More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 25 by RCK770 RCK770

What's next?

Max’s confession

Kyle slammed the door to his dorm room as he entered and took a deep breath before collapsing onto the couch. It had been an exhausting day and he just took a refreshing shower after Chloe dropped him back to the school which felt comfortable. Besides that, as a final parting gift, Chloe gave him her panties, the same pair of orange panties that she had been wearing for the day.

Also since this is the weekend, most of the students had either went home or had been partying especially those who are part of the Vortex Club which meant that no one will be looking at those bite marks and hickeys on his neck.

He shut his eyes enjoying the peace and quiet dreaming until he heard a knock coming from the door interrupting his moment.

“Who is it?!” Kyle grumbled impatiently getting out from the couch walking to the door.

A familiar voice called out from outside the door. “Kyle it’s me.”

Kyle’s attitude immediately changed. He quickly grabbed Chloe’s panties and stuffed them into the drawer of his closet. He then opened the door revealing his two sweethearts Max and Kate that he haven’t been seeing since the morning.

“Maxie! Katie!” He greeted happily giving them a hug and give two pecks on each of their cheeks. Both girls are in their pajamas but Max and Kate are seen wearing their hoodie and cardigan over their pajamas.

Max and Kate entered his room taking off their jackets and hang it at his closet. Max a pair of panties sticking out of the drawer. She recognized the them as it was Chloe’s. She swiped them and stuffed it into her pack pocket before Kyle could notice anything. Max also noticed that there were bite marks and hickeys all over her boyfriend’s neck area and lets out a devilish grin.

Kyle noticed Max’s look and felt the temperature of his face rising. He tried his best to act normal. He poured two cups of water and handed it to Max and Kate hoping to at least distract them.

“So how are you and Chloe today?” Max asked sitting down on the couch while Kate did the same. “Had fun?” She smiled

“Yeah definitely.” Kyle scratched his head answered awkwardly.

“Take a sit” Max motioned. Kyle obeyed sitting on the couch between his two lovers.

Max put down her cup on the table and suddenly grabbed Kyle’s shirt collar playfully pulling it down revealing more bite marks and hickeys on his upper chest area. Kyle was shocked and immediately pulled his shirt up. Kate laughed at Kyle and Max’s moment.

“Wowser…” Max gasped at her best friends ‘handy work’ and then licked her lips. “You two definitely had fun.” She took out her phone and the Chloe’s panties showing the photo of Chloe kissing Kyle at the concert. Max tosses the panties to Kate and both girls laughed leaving Kyle looking awkward and ashamed.

“Maxie wait I can explain!” Kyle said nervously and thought. “Chloe you bitch!” He was sweating once again and froze like a deer in headlights.

“It’s alright Kyle we’re not angry.” Kate suddenly said interrupting him. She toss those panties aside placing her hand on his as she placed her cup on the table too. Having Kate’s hand on his definitely helped calm him down.

“It’s alright baby, listen.” Max begin “There’s something that we want to talk to you.”

“Could it be about that plan?” Kyle asked. “I heard Chloe mentioned that you two had been planning something.”

Max nodded and said. “Remember that night when you make love with us for the first time and you asked if we are a couple or a harem?”

Kyle nodded quietly with Max’s words from that night echoing through his mind.

Max continued. “And I told you that we are more like a trouple right?”

Kyle nodded but he then added. “But you mentioned something about a liking an idea of a harem?”

“Yeah…” Max blushed. “The truth is I’ve been thinking about it for some time ever since that night and I wanted to give it a try to spice up our relationship so Kate, me and eventually Chloe had this little private discussion which we ended up agreeing which I’m sure you probably wouldn’t mind as who doesn’t want to make their fantasy come true.” Max slowly crawled towards Kyle close forcing him back towards Kate while looking at him playfully.

Kyle was surprised. He never knew that Max was opened to an idea of a poly relationship but to be fair. He also thought about it at some point before even though he also believes that it is impossible. He then looked at Kate who smiled and wrapped her arms around her neck slowly pushing him back up as Max sat down close to him legs crossed.

