More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 91

What's next?

Girl's Day

Donna had never had so much fun in her life. It was the perfect day.

"Donna, zip me up! I can't wait to see what this looks like!" Aynsley said presenting her back to Donna and awaiting her help. In fact Aynsley and Madison had both requested help dressing from Donna, Eliza, and even Indira. The three of them were so relieved.

Madison had been the one to tell them at the beginning that they needed a clear chain of command, but Donna had sensed some trepidation in the girl to truly take her place at the top. Aynsley was less resistant, but ever followed Madison. But Donna had learned so much from Eliza's lectures on the history of social structures when multiple women shared a man, and she understood now that even though Aynsley was a girlfriend, it was right to show Madison deference. Aynsley of course could order her around as much as she wanted to, but it was good to see she knew who was boss.

Donna was just glad it wasn't her for once!

Ever since her dear departed husband passed away, Donna had been in charge of everything. She had to raise two daughters alone, and take care of her mother-in-law, while at the same time working a demanding career as a lawyer. Donna had always had to be the responsible one, the one making the decisions. She hadn't realized how exhausting that was until she had Joey and his girlfriends in her life. Of course the other friends she had made in their impromptu sisterhood were there to support her, she knew that, but with Madison and Aynsley it was different.

This whole shopping trip had been a revelation.

Part of what made it so special was that Donna hadn't had a girl group in forever. She loved listening to Madison and Aynsley talk about the drama of living in a sorority, or Eliza's gossip about her fellow professors, even listening to Indira talk about how exciting her freshman year was a treat. She got to see the world through so many different points of view, got to live vicariously, while also offering her own experiences to a group of women who were eager to listen to her. To share their excitement, their fears, their hopes, and, of course, their love of Joey. They were their to build each other up, and Donna was glad she could often her fashion expertise to the group. Though Madison was no slouch herself, she still hadn't fully matured in her understanding of how best to accentuate a woman's body with class and refinement. But she had good instincts, and Donna was happy to help nurture them.

And yet, she also felt cared for. Every time Madison or Aynsley told her to fetch them a new dress, or lacey undergarment, every time they asked her to take pictures for them, Donna felt her own burdens seem to melt away. When Madison had commanded her to give her a neck massage, it had filled Donna with such pride and joy, knowing that she was doing her part to help Joey's girlfriend. It was fulfilling in ways she didn't have words to describe.

They had spent the first hour of their outing at the lingerie store, mostly playing with Indira and Eliza as Donna and Joey's girlfriends encouraged them to expand their wardrobes, and encouraged the shier women. At first they had said it wasn't necessary to spend money on them, but Madison had wisely reminded Eliza of her duty to Joey, and how the more items of clothing he had to admire her in, the more he would be encouraged to pick out her clothing. Indira still hadn't developed any feelings for Joey, but she caved when Aynsley and Madison pleaded with her. Indira knew how much fun it would be for them, but Donna thought it was good for the girl. She needed the confidence boost.

Now though, they were down to business. Donna was in her element as she helped the girls craft the perfect outfits for the evening. She had selected a number of options for each girl, but was particularly proud of the purple halter dress she had found for Aynsley. She zipped it up, and admired her handiwork.

"So? What do you think?" Aynsley said, as Donna finished zipping it.

"The real question is if Joey is going to pull it off of you first, or are you going to pull him off first? See for yourself." Donna said, turning Aynsley around so the girl could see her reflection in the mirror of the dressing room.

"God, Joey's going to die," Aynsley said. "Can you imagine? He's going to literally lose his mind."

Donna chuckled. "That's the idea, darling."

"Very elegant." Eliza said, nodding in approval.

"But still a little slutty!" Indira said. Donna was surprised, but pleased to see the girl loosen up a bit.

"Aw Indira, you've come so far." Madison said, stroking Indira's cheek in admiration.

"I couldn't have said it better myself." Donna said.

"You're such a flatterer Donna." Madison said, giggling, before turning to Eliza. "Eliza leave us for a moment, ask that eager little clerk out there to get us another round of Mimosas, would you please?"

Eliza nodded and left the large fitting room, another perk of Donna being such a valued customer at this particular boutique. The staff practically drooled every time Donna flashed her black card, and Donna was happy to enjoy the perks with her girls. Some of the Junior Associates at the firm had given her odd looks when she left the office mid-deposition when Madison had texted her. But what did Donna care? She was a partner, and they were fresh out of law school. She didn't want to lose her job, but it wasn't nearly as important as what she was doing here.

