Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by RCK770 RCK770

What's next?

Max’s turn

Kate looked at Kyle and then Max. She understood what Max wants and she gave him a smirk. He stopped trusting and pulled out off Kate while she unwrapped her legs from his back.

Kyle turned his attention towards Max. He pulls her into a deep kiss and they once again begin making out. He then pulled her panties away showing her glistening wet pussy. Unlike Kate, Max’s pussy was clean shaven.

“Max, are you sure you want to do this?” He asked once again just as a precaution even though Max clearly wants him. “It’s going to hurt.”

“Yes…” Max said shyly. She bit her lower lip as she spreads her legs for Kyle, nervously preparing for what is about to come while looking at him eagerly. Her sparkling deep blue eyes filled with lust and anticipation.

Kyle lined up his cock against her pussy and with a nod from Max. Kyle pushed himself into her hard, breaking Max’s hymen and taking her virginity away.

“Wowser it… it hurts!” Max cried out in pain. Kyle quickly comfort her pulling her towards him kissing her forehead and embraced her. Max in return wrapped her arms around his neck and they remained so until Max’s pain faded away while Kate gently rubbed her back returning the favor.

Meanwhile, Kyle couldn’t believe what was happening as he did not just his virginity to not just one but two beautiful girls even though Kate was actually his first.

Then Max whispered “Kyle?”

“Yeah?” He whispered back.

“Do you uh… want to continue? I’m feeling alright now.”

“I thought you’d never ask.” Kyle and Max slowly untangled from their embrace, he looked at Max who lets out a smile laying back on the bed. He pulled out his cock once more. He noticed that unlike Kate, Max did not have any blood leaking out from her pussy. He felt relieved adjusting his position and thrusts inside of Max.

Max lets out a moan as she feels her insides being split apart by Kyle’s cock. Just like Kate, her insides were also tight and hot. Soon Max’s moans became louder and louder as Kyle increased his speed.

“Oh yes baby harder! Harder!” Max moaned as Kyle increased his speed while her finger nails dig into Kyle’s back, leaving streaks of red marks on his back as they continued their love making session.

“Oh Maxie you’re so tight! Just like Katie’s!” Kyle moaned while enjoying every moment.

Kate looked at Kyle and Max passionate love making and she was incredibly horny. That feeling in her was growing. She noticed Max’s perky tits were bouncing up and down while being fucked hard and it was turning her on. She licked her lips. Max noticed that look on Kate’s face. She laid beside and placed on of her mouth on Max’s breast sucking and nibbling her nipples.

Max’s body jolted and felt shiver went down her spine . They remained so for a while until Kate crawled towards Max. She cupped Max’s cheeks with both hands and turned her around. Kate then opened her legs wide while Kyle stopped for a moment.

“Go ahead baby, do your thing.” Kate instructed giving Kyle a seductive look.

“Kate…” Max tried to spoke but was cut off when Kate kissed her and pushed her tongue into her mouth. On this night, Kate had not just kissed a boy but even a girl too.

Kyle was instantly turned on by Kate. At one moment she was still that religious somewhat uptight girl who he met during the first day in school and was still conflicted but right now she had turned into a completely different person as is he had turned something inside her on

He continued to pound Max hard while sticking two fingers in and out of Kate while they were making out. Both their hands massaged each other’s breast.

Kyle who is instantly turned on by this girl on girl action in front of his eyes increased his speed and switched positions between Max and Kate. He kept repeating until he felt their walls tightened against his cock. Soon, the body of both girls tensed and spasmed as they got into an orgasm, spraying their juices all over the sheets.

At the same time Kyle also felt like he is about cum and he immediately called out. “Max, Angel. I’m going to cum soon!”

Kate pulled her mouth away from Max after hearing what Kyle said.

“It’s alright Kyle, you can cum inside one of us.” Max said. “Both of us are on birth control.”

A) Kyle came inside of Max.

B) Kyle came inside of Kate.

C) Kyle came both Max and Kate.

D) Kate takes all of Kyle’s load inside her mouth.

E) Max takes all of Kyle’s load inside her mouth.

F) Kyle shoot his load onto Max and Kate’s bodies.

Who did Kyle choose and what did he do

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)