Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by Cross C Cross C

What should I do?

He confesses.

Damn. As much as I wanted to slide my cock between Lucy's beautiful round globes, I couldn't do it.

Thanks to Salamander's little Charm ring I knew exactly how Lucy felt about guys who would use this kind of magic to take advantage of her. I don't think these earrings made her like me but I couldn't just go on without telling her about them.

If she ended up hating me... well, so be it. I liked her and I didn't want to treat her that way.

My hands shook a little as I raised them to take off the earrings. I felt myself hesitating and in a rush I quickly took them off.

I closed my eyes and waited, expecting the worst.

“Najato? What's wrong?” asked Lucy, her voice getting closer, “You look like you're expecting to get slapped any second.”

I opened one eye to see her looking at me curiously, “Um... Aren't I?”

She looked confused, “Why would I slap you?”

I sighed and held out the earrings, “See these? They're magic. I think. I didn't know. I just figured it out but they make it so that everything I do seems normal to people.”

I expected her eyes to widen as she thought back to everything that had happened today and saw it all in a new light, instead her cute eyebrows drew closer together, “That's kind of a lame magic, isn't it?”

“Maybe but think about it. I could just walk up to you and grab- uh... well your boobs and you'd let me because you'd think it was normal.”

I finally saw a little surprise in her eyes as she crossed her arms over her chest and half turned away before she visibly relaxed and smiled a little, “Or maybe I just like you and that's why I'd let you do that.”

Okay. That was nice to know but how could I know what was real and wasn't some lingering influence of the earrings, “Sure, but with the earrings I could have done that first thing before we'd gone on our date and gotten to know each other! I mean- you just changed your clothes right in front of me. I saw you naked!”

This time I saw a full look of consternation twist her features as she recalled doing that. But she quickly rationalized it, “Again... I like you and maybe I'm just feeling adventurous today? And why not? I'm going to get to join Fairy Tail, Najato! This is a dream come true!” Her eyes widened and she continued, “Gosh! We've got to go if we're going to be on time!” She started to move only to stop short as she looked at me closely, “Those clothes! You can't go to the party like that, Najato!”

“That's what I'm talking about, Lucy! Think about it. You didn't notice my clothes until after I took the earrings off.” I stared at her in the hopes that this would shake something loose but she just gave me a blank look. Okay, time to go for broke. “Do you remember sucking my cock, Lucy? My 'birthday blowjob'? There's no way you can believe that is normal!”

Expecting shock and sudden hatred, the first real annoyance crossing Lucy's beautiful face was sort of a relief even if it failed to accomplish my goal entirely, “I could hardly forget, Najato. I thought you liked it. I'm sorry if it wasn't normal or whatever but you know I'm not exactly used to oversized dicks, you know?”

I stared at her in horror even though I knew her sarcastic comment was a rather moderate rebuke. I liked Lucy too much and had enjoyed our day together too much after so long with nothing. I could very easily see me putting my foot into my mouth over and over again without the earrings and turning her obvious affection for me into disgust and disdain. I absolutely hated the thought of Lucy treating me like all those stuck up women from before, not after experiencing how wonderful it was to see the side of her I'd spent with all day.

So I put the earrings back on, resolving to figure out a way to break the truth to her after I'd given it some long careful thought.

Lucy was still looking at me, waiting for me to respond. It seemed like she was less impatient than before and I felt free to ignore the issue entirely, “Is it really oversized?”

She smirked, “Sure is. Though I didn't say it was a bad thing, did I?”

I walked over to her and held out my elbow for her to take which she did and we left her room as I asked, “Are you very sure? Because Aquarius called it massive and I found that a bit concerning...”

Lucy giggled behind her hand before continuing, “Because it is! Its scary-big! In a good way! I mean-it's not just long, its super thick!”

I grinned, “Oh so you like having a boyfriend with a big dick, huh?” We were were walking past quite a few people within the inn's first floor entrance and I loved that no one blinked an eye at the subject of our conversation.

“I do! Watching Aquarius struggle to get you down her throat was really ar- er exciting!”

I was honestly curious about that and with the earrings, I felt free to ask, “Heh. I noticed that. So, is that normal for you... to get really turned on at seeing the well hung guy you're with have sex with other women?”