Donna heard Aynsley and Madison giggling, as Indira blushed deeply, and realized how lost in thought she had been.

"Did I miss something?" Donna said.

"You could say that..." Indira said.

"Shhh! Listen!" Aynsley said.

Donna instantly closed her mouth, and cocked her head. At first she wasn't sure what to listen for. There was the hum of the lights, the muted bustle of the mall, generic pop music playing from the speakers. Then she heard it.

Moaning.

"Oh my!" Donna said. Her first instinct was shock and indignation, but that was the old Donna talking. The uptight one who didn't realize that Joey was the perfect guy. The one who had been afraid of her own sexuality. She shared a conspiratorial smile with the other girls. "Sounds like someone is enjoying themselves."

"Who do you think is hooking up in a dressing room?" Indira asked, genuinely confused.

"That's a good question!" Aynsley said, beaming at Indira before giving her a big hug. "I'm so glad our girl is finally thirsty for some juicy tea."

"You're right Ayns! Donna go check it out for us! We want that hot goss. Emphasis on the hot." Madison said, before she and the other girls descended into more giggles, even Indira joining in this time.

Donna rolled her eyes at the pun. It was an odd task, but in truth she had been itching for new orders ever since Aynsley had tried on this dress that was so clearly the right one for her date with Joey. Though it didn't compare to having his hands roving her body.

She pushed the thought out of her mind. If Donna started going down that road, she might get jealous of Madison and Aynsley for getting the night with Joey. True she had gotten a taste of having her body used by him as she assisted Bianca. But she wanted more. But she knew Joey was right. They couldn't fight over him. She didn't want that. Aynsley and Madison deserved some time alone with him. Donna would get her turn. Eliza was already teaching Madison how to properly organize and maintain a schedule between all the women, and of course she trusted Joey wouldn't abandon her. But she wanted him to use her so bad!

For now though Donna would focus on how much fun she was having giving herself over to Madison and the others. And at that moment she had a job to do. Stepping out of the private fitting room she made her way to where the normal customers changed. Whoever was getting randy in the boutique was trying their hardest not to be conspicuous, and yet they couldn't help but let out the occasional moan or giggle. Donna couldn't wait to report back to Madison, as she locked onto the source of the sound.

Did Madison want her to barge in on the couple? Donna thought about the wording of Madison's command. As much wicked glee she might get for busting up a couple of randy customers for doing hanky panky in the store, she didn't relish the thought of bursting in on strangers having sex. They may be fucking in public, but Donna would gather only as much int-

'Wait a minute.' Donna thought to herself.

She recognized that voice.

Her face flushed with anger. Surprise.

All thoughts of leaving the horny patrons in peace left her mind as she pulled back the curtain of the changing room, to see some dark haired girl going down on her daughter.

Donna instantly regretted it. She had acted on instinct. She knew that Nicky wasn't a virgin, and she supported both of her daughters in exploring their sexuality. That didn't mean she wanted to see it though, and now she tried as hard as she could to forget the sight.

"Mom?!" Nicky said, her voice hitching in her voice.

"I'm sorry! I was just coming over... At first I didn't know it was you! Then I recognized your voice and-" Donna said, getting defensive, and wishing she could be anywhere else.

"And you just barged in on me having sex with my girlfriend!" Nicky said.

"So I'm your girlfriend already, huh?" Donna heard the other woman say. Her back was still turned, but she did admit she wanted to see who Nicky's new girlfriend was.

"Yeah! I mean uh... you know if you want." Nicky said.

"I would! It's just I've never had a relationship this fast before." the other voice said.

"You were the ones who were having sex in public, which I might remind you is illegal!" Donna hissed.

"And you peeped!" Nicky said.

"I'm sorry! You're right I shouldn't have. It was just that Madison said-" Donna started before the Nicky's girlfriend cut in.

"Wait, do you mean Madison Ashford? Is she here?!" the woman said.

"Why yes." Donna said, turning around out of instinct. Thankfully both girls were dressed. "Do you know her?"

"Duh! We're in the same sorority. Please excuse your daughter for not introducing us, Mrs. Fowler, we were a bit surprised. My name is Taylor Vasquez. Nicky, come on let's go say hi! This is a total sign from the universe. Let me show you off!" Taylor said.

Donna liked that. Not only was she glad Nicky's new girlfriend was so proud of her daughter, but also because she was proud to see her daughter dating a friend of Madison's. One who was attractive, and knew how to be polite. That could be a good influence on Nicky. Donna had tried to teach her daughter manners but Nicky never quite cared for them. But at least Taylor seemed to be interested in some of the things Nicky was. The way this girl talked about signs from the universe reminded her of all that tarot and astrology and crystals that Nicky was always talking about. They seemed to be a good match.