“You too sweet angel?” Kyle was even surprised. It’s no doubt that Kate ever since dark moment when she tried to end herself had decided to rebel against her heavily religious parents and church but deep down she is still a devoted Christian and a firm believer of Christ even though he had awakened her freaky side ever since that night when he took her virginity away. But he never thought a devoted Christian like her would be fine with the idea of a harem let alone sharing her boyfriend with others.

Kate just rested her head on Kyle’s shoulder and smirked.

“I never thought you would be okay with this idea since you know, like how your religion kinda forbids or discourages these kinds of stuff.”

Kate scoffed and laughs at her boyfriend’s comment. “Looks like I’m breaking even more rules.” She looked into Kyle’s eyes. “Look babe, I’ve made my choice the moment I made you my first and agreed to share you with Max so what’s wrong about sharing you with others. Besides, I still believed in god but it’s just that I do not approve of my family and church controlling me.”

Kyle didn’t know what to say, he just looked at both girls and stayed silent. But deep down he is exited although both Max and Kate will always have a special place in his heart.

Max smiled trying to break the awkward silence. She looked at the hickeys and bite marks on Kyle’s neck especially the large dark one with deep bite marks on the other side of his neck. She then smirk. “Well well well, looks like Chloe did a ton on you.”

“Yeah but I’m really worried about everyone seeing these once we return to school next week.” Kyle said worried as he rubbed a hickey on his neck while Kate examined and touched it.

“Don’t rub it you’re probably going to make it worse.” Max stopped him. “How bout this, I’ll apply some make up on your neck which hopefully will cover those marks. See me in my dorm room tomorrow and every morning before class.”

“You sure it’ll work?”

“Definitely. Trust me.” Max gave Kyle a quick peck on his cheek and got up. She grabbed Kyle’s hand and pulled him towards his bed and pushed him onto the bed while Kate followed. “Now… I hope Chloe didn’t wear you out.” Max take Kyle’s shirt off presenting his bare chest riddled with hickeys. She was about to go even further until Kyle stopped her.

“I’m sorry Maxie. I’m really tired after spending an entire day out with Chloe.” Kyle yawned as he laid on his bed stretching his arms. As much he would like to fuck the brains out of both his lovers he is really exhausted after an entire day out not to mention Chloe draining him. Kyle looked at his girls saying. “Besides like you said, Chloe did in fact wore me out.”

“Oh you poor baby.” Max said crawling and resting her head on her boyfriend’s bare chest running her hands through the bite marks and hickeys on his chest. She could also smell the scent of the shampoo used. Kate also lets out a yawn to before laying next to Kyle.

“It’s alright Maxie.” Kyle pulled Max close to him as Kate rested her head on his chest close. “I’ll promise I make up for the both of you soon.” He planted a small kiss on Max’s forehead before turning around planting a small on Kate’s forehead too.

“A promise is a promise then.” Max said softly as she nuzzled herself into her boyfriend’s neck.

“Good night Maxie, good night Angel.” Kyle said turning off the lights.

“Good night Kyle.” Both girls said in unison and it didn’t take long for them to fell asleep except for Kyle who was still awake a little.

“Maxie, Angel. Thank you.” He whispered lightly and smiled looking at both girls sleeping beside him closely. “I promise I’ll marry both of you someday.”

Kyle then closed his eyes slowly drifted into sleep. Unknown to him however, Max and Kate were actually semi awake when they heard him and both girls smiled and giggled upon hearing that.

They scooted themselves closer to their lover and gave him a quick peck on his cheek before finally drifting into sleep peacefully for the night.


A/N: That’s the Chloe story arc finished. Who should be next? I was thinking of adding Brooke and Victoria in later chapters and as of right now I would like to add a Vortex Club girl in the next story and who should it be?

A) Dana (Ideas?)

B) Juliet (Ideas?)

C) Taylor (Ideas?)

Also I might try shortening the next few chapters. Also as usual if you are interested feel free to join in.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)