Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 234 by bobbobbobthethir bobbobbobthethir

What's the plan?

Hanging out with the team

A few minutes later, your team is gathered in the common room, everyone squeezed around the small coffee table at its center. Charlie’s dumped a bunch of beers on the table, having acquired them with his over-21 privileges at a nearby shop. Jason and Keegan have both finished one already, with a second by their side, while Daphne is slowly sipping her way through her first, savoring it like one might a fine tea. The twins are passing a beer between them, both of them looking slightly tipsy already from their earlier activities in the night.

“Truth or dare, huh?” Jason says, knocking back his second can. “I’m drunk enough to play. Who starts?”

“You do, for asking,” Val says, and even as Jason sticks up his finger, she asks: “Truth or dare?”

“Dare,” Jason instantly replies.

“Alright, how about you… take off your shirt,” Val says.

“Bringing up the heat already,” Jason laughs, whipping his shirt off in a moment.

“Not bad,” Val smiles, admiring his fit body.

“I’ve seen better,” Katie says, looking unimpressed.

“Yeah, right,” Jason scoffs. “Well, you’re to the right of me, so you’re going next. Truth or dare?”

Katie meets Jason in the eyes, and without hesitating, replies: “Dare.”

“You know what’s coming for you,” Jason says, motioning with his fingers. “Come on, let’s see what you’ve got under your top.”

“Gladly,” Katie replies, removing her shirt in a smooth motion, revealing the fit curves of her body and a tantalizing dark blue bra. This time, all the guys lean in, admiring the sight before them. Katie has an amazing bust. You could spend all day staring and not get tired of it.

“I do it better, don’t I,” she smirks.

“Hey, you’ll hear no complaints from me,” Jason laughs. “Especially with what’s coming next.”

Khloe, after all, is sitting next to Katie. Before Katie can even begin forming her sentence, Khloe pulls off her shirt too, revealing that her bra is an exact match of her twin’s. The guys all lean in again, getting a good look at Khloe, even though you’ve practically seen the exact thing right next to her. But it’s the identical look that makes it all the more appealing.

“Hot damn, isn’t that a sight for sore eyes,” Charlie says. “And she didn’t even have to be asked!”

“You were going to make me do it, weren’t you?” Khloe asks her twin.

“Spoilsport,” Katie mutters under her breath, but you can tell that they’re both drinking in the attention, loving the looks thrown their way.

Khloe smiles at her sister, blowing her a kiss, and then turns to Keegan by her right and asks: “Truth or dare?”

Keegan, caught staring at the sisters, takes a second to comprehend the question.

“Dare,” he replies, a second later.

Khloe glances at him and gives the hem of his shirt a tug.

“Alright, I’ll take it off,” he says, and so off it goes. You see some appreciative looks from the girls. He’s not quite as much of a gym rat as Jason is, but still, your keeper’s got some good muscle there.

Now, it’s Keegan’s turn to ask, and he turns to Valentine on his right. He gives her a knowing smile.

“Truth or dare?” he asks.

“We might as well all take them off at this point,” Val laughs, pulling off her shirt, and so one by one, they all come off.

Katie, Khloe, Val, Mars, Daphne—each girl is as breathtaking as the last. You can hardly believe your luck, the sudden amount of cleavage on display short-circuiting your brain. And all the other guys have the same reaction, caught slack-jawed, unsure of where to focus your attention when surrounded by all these beauties.

Daphne, who was last to go, is the one to break the silence.

“Good to see that everyone’s keeping fit,” she says drily. “Jason, I think it is your turn to go again. Truth or dare?”

“This party’s just getting started,” Jason says. “Dare me. Let’s see what you got, captain.”

“How about a little fun,” Daphne says. “I dare you to give Valentine a lap dance.”

“Hold up,” Jason says. “Shouldn’t she be the one giving me the lap dance?”

Daphne shakes her head. “I said what I said. You’ve got one minute on the clock,” she says, to plenty of laughter. Charlie puts on some smooth jazz over the speakers and salutes his friend.

“Alright, Val, get ready for the lap dance of your life,” Jason says. He gets up, hands behind his head, shaking his hips side to side as he approaches Val.

“That’s it, shake your money maker,” Val laughs as he sticks his ass in front of her face, gradually shimmying downwards until he’s pressed against her lap. “Oof… though you are a bit heavy.”

“All the more loving to share,” Jason says.

Although he hasn’t quite got a stripper’s moves, he more than makes up for it with enthusiasm. He grinds his ass against Val with gusto, making sure that she can feel every pound of him. He puts his hands to the air, dancing in time with the song, and by the time he gets up, there’s a round of applause. Jason takes a bow, returns to his seat, and then looks meaningfully at Katie.

“Truth or dare?”

“Keep it coming,” Katie says. “Dare me.”

