Better than expected!

"What in the Hell is going on in here?!" your stepmom Claire demands, arms crossed and scowling.

You don't know what to say, but you're pretty sure "Oh, nothing, mom, just gagging and assfucking my younger sister with my best friend" won't go over very well. Tommy is slowly backing away into the closet like a coward.

Before you can muster a response, though, Rachel breaks the silence. "Mom, it's been awful! First David stormed in here this morning and stuck his penis down my throat and even in my butt, it hurt so bad and I thought I was going to ****! Then he sprayed his cu-- uh, semen in my mouth and made me swallow it all! He came back with Tommy later and they did it to me again only worse, and they even put themselves inside my butt and privates at the same time!" She stops and starts to sob. You're pretty sure she's exaggerating the crying to make you look worse... some of the crying, at least.

"You DOUBLE PENETRATED your own little sister?!" Claire asks you, astounded. "Who got her ass?"

The second question seems a little odd, you're not sure why that matters at this point. "Um, Tommy did..." you answer, confused.

"Dude! Don't sell me out!" Tommy complains from behind Rachel's clothing rack.

Rachel continues, between sniffles, "They kept making me gag on their coc-- uh, penises, and made me swallow a bunch of their sperm, until eventually they came back a THIRD time, and I was exhausted and couldn't take any more, and Tommy made me **** so bad that I threw up, it was horrible! Then David jiz-- uh, ejaculated inside my butt and now I'm covered in all this mess! Oh thank God you're home, Mom!"

Rachel only ever calls Claire "Mom" when she's trying to get a favor from her. You know she's trying to ham it up. It seems weird that she'd even NEED to be dramatic, given the glaring obviousness of your crime.

Claire glares at you. "You fucked your kid sister THREE TIMES today?!" she asks, incredulous. "And you, Tommy, my stepdaughter VOMITTED on your dick?!" She points at the mess continuing to drip from Rachel. "So now you two have left a massive load of ejaculate in poor Rachel's ass, I see?"

"Uh, I didn't cum... uh, finish... uh, ejaculate this last time, that was just David," says Tommy, desperately trying to excuse himself from guilt.

"Oh really?" Claire sounds unimpressed. "So what finally stopped you from taking things all the way with my TEENAGE, HIGH SCHOOLER daughter?!"

"W-well, uh, STEP-daughter, and she's 18, so technically..." Tommy stammers

"Shut the fuck up, Tommy. Answer the question."

Tommy is still hiding in Rachel's closet, afraid to come out and face Claire. You're just relieved she seems to be focusing her anger on him and not you.

"Well, Claire, thing is, I guess, I WANTED to finish, er, ejaculate in Rachel's ass, uh, butt? Anus?"

"Out with it."

"Right, well I WANTED to, but I didn't want to do it while David's, uh, semen was still in there... He was gonna make her clean herself out but she refused, and then you got home and now here we are. Aw, gee, Claire, look, I'm really sorry..."

"Don't be," she replies, matter-of-factly.

Now it's your and Tommy's turn to stare, dumbfounded.

"Wait... WHAT?" you ask, agape.

"Don't be sorry, honey, it's not your fault. Though, Tommy DID get her ass last time, so you certainly had first rights to her ass this time, but if he still wants it, Rachel should know better."

A sheepish grin creeps over your face. You have a feeling what's coming next. You look back to Tommy, who's now returning from behind Rachel's clothing rack. He silently mouths "WHAT. THE. FUCK." to you, and you give him a wink back.