"We have a fitting room to ourselves, why don't I go check that everyone is decent?" Donna said. She did desperately want to learn more about this new girl in her daughter's life, but was all too cognizant of the fact that Madison hadn't given her any instructions on whether to bring anyone into their dressing room. Besides, considering the importance of this outing as some sisterly bonding in the group, she wasn't sure if the others would want to add anyone. Especially since it meant they would have to be careful what they said around these two. Even if Nicky was Donna's daughter, and Joey's best friend, Joey's safety came first.

Donna was so glad she didn't have to make this choice herself, and excused herself as she went back to Madison.

Madison freaked out.

"OMG what?! I told Taylor she should ask out Nicky, but that was this morning. Now you're telling me they're dating!" Madison said.

"That's bananays." Aynsley said.

"Totally. I have to hear this. Donna invite them in."

"Yes! I'm dying to learn more about Joey! Not that your stories from when he was little aren't helpful Donna, or your research on that One Piece cartoon, which I promise I will study more later, but I want that BFF lore!"

Madison nodded in vigorous agreement as Eliza walked in.

"Yes that might be very helpful but remember-" the professor said.

"We know Eliza, we won't compromise your career, and we'll be very careful explaining all of this to them so that Joey is protected too. And if it looks like we do, you have my permission to shush us, now go get them Donna!" Madison said with a whoop of excitement.

Donna nodded, and walked back out. There would have to be some explanations of course for why she was there with those girls. That could get awkward, but it was bound to happen eventually. Besides, she was eager to learn more about this new woman in her daughter's life. If Madison vouched for her, than she must be special.

When Donna walked back to the changing rooms, Taylor was smoothing out a gorgeous red bodycon dress, and Nicky! Donna's eyes got a little misty seeing her daughter. Nicky had always been more interested in hoodies, and graphic t-shirts with old video games, or horror films on them. Nicky was never interested in the fashion magazines that Donna and Juniper had devoured. But now! Maybe all of Donna's work trying to teach her daughter had finally paid off.

It still wasn't a dress, Donna couldn't remember a time when Nicky ever wore one willingly, but her look was stunning. Nicky had selected a pantsuit in a light blue that highlighted her daughter's auburn hair, and paired it with a bright red strapless crop-top. It was feminine, but not quite girly. It was mature. It reminded Donna that Nicky was no longer the little girl who would play action figures with Joey, she was a grown woman. Donna was so proud, she nearly fumbled the words as she invited Nicky and Taylor to join the others.

Nicky blushed for a moment, babbling an excuse about not wanting to see the other girls naked. Donna and Taylor laughed.

"That's sweet babe, but I know you only have eyes for me." Taylor said.

"You've been in a locker room before dear, there's nothing Madison and Aynsley and the others have that you don't. Trust me." Donna said. "Now stop being a prude and come along."

Nicky gulped. Donna wondered if her daughter's sudden prudishness had anything to do with this new foray into embracing her body. Maybe she was scared of showing the others her new look. Donna wouldn't have thought her daughter would be one to fornicate in public either. Maybe it was just part of exploring new things in college. Either way it was clear Donna needed to catch up with her. It had been forever since the two had talked, especially after Joey and the other girls became such a big focus in her life. This would be good. She was glad Madison had chosen to invite them.

As they walked back into the private fitting room. Madison and Aynsley erupted into a fit of excited squeals as they rushed to look at the new couple. They fawned equally over the two girls.

"Oh my gawd! Taylor you dirty girl!" Aynsley said bouncing on the balls of her feet so quickly her breasts were in danger of falling out of the halter top. "Hooking up in the mall with Nicky Fowler?! I'm so proud."

"Nicky!" Madison said hugging the girl. "I am so soooo happy to meet you! I mean, we've gone to the same school forever and we've like never even talked. I am such a bitch sometimes, but I want to everything about you. Especially now that me and Aynsley are dating Joey! I know I've been the worst, but I hope you can forgive me. You're so important to Joey, and I really hope we can be friends."

Donna exchanged a quick glance with Eliza and Indira. Apparently it was common knowledge Joey was in a throuple, but how would Madison and Aynsley explain the presence of a professor, Nicky's mom, and some random freshman. Eliza kept her face level, and Donna understood what the other woman was implying. They needed to follow Madison and Aynsley's lead on this. It was a bit nerve-wracking, but they trusted Madison and Aynsley, as much as they trusted each other. This group may have been new, but already their bond was unbreakable. Already they didn't need words to communicate. They had faith in each other. Completely.

