Biggest Cock in Gotham vs Average College Guy

The games escalated. Duke attempted to calm things down, to get his girlfriend to lay off the drinks, but she wasn't listening. Nobody was listening. The game of truth and dare became a game of sexual acts.

The atmosphere was totally hot and steamy and with the amount of prying eyes there was no way to resist. Seriously, things got sexual too fast. Shirts were thrown. Pants were discarded. Zatanna fucking Zatara became topless, her tits bouncing out, and it was impossible to just leave. They wanted to stop this but they also didn't.

"What cup size are those," Duke muttered, blushing red. This was way out of his pay grade. He was familiar with his vigilante girlfriend, not the strongest and most smoking hot sorceress.

"Next dare, next dare!" Stephanie and Izzy chanted. Their gazes settled on poor Duke, who looked nervous. "You're next, Duke."

"O-okay." Duke gulped nervously. "What the dare?"

There was a glint in Izzy's eyes, but it was Riko who spoke up. "Pull your pants down. We wanna see your dick."

Duke choked. "E-excuse me?"

"C'mon, Duke, do it," Izzy egged on, giggling. "Zatanna is topless over there. Let's make it fair."

"Gender equality!" Stephanie added with a hand raised, causing Carrie to snicker.

Duke opened his mouth yet was unable to muster a response. He looked at Zatanna, who smirked, used her arms to prop up her tits, and wiggled to and fro. Duke gulped again. His eyes were absolutely stuck to her lovely set of nipples and pale flesh.

Slowly, Duke stood up. Quickly, the girls whooped. Aaron thought that for once he needed a drink.

Lost in the heat of the moment, Duke finally mustered the courage to pull down his pants. Each girl took in the sight before them - a three and a half inch flaccid dick laying on a hefty sack.

Cassandra couldn't help but let out a giggle that escaped her lips like a burst of playful mockery.

Stephanie cooed. "Awww! Look at it!"

"Cute, isn't it?" Izzy commented. Riko nodded silently.

Duke choked and went wide eyed. He glanced down at himself. He wasn't small or cute, he was pretty average. Aaron sighed as he heard Duke mutter in confusion and shame, "C-cute?"

"It's not very big, is it?"

Guess who said that? Zatanna. That was when Duke realized he fucked up. His girlfriend and her friends, fine, he was okay with humiliating himself, but Zatanna? Hell no.

Immediately, Duke covered himself up, hands cupping. "W-what? It's…it's cold!"

"Sorry," Cassandra replied.

"I think it's pretty big," Carrie said, abashed.

"That's cuz you're a virgin," Izzy said. Aaron wanted to hand his head. Two rounds ago, they got Carrie to admit she was a virgin. To her, for someone that hadn't slept with Aaron, of course Duke would be on the larger side.

Not Cassandra though. Not Stephanie, Izzy, Riko, or Zatanna who had gotten pounded left and right by his horse dick.

"It's definitely cute," Stephanie said with a hint of sarcasm, trying not to completely burst into laughter. "You should jerk off, Duke. Maybe you'll impress us at full size."

"I, uh–"

"Come on, Duke! Do it!" Duke's girlfriend was way too drunk. She was almost insistent on embarrassing the guy.

"Please, Duke?" Zatanna begged. "I'm sure it'll be magical."

When Zatanna with those big tits said it, then why refuse? Duke released his crotch, earning some laughs, and pumped his little guy off. Inch by inch, stroke by stroke, it grew. Duke let out a shaky breath as his eyes flickered from Zatanna to the pantless Stephanie and Cassandra. Seeing his close friends wearing lingerie stimulated him like nothing else.

"Woah." Carrie bit her bottom lip. She was visibly impressed at his full erection. "That's…wow."

"I'm a grower, not a shower," Duke said, still stroking himself. His black cock pulsed, remaining at an above average six and a half inches. Sturdy, a little on the slender side, but not definitely not small.

It truly was unfortunate that Aaron Reigner existed.

Stephanie couldn't contain herself anymore; another wave of giggles erupted from deep within her throat. "Well, well," she chuckled between fits of laughter, "looks like we have a bit of an issue here."

"H-huh?" Duke didn't understand. He knew by all means he was above average. He had nothing to ashamed of.

"So cute," Izzy repeated, snickering. "Isn't it, Riko?"

"Mhm."

Duke's face flushed with embarrassment as he tried to salvage what little dignity remained. "It's not that cute," he stammered defensively. "It's pretty big."

Aaron pursed his lips. He felt bad for Duke. Seriously, getting called small in front of gorgeous women must have been the worst feeling in the world.

"Sure thing," Stephanie replied sarcastically, rolling her eyes playfully. "Maybe next time you should invest in some penis enlargement pills or something." She paused momentarily before adding with a mischievous grin, "Or maybe I can lend you one of my vibrators."

"Or maybe Zatanna can use her magic," Izzy said. Zatanna laughed at the remark.

Duke's pride shattered like glass under Izzy's biting words. He sheepishly looked away as if searching for an escape route from this awkward situation.

"I still think it's big," Carrie commented, also embarrassed.

Cassandra raised her voice. "Aaron, you should show your thingie."

"Yeah, yeah!" Izzy encouraged him. "Do it! I want you to show Duke which cock absolutely POUNDED me."

