Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by 4incher 4incher

Where or how does our story start?

Magic shop

Nathan wandered through the dimly light aisles of the mystic moon, A shop nestled between a thrift store and a dusty old bookstore in one of the older parts of Easton. It was the kind of place his best friend Jane loved. a mix of crystals, candles, and things that claimed to be “magical.” She was always talking about energy and auras, so he figured a crystal or something might make a decent gift for her birthday. She was holding this giant pool party with all the members of the swimteam including their newest member.. him.

He has asked her to do a 'normal' party without the pool and speedo's aspect. But she insisted. So he just gave up. You see ever since Nathan Lewis joined the swimteam 4 weeks ago his life has changed dramaticaly. He is suddenly one of the most populair guys at school. Girls swoon all over him. Tho never the pretty ones. He gets invited more to social events. He is finally popular... somethign he always wanted. Just one thing... His bullies are also on the team. And they always call him out for his short physique or that he hasn't as much muscles as them. Luckily they don't know about his biggest insecurity.. Or should I say smallest.

Nathan has a tiny dick. And when he first put on the speedo it was very noticeable. Jane his best friend laughed at him allot when he walked out of the changing room. She was the one that gave him his introduction to the team. They both figured out that his reputation would be tarnished if the boys or girls on the swimteam ever saw him with such a tiny bulge. So she had the brilliant idea of stuffing a sock down there. He refuses at first but she quickly shoved her sock down there making him blush. So now he is keeping the Illusion in tact.

As he kept browsing, a soft voice interrupted his thoughts. "Looking for something special?''. He looked over to see a hot young woman sitting behind the counter. She was your typical alt girl. with black bangs almost covering her face and a pierced nose and a few small tattoos. He cleared his throat and said: "Yeah... I mean, it’s for a friend,” he replied, shrugging. He glanced down at the collection of crystals in his hands.

The woman smiled knowingly. "Of course." Her gaze seemed to pierce right through him, her eyes lingering just a little too long. “But you know,” she added in a low voice, “I think I know what you're really looking for''. Nate raised his eyebrow and laughed. Was she flirting with him? He almost had gotten used to it these past few weeks. ''Well isn't that a line?'' He said smirking walking over to the counter.

The woman grinned and let her eyes fall to his jeans. ''You have a big ego... but a small dick. You shouldn't hide behind a sock you know..'' Nathan froze, suddenly wary. “Um… what?”. He looked down at his jeans. A clear bulge visible... but how did she know it was a sock? She grinned again. ''Don't worry Nathan... your little secret is safe with me'' She winks and keeps staring at his junk. Nathan fights the urge to cover his package. ''Are you a witch?'' Nate asks carefully. Stil not believing that what is happening is real. ''You could say that..'' The black haired woman says mysteriously. ''But I want to help you''. She grabs a box from under the counter. It's a small wooden chest with a golden keyhole in it. She grabs a key from somewhere and slowly opens the old thing. ''One of these will help you with your little problem. But you can choose which one you will use. Remember once you chose you can't give it back'' She says.

What does Nate choose from the box?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)