Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by lovestoblush lovestoblush

Who is it?

BigCockAlan

“Submissive baby carrot I presume?” It was a soft voice speaking his online name in the form! If Matt turned, he would see a man in his mid 20s, no older than himself. BigDickAlan was clean shaven with a bit of a gut, standing in a pair of tight jeans and a T shirt with his short brown hair combed over, staring at his new toy's ass.

Matt was tempted to peak over his shoulder and look at the man that had taken control of him. He felt his balls ache when he heard his online name spoken out loud. What if someone nearby heard that, got curious and found them. The thought sent a surge through his balls.

"Yes sir, BigCockAlan?" Matt asked, feeling immediately silly. Who else could it be, who else knew to call him baby carrot. Who else could speak with such confidence that it made his knees buckle a little.

“That’s me… pull up your pants before someone sees” Alan ordered as he put a soft hand on Matt's ass and gave it a quick, playful grope before stepping back.

Matt quickly pulled his pants up, making sure to keep his boner facing the wall as he hid it in his baggy pants. "I was so nervous, I wasn't sure it was you at first. I've never done anything like that before," Matt quietly confided to Alan as he turned to face the handsome dom. Finally laying eyes on Alan, Matt felt immediately put in his place. Matt was actually dressed rather well, in a nice button down and slacks, as he had hoped to impress Alan. But Alan, in his jeans and white T-shirt, clearly didn't care as much about impressing Matt.

Alan gave a warm smile. “And yet you dropped your pants and even went commando for someone you had never met… I like you already baby carrot” he said with a small smirk. “Nice name by the way” he laughed quietly

Matt blushed. "It was a nickname when I was in high school...my bullies called me that and it stuck..."

Alan raised an eye brow. “Oh, now I would love to learn why… say it out loud for me… your first dare” Alan said, obviously fully aware of why he was called that but he wanted to watch him squirm

"They called me baby carrot...because of when we would change in the locker room..." Matt trailed off, hoping that was enough. But Alan just glared and waited. "And I would try and shower after everyone left...but then one day someone took my clothes and my secret was exposed."

Alan smiled now. "What secret was that baby carrot?"

Matt looked at the floor in shame. "That my penis was smaller than a baby carrot."

Alan smirked.

“And how did they know? Did anyone ever bring one in to compare?” He asked as he put a hand on Matt’s waist in a sexy way. “Did they ever corner you” he asked as he pushed Matt slowly back onto a book shelf. “And pull open your waistband and check?” He asked as he put his hand teasingly on Matt’s pants waistband

Does Alan do it?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)