Duke stared at Aaron, who sighed, shrugged, and got up. He was very casual about it. At this point, he was used to standing naked in front of a bunch of thirsty whores.

Thwap!

Gasps, shrieks, grins, and smirks.

Aaron sighed again. Flaccid, at a girthy nine inches, he was much larger than Duke's six and a half inches. There was no comparison, really. Especially because in terms of thickness Aaron was nearly double Duke's.

"Okay…woah!" Carrie was literally taken aback, her eyes and mouth wide open. "W-wow…my gosh…"

"See? See?" Cassandra said, grinning. "Told you. Very big."

"Ooh, we should get him hard," said Izzy. "Who want to do it–"

"Teg drah." Zatanna's magical voice echoed through the room. Aaron sensed an invisible power wrapping his flaccid dick. He could very easily resist it. He didn't want to raise suspicion, however, so he allowed.

He allowed himself to get totally hard.

Same reaction. Same bewilderment.

Duke's jaw dropped. "W-what the…hell…?"

Rather than nine inches, Duke now had to compete with thirteen and a half inches. Literally double his length and girth. It was ridiculous. Duke didn't even want to compare their balls because he could already Aaron's were beyond hefty.

Aaron could read his thoughts. All Duke could think about was: 'How did Izzy take that thing?'

Poor guy. Knowing your girlfriend got fucked by a cock twice your size must have been humiliated. He probably reflected on their lovemaking. Was she ever really satisfied? Or was she faking it? Because after taking that thing, there was no way she would feel her walls getting fucked by Duke's size.

"I remember when he came in me," Izy said. "He cums a LOT. Like, Duke is a couple teaspoons but Aaron is like a waterhose. My pussy hasn't forgotten."

"Me neither," Riko muttered.

Imagine that. Compare that. A 250 ml round glass bottle to a 2l coke bottle. Two coconuts to two walnuts.

"He…came in you?" Duke asked, his cock lurching forward in excitement. Six inches nearly became seven.

"Obviously. We did a lot of things," Izzy replied, grinning. She scooted between them and with one hand grabbed Aaron's colossal titan of a cock and Duke's plain dick. There was the contrast in skin tone, Aaron's white to Duke's black, but the size. That was what mattered.

That was what caused the spectating girls to laugh. For Duke's mouth to go dry. He saw how Izzy's hand wrapped around his yet failed to do the same with Aaron's.

"Oh yeah." Izzy glanced between the two members. To her left, a member that went past her peripheral and the other perfectly in sight. "We did a lot of stuff."

Stroke, stroke, stroke. With one hand, she stroked both cocks. Then, unprompted, announced, "How about us girls give you guys a handjob? Or a blowjob? Or a titjob?" Izzy was really fucking drunk, giggling as she talked. "Well, girls? Choose your cock.

Cassandra, Stephanie, Zatanna, and Riko went over to Aaron.

"Obviously birthday boy," said Zatanna, grinning.

"Mm." Cassandra and Riko nodded silently.

"It's wayyy it's bigger."

"Sorry, Duke." Izzy parted from her boyfriend's smaller member and focused her efforts on Aaron entirely.

Duke was left there, humiliated, red, and throbbing mindlessly. He was secretly excited by the prospect of his girlfriend getting stolen but still insanely jealous and insecure. It was the first time something like this had happened to him, of course he was unsure about it.

"B-but, Isabella…"

"Sorry," Izzy cut him off. She turned her neck back to his cock, kissed it on the side of its glans, and went back to Aaron. "It's cute but it's not big enough for me. These small watery nuts just aren't enough."

Duke was wildly envious of the attention Aaron was receiving. Even Zatanna wanted his cock. Aaron could hear Duke's thoughts. He felt abandoned yet thrilled.

Luckily, there was someone to relieve Duke. A hand suddenly touched Duke's flailing member.

"I think it's big, Duke."

Indeed, Carrie went with Duke. She chose Duke's six and a half incher over Aaron's monstrosity. Judging by her clumsy handjob, it was clear she was a virgin.

Aaron didn't mind letting Duke have Carrie. After all, this was Aaron's birthday and he wanted everyone to have fun.

Plus, he had Zatanna's big tits and Cassandra's hands to service him. His deal was much better–

"Oh!"

Spurt, spurt, spurt! Upon a few strokes, Duke came. His strings of baby batter missed Carrie by a few inches and he ended up jizzing all over his carpet. Panting, dick softening, Duke's red face went redder.

"S-sorry, that's never happened," Duke stammered. His nerves combined with Zatanna's teasing, her phenomenal breasts, and Izzy leaving him for another man pushed Duke Thomas, the Signal, to a record orgasm. Indeed, Aaron could tell he was being honest when he said he usually lasted longer. "I never…er…"

"I-it's okay," said Carrie, smiling sheepishly at him. Seeing his cock lose its hardness, however, there wasn't much she could do. She jerked it for another ten seconds, saw Aaron's imposing rock hard cock, and STILL chose Duke's wilted dick.

"T-thanks," Duke muttered, feeling her efforts and getting hard in record time. Carrie smiled and nodded, one hand jerking him off and the other massaging the underside of his balls.

"I hope you have some left in the tankie."

"I do," Duke replied.

Aaron looked down at all the women at his behest. Cassandra, Stephanie, Izzy, Riko, and Zatanna. Each of them were working hard to please him.

'Happy birthday, Aaron.'