said she wouldn’t be returning to school for a while. She needed a lot of physical therapy before she could get around. The weight and size of her breasts would take getting used to. Her center of balance was way off now too. Caleb felt sorry for her, but he knew he couldn't cure her unless he created another normality.

In the current reality, since he cured her of Shrew syndrome, his cum made her breasts grow. If he gave her more to fix her breasts, they would just get bigger. If he created another normality related to a woman's breasts, there was no telling what might happen if it conflicted with the others.

For now, he decided on a wait and see approach to that problem.

Later in math class, Priestess Emma kept smirking at Caleb. He had no doubt that she already knew about the events of the previous evening.

While they were working on a quiz, she came over and softly asked, "Your Holiness, would you like to **** fuck me sometime? You don't even have to ask. Just grab me and do whatever you like."

The smirk she had on her face, and the way she bent over in front of him, was a glowing sign of her seriousness. The way her skin tight robes clung to her, and the generous amount of cleavage she was showing woke his cock.

He spent the rest of class with a boner trying to rip through his pants, cursing himself for promising Kathy that he'd save his energy for the orgy.

After class Emma stopped him and said, "The Mother Superior sent a courier to give you this."

She handed him an expensive looking hand bag, inside were a bunch of bras, each one signed and dated.

Emma purred, "Those are from all the priestesses you bred last night, along with the Mother Superior's. She said she heard you collect them."

Emma laughed as Caleb blushed. Then she shooed him out the door.


“None of them are coming. Everyone we asked already has an invitation to Caleb’s orgy.” Wanda waited for Kesha to explode. She braced herself for what she knew was coming. The last time she brought Kesha bad news, Wanda earned a handprint across her face and several kicks to the ribs for her trouble.

Kesha merely smiled and said, “I guess we will just have to crash the party. It’s an orgy. It’s not like they’d kick the hottest girls in school out.”

Wanda thought this was Kesha’s dumbest idea yet. She held her tongue though. Delivering bad news was one thing, deliberately challenging her idea was something totally different.

“Uh, yeah Kesha, but how do we do it? Just drive on in at the gate?”

“That’s exactly what we’re going to do. The orgy will be in the mansion gardens. We won’t even have to set foot in the house. It might take a while for them to even notice we are there. I looked the property up on google Earth, the gardens are huge, with bushes and shrubs and flowerbeds all over the place. If we split up once we are inside, one of us should be able to find Caleb before anyone notices we are even there. Then all that person has to do is send a text in the group chat letting the others know where to find them, and we can take turns riding his cock the rest of the day.”

Wanda blinked. It was a themed orgy. The guests would be in costumes. The cheerleaders would stick out like sore thumbs. There was no guarantee Caleb would even touch one of them. A million and one things were bound to go wrong before they even found Caleb.

Wanda looked around at the other cheerleaders and saw that they were all in on this idiotic idea. Even Ludmilla didn't see how insane the entire thing was.

Wanda wanted Caleb to fuck her just as badly as the rest of them, but was it worth the risk? They could get arrested. She wasn't sure how bad the punishment would be, but all punishments were severe when it came to a Stretcher King.


Holly had never been this deep inside the Pit before. She had walked by it a thousand times, she had admired the flowers and other plants, but never ventured far from the entrance. It wasn’t that she had anything against the Denizens, they just weren’t people she hung out with.

She followed Hazel toward a large shed in the corner that you wouldn’t notice if you were not standing in front of it. There were tall plants and shrubs nearby that hid the shed from view if you weren’t close already.

“Um Hazel, where are you taking me?” She glanced back at the Denizens eating their lunches. Caleb was sitting with his friend Zack and a couple of their other friends, but she didn’t see any of his harem at all.

“Relax, this isn’t a horror movie. No one is going to hurt you. I told you, Kathy wanted to see you.” Hazel said before knocking on the door in an odd pattern. She paused and then knocked again. The door swung open and Hazel pushed Holly inside, closing the door behind them.

It took a moment for Holly’s eyes to adjust to the relatively dark room. Against the back wall of the room Kathy sat on a long couch. Her dress top was loose with her enormous breasts in clear view, or at least one of them was. The other was being sucked on by Coach Katie. Kathy cradled the teacher's head as she lay along the couch Kathy was seated on. The coach was completely nude and Gabbie, their Mexican friend, had her head between Katie's legs. Chris and Angie were laying on a futon on the floor, locked in a sixty-nine.

Kathy smiled and patted the spot beside her saying, "Thank you for coming Holly. Please, come sit beside me and we can talk."

When Holly left at the end of the lunch hour, her head was spinning. All the talk about the Harem Effect was unbelievable, but even Coach Katie told her it was true.

Kathy wanted Holly to be with Caleb, but she had promised not to want her to join the harem. She promised that she would let Holly choose. Kathy told her Caleb would pay for her tuition if she stayed and went to college with the harem, and gave up her scholarship across the country.

The thing that convinced her that everything Kathy said was true, was when Kathy told her she would never want to be with another man, and she would never want to carry a child inside her that did not belong to Caleb. Holly already knew both of those things.

She was uncertain about whether she wanted to stay and give herself to Caleb completely, but she did know two things. Hazel was an expert pussy licker, and Kathy's milk was delicious.


Kathy looked at the girls around her as they redressed. "Well, what do you think?"

Hazel was the first to speak. "She'll stay. No doubt about it. Telling her you wanted her to be with Caleb sealed it. You didn't even have to say she'd never want another man."

Katie nodded in agreement. "Yeah, Kat. I'm a little bothered that you're using the harem effect to drag her in, but... she does have a crush on Caleb. But if Caleb does claim her, you all have to promise me you'll love her, and welcome her as an equal."

Kathy huffed, "Oh please. Of course we will. As soon as she joins us we will all love her. It will be just like it was when he claimed his aunt Lori. We all fell in love with her as soon as he claimed her. I want everyone in the harem to love each other. And what I want, I will get. Caleb is going to get every woman he wants, even if it's just a one time fling. It may seem a bit shady, but I'm okay with it so long as our man is happy."

None of her fellow harem members disagreed with her.


Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)