Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 42 by perv-senpai perv-senpai

What's next?

Welcome her

The familiar sound of the front door opening signaled that Casey was home. Erica, Anna, and I shared a knowing look, our ritual about to begin. We moved to the entrance hall, waiting for Casey to step inside.

As soon as Casey entered, she smiled at us, her eyes sparkling with a mixture of excitement and relief after a long day at work. "I missed you all," she said, her voice soft and affectionate.

"We missed you too, Casey," I replied, stepping forward to embrace her. Our lips met in a tender kiss, the day's separation melting away in that moment of connection.

After the kiss, I took a step back, giving Casey a meaningful look. She understood immediately, her smile widening. Without hesitation, she knelt before me, her hands gently undoing my belt and unzipping my pants. She looked up at me with a mixture of devotion and desire, her eyes never leaving mine as she freed my already hard cock.

"Such a good girl," I murmured, running my fingers through her hair as she took me into her mouth. Her tongue swirled around the tip, eliciting a deep groan from me. I placed a hand on her head, guiding her movements as she began to bob up and down, taking me deeper with each motion.

Erica and Anna stood nearby, watching intently. Their presence added to the intensity of the moment, their eyes filled with admiration and lust as they observed Casey pleasuring me.

"You're doing so well, Casey. Just like that," I praised, my voice thick with pleasure.

She moaned in response, the vibrations sending shivers through my body. I could feel myself getting closer, my grip on her hair tightening slightly as I guided her faster. With one final thrust, I came deep in her mouth, my body tensing and releasing in a wave of pleasure.

A bit of my cum escaped from the corner of her mouth, and as Casey rose to her feet, Erica leaned in to lick it up, her tongue darting out to capture every drop. "You're such a good girl, Casey," I said, giving her a kiss on the cheek. "Thank you."

"Thank you, John," she replied, her voice filled with warmth and contentment.

With our ritual complete, it was time for the next part of our evening routine. We all moved to the bathroom, where we would wash Casey before dinner. The bathroom was warm and inviting, the soft light creating a soothing atmosphere.

Casey began undressing, her work clothes falling to the floor as she revealed her beautiful, tired body. I turned on the shower, adjusting the water temperature until it was just right. Erica, Anna, and I joined Casey under the warm spray, our bodies pressed close together in the confined space.

We took our time washing Casey, our hands moving over her skin with gentle care. Erica lathered soap onto a washcloth and began to wash Casey's back, her movements slow and deliberate. Anna took over Casey's legs, massaging and cleaning each inch with loving attention.

I focused on Casey's front, my hands moving over her breasts, her stomach, and finally between her legs. She sighed softly, her body relaxing under our combined touch. "This feels wonderful," Casey whispered, her eyes half-closed in bliss.

"We're glad you're home," I said, leaning in to kiss her neck. "We missed taking care of you."

Erica and Anna murmured their agreements, their hands continuing their tender ministrations. The shower was filled with the sounds of water and soft moans, the air thick with the scent of soap and the warmth of our shared love.

We didn't just stop at washing her skin. Erica and Anna knelt down, spreading Casey's legs wider. Erica gently inserted a soapy finger into her pussy, cleaning her thoroughly while Anna did the same with her ass. I held Casey steady, my hands caressing her breasts and teasing her nipples, eliciting soft gasps from her.

"You're so good for us, Casey," I whispered in her ear, my voice filled with affection and lust. "We love taking care of you."

Casey moaned softly, her body trembling under our combined touch. "I love it when you take care of me," she whispered, her voice filled with emotion.

Once Casey was thoroughly washed and rinsed, we stepped out of the shower and dried each other off. The intimacy of the moment was not just in the physical care we provided but in the emotional connection that bound us together.

With Casey now refreshed and relaxed, we moved to the dining area, where our meal awaited. We sat down together, the table filled with delicious dishes we had prepared earlier. The atmosphere was warm and joyful, the bonds between us strengthened by the rituals and care we had shared.

As we ate, we talked and laughed, sharing stories from our day. Casey recounted her experiences at work, while Erica, Anna, and I shared our adventures and moments of relaxation.

As we finished dinner, we cleared the table together, reinforcing the unity we felt. Then we moved to the living room, where we settled down to watch some Netflix, cuddling close to each other on the couch. The room was filled with the comforting sound of the show playing in the background, our bodies warm and relaxed from the day's activities.

As we enjoyed the show, my phone vibrated on the table, catching our attention. I was too comfortable and nestled between Erica and Anna to reach for it, so I asked, "Erica, can you check who that is?"

She picked up the phone, her eyes scanning the screen. A mischievous smile spread across her face as she read the message. "It's from Sarah," she said, looking at me with a playful glint in her eyes.

"Read it out loud," I prompted, curious about what Sarah had to say.

Erica cleared her throat and began to read the message. "Hey John, I hope this isn't too forward, but I can't stop thinking about the day we spent at the lake. I've been wanting to reach out but didn't want to be a bother. I finally mustered the courage to ask if you might want to meet up sometime. I hope this isn't too much. - Sarah."

The room fell silent for a moment as we absorbed the message. Then Casey broke the silence, her eyes wide with excitement. "That's amazing! Sarah is such a sweet girl."

Anna nodded in agreement. "I'm so happy she's reaching out. She was wonderful at the lake."

We all shared a look of understanding. Something like jealousy doesn't exist among us. While they are completely loyal to me and have sworn eternal loyalty, they genuinely enjoy seeing me happy, even if it means being with other women. Moreover, they all liked Sarah very much after our day at the lake.

I smiled, feeling a warm sense of appreciation for Sarah's bravery. "I'm glad she reached out. What do you all think I should say?"

"Tell her you'd love to see her," Erica suggested. "Maybe invite her for dinner tomorrow night."

I nodded, taking my phone from Erica and typing out a reply. "Hi Sarah, I'm so glad you reached out. I'd love to meet up. How about dinner tomorrow night in the city?"

As I was about to hit send, Casey quickly added, "Wait, let me add something." She took the phone from my hands, a sly smile on her face. She typed quickly before handing it back to me. Without checking, I sent the message.

Moments later, my phone buzzed again. It was Sarah, replying almost instantly. Erica read the message out loud again. "I'd love to! Tomorrow night sounds perfect. Also, here's a picture of me; I hope you like it." Attached was a photo of Sarah.

We all leaned in to see the photo. Sarah had sent a daring and sexy picture of herself. She stood in front of a mirror, wearing only a pair of lace panties and a matching bra that barely contained her small but firm breasts. Her slender, almost ethereal body was highlighted by the delicate fabric. Her shoulder-length blonde hair framed her delicate features perfectly, and her icy blue eyes looked directly into the camera with a mix of shyness and allure. The lighting in the photo cast a soft glow on her pale, almost porcelain-like skin, making her look even more enchanting.

"Wow," Anna said, her eyes wide. "Sarah looks amazing."

I was stunned by the photo, feeling a rush of excitement. "I can't wait to see her."

Erica and Anna were grinning, clearly thrilled by the turn of events. "John, you have to tell us everything about how it goes tomorrow," Erica insisted.

"Absolutely," Anna added. "We want all the details."

I laughed, feeling incredibly lucky to have such supportive and loving partners. "Of course, I'll tell you everything."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)