"Thanks. I have to say, I was a bit surprised at first when Joey said he was dating not one, but two of the most popular girls in Theta Upsilon. Not that he doesn't deserve it though! I would never get in the way of Joey's romantic relationships." Nicky said. That was a good start, Donna started to relax before Nicky continued "So what brings you all here together?"

"Well, to be honest your mom, and the others have been helping me and Ayns get ready for a date with Joey." Madison said.

"Plus we needed to help Professor Matthews with her fashion sense, Indira too. But look at you Nicky! You look so good. You are like totally giving corporate girlie and I am here for it!" Aynsley said gushing over Nicky.

"Thanks! I actually have been trying to be a bit more cool." Nicky said.

"But not too cool I hope. You know I have a thing for nerdy girls." Taylor said, giving Nicky a quick peck on the cheek.

That was good to hear. Donna's heart glowed to think that Nicky found someone who really accepted her.

"So do I have you to thank for getting my daughter into such a fabulous outfit?" Donna said, smiling warmly at Taylor.

"No, I'm more in the getting Nicky out of clothing department." Taylor said with a giggle, before turning red. "Not that I'm just with your daughter for her body! I meant that Nicky actually picked it out. I was honestly pretty surprised myself, but she told me how much you taught her about fashion."

"Plus." Nicky said, clearly worried that Madison and Aynsley would think she was a momma girl. "I had a really good talk with Joey today. He was the one that helped me see that I should be more cool and accept my body."

"He was the one that made us realize we just could not wait until the Formal to go out with each other." Taylor said, beaming. "I see what you two see in him."

"If it is just the two of you." Nicky said, her eyes now moving to Donna, Eliza, and Indira.

The room was tense for a moment. Donna looked to Madison. Madison's face was still pleasant, but there was something serious in her eyes. She nodded. Donna understood.

"Well, dear, you see it's a bit complicated. We're not all dating Joey. Only Madison and Aynsley. I have, however, gotten... closer with him. He was the one in fact who brought us together, helped us see how important female friendship is. But, to be honest, while I wouldn't call myself Joey's girlfriend, we have kissed. Maybe a bit more." Donna said, constantly looking between the other women in her own sisterhood, their looks of approval encouraging her as she walked this particular verbal tightrope of being honest without giving up too much information.

Nicky thought for a moment, then smiled. But it was Taylor who spoke first.

"Good for you girlie! Nicky told me you've been single for a while, but you're way too hot not to get any!" Taylor said.

"Taylor! That's my mom!" Nicky said, her face almost as red as her crop-top.

"What?! Your mom is hot. Where do you think you get your amazing looks." Taylor said, purring into Nicky's ear.

Nicky's blush deepened, but she looked back to Donna.

"You know it's okay mom. Juniper and I have been dying for you to have some kind of love life again. And I would never get in the way of Joey's romantic life. I'm glad you found some friends, and Joey really is a great guy." Nicky said, before hugging her mother.

Donna couldn't hold back the tears as she embraced her daughter.

Madison and Aynsley were grinning from ear to ear.

"He really is just so great isn't he?" Aynsley said.

"He is the best thing that could possibly happen to a girl like me." Madison said.

"You mean girls like us!" Aynsley said, and they both tittered at the reminder, squeezing each others hands, before turning back to Nicky.

"Okay now tell us everything." Madison said.

"What do you mean?" Nicky said.

"About Joey! I want the tea girl." Madison said.

"Yeah. Your mom already told us about how you two were so close growing up, and Indira was giving us a really in-depth intro to some of the anime you guys like, but you're his best friend! That means you know all the juicy secrets." Aynsley said.

"Like who his first crush was!"

"Or what kind of food does he like."

"Do you know if he has a preference when it comes to hair color?"

"What kind of porn does he watch!"

Aynsley and Madison flanked Nicky as they brought her to the couch, and Donna couldn't help but smile. It was so nice to see her chosen sisters embracing her daughter. So nice to have her two worlds together at last. Plus as they interrogated Nicky, that left Donna a chance to get to know Taylor better.

That would have to wait a moment, though.

Donna's phone buzzed. At exactly the same time as Eliza's and Indira's. The three women took out their phones. It was a text from Joey. He had very explicit instructions. Donna looked up at the others and shared a wolfish grin with them.

It really was shaping up to be the perfect day.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)