Lucy actually blushed and looked away even as the side of her breast came into fuller contact with my arm between us, “You got me. Yea, I guess it is. Honestly, I've never actually experienced it before today but I've thought about it. A lot.”

I absolutely loved the way it felt to be able to ask her whatever I want. I gave her a wicked grin as I said, “You mean when you play with yourself late at night?”

She blushed even more as she smiled and nodded.


This party was weird.

The ship's enormous open deck, taking up half the vessel's length, had a bunch of round tables and one big long one with all the tiny little things being called food. That wasn't what made it strange. That would be that it was populated entirely by women and two males. Salamander and me. And I'm pretty sure that if it weren't for the earrings, then the rough looking men at the gangway would have kept me from getting on board.

I hadn't seen any of those men lately, I guess they were inside running the ship. But I really hadn't liked the way they'd been eying the women, Lucy in particular.

I had resolved to stay by Lucy's side the entire evening, knowing full well there would be no one willing to stop me.

That is except for Lucy, that is.

I watched her closely as she approached a group of five women. She'd told me to stay put. That she had a surprise for me. I figured as long as I could see her, it would be fine. Besides that glowy bastard was on the other side of the deck being fawned on by at least ten ladies.

Soon enough she returned accompanied by the women.

I was rather self conscious at being the center of attention of so many very attractive women (Salamander didn't invite anything less...), even with the power of my earrings, so I just looked at my feet awkwardly.

Lucy swept in against my side and happily declared, “Ladies! This is Najato and I have the great pleasure to tell you that it is his birthday and he hasn't had his blowjob yet!”

I'd really like to say that all of them jumped for joy at the opportunity but only one broke out into a smile and looked interested. A tall brunette raised an eyebrow, “Really? A guy holding out all day for a birthday blowjob?”

A lovely dark skinned girl with closely cropped hair nodded, “Yea. For most men that's a 'before breakfast blowjob'.”

I was a bit shocked myself and looked to Lucy. She winked and nodded. Oh. Right. I'd somehow lucked into not only finding a magic pair of earrings but a girlfriend who really enjoyed seeing my do stuff with other women. Seriously, I needed to go back in time and slap that depressing mope of a Najato who woke up this morning. Kid didn't know a thing. Right. With growing confidence thanks to Lucy at my side, I boldly lied, “Nope. I sure haven't. Do you think you guys would mind?”

The brunette sighed, “No of course not. But why can't she give it to you?” she nodded in Lucy's direction as a redhead declared, “I wish it was Salamander's birthday...”

I opened my mouth but Lucy beat me to it with a hand resting on my chest, “Because I'm going out with him! Who wants a birthday blowjob from your girlfriend? He can get those anytime.” To me, she whispered, “We are totally not to that point yet so don't get any ideas.”

“Alright-alright. Well, who do you want one from?”

By this point I was pretty aroused and completely achingly hard in my pants, so I didn't need any prompting from Lucy to say, “Well, I'm told its pretty...massive so... how does... all of you, sound?”

I had five beautiful women on their knees as they slathered my cock with their tongues and mouths. They were each wearing very fine dresses, their faces all made up, twinkling earrings dangling with their movements. Have I told you how this is the best birthday ever?

I was leaning back against one table. Lucy was doing the same across from me, her eyes watching the action intently, her nipples like bullets standing out from her dress. She really did like this sort of thing, didn't she?

“Aha! There you are, my dear!” And there's one blue haired fop come to ruin my day. He sidled up to Lucy who slipped away with a hasty glare. “Awe... Don't be like that! With your... fellow there otherwise engaged, I thought we'd go somewhere private to discuss my recommendation for your entry into my guild... Fairy Tail.”

Ugh. Those two words were like a magical talisman all in themselves as they abruptly evaporated the open expression of disgust and negativity Lucy had been wearing all throughout his speech up till that point.

I tried to catch her eye and furiously signal my disagreement but that haughty brunette did something amazing with her tongue and the head of my cock. My open mouth found no words of protest, instead I groaned and shuddered.

When I managed to compose myself, I could only watch as Lucy and that damned mage walked away, heading towards one of the doors to the inside of the ship. Damn it! I had to do something! I struggled to go after them only to be held fast by the five women currently very vigorously holding on to my cock.

What happens next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)