“Let’s keep the show going,” Jason says. “I dare you to make out with a special somebody for a minute.”

“Who’s the lucky guy?” Keegan asks, looking hopeful as hell. But the looks he gets from the twins are enough to make you feel sorry for the guy. They are not interested in him, for whatever reason.

“Not a guy. A girl,” Jason says. “Katie, I want you to make out with Khloe.”

“That’s weak sauce,” Katie smiles, sliding over to put her arm around her sister. “We’ve done far more together.”

“Oh, I know,” Jason laughs. “I’d love to see it all.”

“Pity that some tongue is all you’ll ever get to see,” Katie smirks, and before you know it, the sisters are kissing.

The two of them entwine, shoulder to shoulder, mouth against mouth, making out with surprising ferocity. It’s evident that they’ve got experience with one another—and experience performing for others—from the identical soft moans that escape from their lips to the way they sensuously caress each other in perfect symmetry… clad in only their bras and denim shorts, the sapphic sororal scene is the hottest thing you could have imagined seeing tonight, yet here it is, playing out live before you. You feel the beginnings of your arousal stirring down below. The sight is so erotic, so tantalizing, that you wish that you could somehow join the two of them. In fact, the room’s silence but for those soft moans tells you that you’re all entranced by this sight, and when the timer for a minute goes off, everyone collectively starts, shocked out of the moment as Katie and Khloe break away from each other.

The twins both take a moment to fix their hair, their cheeks also flushed with color, and then Katie turns to Khloe.

“Truth or dare?” she asks.

“Is that even a question?” Khloe asks in return.

“A dare it is,” Katie smiles. “Now I get to have some real fun. Khloe, I dare you to give Keegan a lapdance.”

“Really? Him? You couldn’t have picked anyone else?” Khloe frowns.

“Hey!” Keegan says, just as Katie says: “You know I love you, sister dearest.”

Khloe rolls her eyes, but the smile on Katie’s face only grows wider.

“You’ve got one minute on the clock, starting… now.”

Khloe reluctantly begins to get up, but when Charlie resumes the music, she starts to dance, getting really into it. She moves slowly, teasingly, running her hands down the length of her body. As her hands reach her shorts, she sways down to her knees then goes down on all fours, swaying her ass in the air. She makes direct eye contact with Keegan as she crawls towards him, transfixing him with that gaze of hers. When she reaches Keegan, she slowly rises, hands sliding up his thighs, moving ever closer to that visible lump between his legs. Just as it seems they’re about to make contact, she puts a hand on his shoulder and leans over to his ear, whispering something that makes him go bright pink. She smiles, her hand now hooking around his shoulder as she slides seamlessly into his lap, and it looks like things are just about to step up another notch when the alarm goes off. As it does, Khloe instantly slides off him and returns to her seat.

“Damn, what a show,” Jason says. “Pity it was just getting started.”

“Nice moves,” Val says, just as Keegan says: “If only it could have been a minute more…”

“You wouldn’t have lasted a minute more,” Katie says.

“Yeah yeah yeah, you girls are too hot for me, I get it,” Keegan laughs. “But tell you what, Khloe, you want to get back at your sister? You’re up next, and I got plenty of ideas for you.”

Khloe simply smiles, saying: “Truth or dare?”

“Give me the dare,” Keegan says.

“One minute on the clock, and you get to touch Katie anywhere, clothing on, how does that sound?” Khloe says.

“Say no more,” Keegan smiles, pumping his fist in the air, just as Katie mutters: “Fuck you, fuck you both.”

This time, there’s no swaying or crawling or any of that bullshit. Keegan makes a beeline straight for Katie, who looks pissed at her sister. When he gets there, Keegan freezes like a kid on Christmas day, unsure of where to begin with all his presents. He begins with a soft touch to Katie’s neck and quickly makes his way down to her shoulders, where he massages them for a few good seconds, working on the knots there. Quietly, but unmistakably, a soft moan escapes from Katie’s lips. Keegan grins, working her shoulders for a few seconds longer, but the rest of her body is just too tempting for him to remain there. He begins massaging down the length of her arms, his hands finding his way to her waist from there. He gives her taut stomach and abs the attention they deserve, but it’s clear that there’s a place that he’s been working towards, and when he finally cups her tits through her bra, Keegan goes to town. He takes big handfuls and kneads. Katie’s stacked for her size, and he makes sure to show her just how much he appreciates that with every passing second. When the alarm finally sounds, he pulls his hands away, the pleased look on his face quite possibly the happiest you’ve ever seen him.

“Good, wasn’t it?” Keegan says.

“Keep dreaming,” Katie replies, though everyone can see her stiff nipples poking through her bra.

Khloe gives Keegan an approving nod, and he takes a brief bow, the guys cheering him on. All of you guys, and likely many of the girls too, would have loved to take his place.

