Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by Shl33 Shl33

What's next?

Blownup

The day's overload of attention at the office had left him buzzing—flushed from the constant flirting, touches, and stares—but also drained, like he'd run a marathon of ego boosts. He kicked off his shoes, grabbed a cold soda from the fridge, and flopped onto the couch, intending to unwind with some mindless scrolling before gamer night. But as soon as he pulled out his phone, it erupted like a digital fireworks show. Pings, buzzes, notifications stacking up faster than he could swipe them away. Friend requests on Facebook, Instagram DMs, Snapchat adds, even old-school texts from numbers he vaguely recognized. Women from his past—high school flames, crushes, near-misses—flooding in, compelled by the New Rule he'd scribbled last night. It was kinda overwhelming, a tidal wave of attention that tested those "limits he could and couldn't handle," but damn if it didn't thrill him, that twisted craving finally fed on overdrive.

He'd dodged bullets with all these women back in the day, each one carrying their own baggage: cheaters, flakes, incompatibilities that screamed "red flag." Yet here they were, resurfacing like ghosts, their messages a mix of casual nostalgia and brazen inappropriateness, laced with that nervous excitement the rule imposed. Steve scrolled through the chaos, heart racing, a smirk creeping across his face as the deluge unfolded. At least 30 had hit him up so far—old classmates from his suburban Chicago high school, community college flings, even a few from early jobs—each one either friending him anew or dusting off dormant connections.

Shana Dross was one of the first to pop up, his ex from senior year who'd cheated with his then-best friend, leading to a messy breakup that left him bitter for months. She'd been lingering as a Facebook friend all along, but her DM hit like a blast: "Steve! OMG, it's been forever. You look so hot in your profile pic—have you been working out? Remember our nights? I'd kill for a redo... no strings, just fun." It was wildly inappropriate, followed by nervous texts: "Idk why I'm saying this, but I can't stop thinking about you." Steve chuckled darkly—he'd dodged her drama queen tendencies and serial infidelity.

Then came Melissa Mansfield, the little sister of that same ex-best friend, adding a layer of irony. They'd dated briefly in high school, a sweet but awkward fling overshadowed by family ties. Her friend request arrived with a message: "Hey stranger! Saw your posts and had to reach out. You're killing it these days. Coffee sometime? Miss our talks." It started casual, but she quickly sent a selfie in a low-cut top, captioned: "What do you think?" Her clinginess had always been the issue, treating relationships like a security blanket. Bullet dodged.

Savannah Sable followed suit, another high school girlfriend who'd sparked that electric webcam session back in the early 2000s—grainy 10fps slideshows of pixelated bliss, him jerking off while she played with her pussy over dial-up lag. It had felt revolutionary at the time. But she'd admitted to wanting to "date other guys while with him," phrasing it like "we could stay exclusive if you just say so," which screamed opportunist always eyeing trade-ups. Her Instagram DM: "Steve!! Blast from the past. You were my fave—remember our 'shows'? Let's recreate, but HD this time. My place?" Super inappropriate, with a nervous emoji spam: "This is weird, but I had to message you!" He'd dodged her wandering eye and the string of failed marriages that followed, from what he'd heard through the grapevine.

Kerry Michaela—yeah, two first names, courtesy of her quirky parents—was next, the skinny girl from junior year he'd tried to hook up with at a party, only to realize mid-makeout he wasn't into her rail-thin frame and tiny A-cups; it felt mismatched, and they fizzled awkwardly. Her text from an unknown number: "Is this Steve? Kerry here—high school? You've aged like fine wine. Drinks? Or more?" She kept it somewhat casual at first but attached a mirror selfie in lingerie, adding: "Feeling bold today, idk why!" Her insecurity and pushiness had always been turn-offs, seeking validation through endless hookups. Glad he bailed early.

Allison Gibraltar hit different, though—his ultimate high school crush, the 5'6 bombshell with that impossible pear shape: small B-cup tits up top, but an ass so massive and round it turned heads in the hallways, jiggling like it had its own gravity. Kids teased her about her "horse face" (long features, strong jaw), tanking her confidence, but Steve saw majesty in her shy smile and killer curves. They'd flirted but never dated; he chickened out asking her to prom. Her Facebook message: "Steve Thompson? Wow, it's Allie. You were always so sweet to me back then. Looking great now—want to catch up? Maybe dinner?" More casual than the others, but she sent a recent photo highlighting that legendary ass in yoga pants, with a hesitant note: "Not sure why I'm reaching out, but here goes!" Her self-doubt had led to toxic relationships later, but Steve still felt a pang of what-if.

The floodgates stayed open from there, with the rest pouring in like a whirlwind of names and faces from his past. Emily Roth, the cheerleader type always prone to drama, messaged casually: "Hey hunk! Long time. Up for a reunion?" But she attached a nude from "old times," pushing it into inappropriate territory. Rachel Kim, the smart but controlling Asian-American classmate, sent a friend request with: "Steve, you're thriving! Let's link up—I've missed your vibe." Followed by a nervous: "This feels random, sorry!" Tara Jennings, the party girl with substance issues, went explicit: "Remember me? Let's get wild again. Naked pics incoming..." He'd dodged her downward spiral for sure.

Lindsay Hale, the quiet bookworm turned clingy, kept it light at first: "Hi Steve! Saw your profile. Coffee?" But escalated to "I need to see you soon—why now? Idk." Brooke Sanders, the vain fitness nut, flirted hard: "Damn, Steve, you're fine. Gym date? I'll spot you... everywhere." Natalie Vargas, the flaky artist, invited: "Art show? Or just us? Feeling drawn to you suddenly." Sophia Chen, another Asian ex-fling with jealous streaks, pleaded: "Steve! Reunite? I've changed... promise."

And on it went—Vanessa, Katie, Jenna, Mia, Olivia, and a dozen more, some sending thirst traps with captions like "You inspire me—here's proof!" while others stayed casual with "Old friends? Let's chat!" All laced with that rule-induced nervousness: "This is out of nowhere, but..." Issues ranged from gold-digging (one hinted suspiciously at his "success") to emotional baggage (breakup sob stories begging for closure).

Steve's phone vibrated non-stop for over an hour, the screen a blur of hearts, eggplants, and winky faces. Overwhelming? Absolutely—his thumbs ached from scrolling, and a part of him wondered if he'd overdone the rule. But the thrill outweighed it, that sick craving sated as he imagined the chaos rippling through their lives. He replied to a few casually, stringing them along for fun, but mostly basked in the glow. Dinner and gaming awaited, but first, he muted notifications for sanity's sake. Tomorrow, the mirror arrived—shapeshifting time. For now, he was king of the attention avalanche.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)