Truth or Dare (gone wrong)

It was quite amusing to see the two girls arrange stuff in the living room for their girls night. Alex's stash of alchohol was quite impressive, and Jackie ordered more food than one could imagine.

I never really knew Dee's friend's, Alex was the only I met previously that I could attach a name to. I've never seen Jackie before. And overall Dee's friends never hung out at our house.

"Alrighty!" Alex claps her hands together, "are you ready to play the game."

Jackie turns her head to Dee, "I think its only right you go first, miss private."

Dee speaks without thinking, "dare. I told you I wasn't gonna spill."

Jackie looks back at Dee, "um do I shot, I guess?"

Alex and I raise our eyebrows, Alex speaks first. "Really that's all you could think of for a dare."

I jump in, "Yeah I just met you, but that's some pussy shit right there."

Jackie stammers, "it's hard choosing the first dare. You'll see, you gotta ease into the more intense stuff." She blushes, it's strange seeing someone so confident caught off their toes.

Dee pours a shot and downs it with ease, "my brother is right, that was some pussy shit. Anyways, Alex truth or dare?"

Alex hesitates but regains her composure quickly, "truth." She says firmly.

Dee leans in, "how far have you gone with my brother."

Jackie let's out an audible ooh, while my face turns into a lobster.

"So were playing the hard game are we?" Alex leans in.

Dee doesn't break eye contact, "you didn't answer the question."

"All. The. Way. And I'm guessing you don't wants specifics." Alex winks at Dee.

"Ew gross, I thought that was just gonna end the game quickly," dee recoils.

"Its gonna take alot more to stop the game, you should know that Dee." Alex leans back, "Jackie, truth or dare?"

Jackie perks up and thinks her options through before finally choosing, "I choose dare!"

"Alright Jackie," Alex sips her drink, "strip."

"What!?! No!" Jackie stomps her foot, "I don't want you and Ed ogling me."

"Ending the game so quickly before we can get to the bottom of Dee's story, that's kinda weak of you Jackie," Alex winks.

Jackie begins taking off her clothes, "you guys suck," she reveals her lithe tattooed body and cute bubble butt as well as her nice tits, probably a c cup, with their nipple piercings.

I'd be lying if I said she wasn't attractive. She was gorgeous. I could see why Alex wanted her to strip, I had to fight every urge to not pop a boner right there.

"Perv," Jackie covers her body as she catches me staring, "truth or dare, Ed?"

Without thinking I said "dare!"

"That's bold of you, Ed," Jackie gets an evil smirk on her face, "let's see if a pervert like you enjoyed seeing me naked, strip as well."

Yeah that was the wrong choice, not that I had anything to be ashamed of but my sister was literally in the room. "Um, Dee's here"

"Ew," dee recoils

"I won't object," Alex says.

"Going to end the game now Ed," Jackie says with a smirk, "I didn't, and I don't want to be the only one naked."

"Fine," I say with a sigh as I begin to take my shirt off. I know I shouldn't be embarrassed but having 3 girls stare at me is putting me off, especially my sister.

I do have to thank Heleth for the body though, if I was skinny as I was a couple days ago this would be mortifying. But now having them look at my toned body as I remove the shirt makes me feel just a bit more in control.

I feel their eyes burning into me, looking at Jackie she looked the most surprised while dee and Alex seemed to be in a trance.

I move to my pants slowly lowering them. It felt natural to take my time, to tease the girls with the v leading down to my crotch. I felt myself growing hard, but instead of being embarrassed I use this to my advantage. I slowly reveal my dick inch by inch, till it springs out of its cotton prison. Jackie's mouth drops, while Dee pretends to have never seen it before, Alex meanwhile licks her lips.

I broke the silence, "Umm my eyes are up here."

"See I told you he was big," Alex says with pride.

"Jesus christ, that's the biggest cock I've ever seen!" Jackie says.

Dee looks up "could you sit down so I don't have to stare at it?"

"Yeah, sorry" I sit back down trying to hide my large cock with little success. "Alex it's your turn right? Truth or dare?"

Alex pauses for a moment, "too many dares, I'll do truth."

I thought about what I could ask. Until I thought about something that would help me confirm my suspicion about this girls group. "How far have you gone with everyone in this room?"

Jackie and dee look at each other then Alex, it seeks there's definitely more than nothing.

Alex finally speaks, "to be honest with you, I guess I've had sex with everyone in this room. I don't think we're more than friends, Jackie and dee that is. But things happen and we don't mind experimenting with each other. I guess we're more friends with benefits. Sorry that if that makes it awkward that I've done it with your sister and my roommate, I know we haven't defined what our relationship would be." She looks down having felt bad.

To be honest, this works for me. While I don't like the thought of my sister having sex. I think me and Alex being more open than together might work out better with my predicament. "That's cool with me, you don't need to feel bad. Like you said me and your relationship isn't defined and this barely a second date. It's a little be awkward that you've boned my sister but it's cool."

Alex immediately smiles and the other girls seem to be more at ease. "Well then Dee I believe it's your turn. Truth or dare?" Alex smiles.

"Dare," dee says, "I told you I'm not switching and telling you guys what happened earlier today. No matter how intense you get, Ed already knows I'm not above having sex with either of you. I'm not losing the game."