“Alrighty, next up, your turn Val,” Keegan says. “Truth or dare?”

“Give me a challenge, give me a dare,” Val says.

“I think it’s time for some other guys to share the fun,” Keegan says. “Val, I dare you to tease Alex as much as you can. Do your best to get him off in a minute, but same as before—you can’t take any of his clothes off!”

“Oh, I like the sound of that,” Val smiles at you devilishly.

When the clock goes off, Val is on you in an instant. She feels up your groin and lets out a pleasant sound when her hand grasps your semi.

“My oh my, what do we have here? I didn’t realize you were such a voyeur,” she says. “I guess you must like seeing all of your teammates half nude…”

“Yeah, Keegan’s got great pecs,” you say, to the laughs of the others.

“Or maybe you’re reacting to something else,” Val smiles, giving your growing hog a good squeeze.

She begins to stroke you off through your pants, your pecker quickly responding to the call to attention. Val grins as you harden up in her hands. Within seconds, you’re straining against your pants, your erect cock begging to be freed.

“I didn’t think a minute would be long enough to get you there, but you look awfully pent-up to me,” she smiles.

“My my my, is Alex a quickshot?” Khloe asks, looking at you with great interest in her eyes.

“I’m not cumming anytime soon,” you say, but somehow, it sounds unconvincing even to you.

“We’ll see about that,” Val laughs.

She suddenly deathgrips you, clenching your cock hard in her hand, while her other one finds the underside of your balls. The sudden stimulation has you bucking your hips in a quick motion, and you hear a giggle from the twins. You glare at them, gesturing at your still hard cock. You haven’t cum yet, and, contrary to what they might think, you’re not even close.

“Are you still getting harder?” Val asks.

“I’d be surprised if you could get me fully erect,” you say. “You’ll have to try harder than that.”

“I do like a challenge,” Val grins, and she seems about to take it a step further, when the alarm goes off.

“Guess this is as far as it goes,” you laugh.

“You forget, it’s my turn now,” Val says. “Truth or dare?”

“What’s the dare?” you ask her.

“I dare you to take the rest of your clothes off. Show us how hard you really are,” she says.

“Now things are really heating up,” Charlie laughs.

He starts up the music again, and you get up, hooking your thumbs into the waistband of your pants. Slowly, leisurely, you drop them, revealing the sizeable contours of your bulge against your boxers. You glance around the room, revelling in the looks that you’re getting back in return. You’ve got something worth showing off and now the girls all know it, too.

“Don’t stop there,” Val calls out.

“So impatient,” you smile, now playing around with the hem of your boxers.

This time, instead of doing a slow tease, you instantly whip them off, revealing your rock hard cock to the world. It stands tall and proud at attention. No doubt that Val, and the rest of the night, has done its trick.

You see Mars’ eyes instantly go dishpan wide, while Jason lets out a whistle.

“Mmm, that looks kind of nice,” Katie says, glancing at Khloe, who nods back at her twin.

Out of the corner of your eye, you see Daphne biting her lip, and then she covers her face. As you pull your boxers back on, you turn to Mars, sitting next to you.

“So, what do you want?” you ask her.

Her gaze flicks down to your crotch, and then back at you, puzzled.

“Truth or dare?” you laugh.

“That was evil,” she laughs. “I hate to take it down a notch, but I don’t think I can match what you just did. I’ll go with truth.”

“Fair play,” you say. You were expecting a dare, but now that you need a truth, you blurt out the first question that comes to mind for a truth: “How about you tell us… pick your dream threesome out of those of us in the room.”

“Now that’s an interesting question,” Mars says, cracking a smile. She thinks for a second, and then says: “I’m spoiled for choice. Ask me tomorrow and it could change. But for today, I’m going to go with… Alex and Daphne. I think the three of us could be hot.”

You and Daphne instantly look at each other, and then glance away. Then you look at Mars, who winks at you.

“I thought you were trying to take it down a notch, not turn me on more,” you say.

“Not saying it’s happening,” Mars shrugs. “Plus, you’d have to get Daphne on board.”

Daphne shakes her head vehemently, saying: “I could never sleep with my juniors, it would be so inappropriate…”

“So boring,” Val says, feigning a yawn. “On that note, I have to run now, but I’ll catch you all tomorrow!”

“I’m… I’m also getting tired, I need to get some sleep for the drive tomorrow,” Daphne says, making her exit behind Val.

You wonder at her motivations, but with the departure of the two girls, the rest of the room begins to slowly empty out, everyone retiring for the night. You soon find yourself back in your bedroom, reflecting on the game that was just played. It went further than you expected, but at the same time… you can’t help but wish that more could have come of it. Or, maybe, could it be a sign of things to come?

Mars +10
Valentine +10
Daphne +10
Katie +10
Khloe +10
Keegan +10
Jason +10
Charlie +10

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)