Alex's smile turns to an evil grin, "me and Jackie know that. However there's someone you do have a boundary with. I dare you to jerk Ed off."

"What!" The girls and I say.

Alex turns, "she's not gonna do it guys, trust me."

Dee gets up and sits next to me, putting her hand (barely) around my dick. "I told you I ain't losing."

I moan, "um dee, this really is a boundary for me."

Dee looks at me in the eyes, "then you forfeit then."

I feel her hand go up and down my shaft, "I'm not losing either dee."

Alex then speaks up, "there's no stopping till Ed cums or another dare is made. Just saying."

Jackie sat silently her eyes wide before Dee speaks up again, "very well, Jackie I think it's your turn."

"Truth, I choose truth." Jackie says very fast and afraid of Dee's wrath.

"Who would you rather do, me or Ed." Dee looks at Jackie. Her stare reveals a past between the two. Jackie opens her mouth but Dee speaks again, "the truth, Jackie. I already know the answer."

Jackie regains her composure, "I'd have to say Ed, sorry Dee."

The two look at each other, a history revealed between the staring contast. "Ed it's your turn, truth or dare?" Jackie says.

I was scared of what the next dare would be, but I really wanted the handjob from my sister to end. It scares me how much I'm enjoying it. "Dare," I say unsure.

"I feel your sister hasn't been challenged enough, I dare you to stop the handjob. And get a blowjob from her instead." Jackie says her palms together.

Instead of speaking or having a chance to end this dee interrupts, "blowjob, easy. Ready for the best head you've ever had bro." And before I object I feel her mouth wrap around my cock as she gets on her knees in front om me. I lean back, I'd kill myself before I let this end.

"Oh fuck," I say as I feel my sister, my blood, wrap her tongue around my dick like a slut. "Alex, truth or dare?"

"Dare!" Alex says without hesitation she saw where the night was leading.

"Get your fucking clothes off and sit next to me!" I order.

Alex quickly complies revealing her naked body and hard cock. She was so cute. As she set next to me. Jackie also came beside me, pulling my head in for a kiss as she begins to finger herself.

I grab Alex's cock and start stroking it up and down. Make sure I had control over her dick before she spoke up, "dee, truth or dare."

Dee pulls her head up from my dick, "are we really still playing this? Dare!" She says before going back down on me.

"I'm still going to push you don't you forget, ride your brother Dee. Do it." Alex moans as I jerk her cock faster.

Dee gets up and pulls her pants off. Revealing her chubby booty and clean shaven vagina, my sister was beautiful even if she didn't know it. This feels so wrong, I know we shouldn't. But my cock throbs at the idea of Dee and I having sex.

Der pushes Jackie away from my mouth as she straddles me. "Do you want this? You want to be a dirty sister fucker?" She says seductively, "you want to fuck your fat ass sister you dirty boy."

"Yes dee! I want it! I want it bad!" I moan as I feel the tip enter Dee's snatch. She moans deeply as more of me enters her.

"I love you, Ed. I've always loved you, before you became this hunk. I know it's bad as your sister. As your older sister who was meant to protect you, but it's true. I fell in love with and only sought to be with people like you. But they could never be you, and all those relationships failed." Dee confesses as she takes my entire length inside her, pulling me deeply into a kiss.

I pull away and look her in the eyes all I could say was, "Dee," softly.

She interrupts me, "it's okay. I know it's wrong. Just enjoy it. We'll talk about it later." She begins going up and down on my dick faster and faster.

Jackie lifts Dee's shirt off of her and begins sucking on her big tits. Dee leans back and moans deeply as Jackie suckles on her.

Alex stands up on the couch and guides my mouth to her cock as dee rides me. I begin sucking her dick with fervor as I feel her grab my hair.

"Look dee, your brothers a good cockslut," Alex says as she thrusts into my mouth.

"I'm gonna cum!" Dee screams, "I'm gonna cum on your dick baby."

Dee spasms as she orgasms on my cock. Her eyes roll back as she clenches in extasy. Jackie not wasting any time lifts Dee off my cock. "Its my turn now" she says. She begins riding my cock. Her lithe body bouncing up and down. Dee recovers quickly and gets behind Alex, shoving her tongue in her asshole.

"Oh fuck," Alex says, "tongue my asshole you dirty brother fucker."

She quickens her pace as she fucks my mouth, tightening her grip she has on my hair. I gag multiple times as I leave her cock sloppy with my saliva. "Ah fuck I'm gonna gonna cum," she says as she pulls her cock out of my mouth shooting ropes of cum all over my face. Leaving me a glazed mess.

Dee quickly pulls her tongue out of Alex's mouth and has her lay down. She sits on her face and moans deeply as Alex begins to eat her pussy. Dee begins to lick my face, gathering up Alex's cum and kissing me. Each of us swapping her salty seman between our mouths as we swallow every last bit.

Jackie was being pushed to the brink, "I'm gonna cum too!" As she has a shaking orgasm on me.

I pull out of her and stand up. "Everyone on their knees in front of me." I order as I jerk my cock. They all line up on their knees. Their tits out and mouths open looking up at me pressing into each other. It wasn't long till I shot an inhumane amount of cum onto all three of them. Rope after rope, coating them all in my sperm.

The girls looked like a glazed mess, and after it was done. We all sat back exhausted and full of guilt.