Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by storysmith storysmith

What's next?

On your knees

Max looked at the worried couple huddled together on the couch, holding each other's hands.

He could sense their love and affection for each other. To successfully infiltrate this relationship, he had to erode their trust in each other.

"Please, I want you both to know that just because I own your soul doesn't mean I'm not a kind and benevolent master. Let's all relax, and I'll fill you in on some of the fun changes we'll be making around here."

"Let's start with something small. Why don't you both show me the proper respect and from now on, you can both address me as sir".

"Yes, sir", Katelyn blurted out immediately, surprising not only Evan and Max but herself too.

"Babe," Evan said hurt.

Katelyn, feeling embarrassed by her natural submissivness hissed, "He's in charge, just say it" back at him.

"Yes, sir", Evan complied through gritted teeth.

"Good, see how easy that was," Max said, smiling as he moved closer to tower over the couple.

"The Next rule is that when you're out of the house, you will only wear clothes that I have approved for you."

"Yes, sir," Katelyn said, followed by Evan.

"And when you are at home, let's have you both make sure to strip completely naked for me, right?".

The couple nodded.

"Understood!" Max said in a stern voice.

"Yes, sir", the couple repeated, more hesitantly this time.

"Good, now, chop chop," Max said, looking at the couple expectantly.

Evan stood up and slid off his shorts, pulling his t-shirt off without much hesitation before sitting back down. Wincing in pain as he sat, forgetting for just a moment that he was wearing his cage and feeling the **** of sitting zapped his cock with pain.

Katelyn was more hesitant, but having seen Evan strip and sit down, she stood up and pushed her soft cat pyjama pants over her hips and let them pool over her bare feet. Lifting the hem of her tight, figure-hugging t-shirt, Katelyn crossed her arms as she lifted the shirt over her head, catching her large breasts on the way, causing them to bounce provocatively at Max.

Katelyn quickly covered her pussy with one hand and her large round breasts as best she could with her other arm. Sitting down quickly and hunching forwards to try and preserve her dignity but unknowingly giving a deep view of her cleavage to Max.

"Wonderful, what a beautiful couple you both are. There is no need to hide it. It's easy to see in your online videos and your sex tape how much you love each other. Now I get to be a part of that too, and together, I think we can bring a lot of joy."

"The channels will still be called Evan and Katelyn, but I want you to think of them more as Evan and Katelyn and Max. It's not something to think about for now; we can discuss that later."

"Speaking of joy, Katelyn, please relax, lean back on the couch and put your hands to your sides; we're too close for you to have anything to hide from me."

Katelyn looked at Evan for approval. Receiving a small shoulder shrug, she sighed and complied.

"Beautiful," Max said as Katelyn's naked chest came into view.

"Now, lets spread those legs for me too, I don't want you hiding your pussy from me, do you understand"?

This time, without needing to look to Evan for approval but with a groan, Katelyn spread her legs apart, just a little, but enough for Max to see the lips of her labia and the tuft of pubic hair she'd been trying to cover.

"Beautiful," Max repeated, eliciting a small groan of discomfort from Katelyn.

Max saw Evan's angry face start to wince as he bent over further.

"Evan, you look like you're in pain. Can you promise to be an obedient and gentle **** if I let you out of your cage?"

Evan was torn, not wanting to be humiliated by the affirmation but **** to free his trapped penis from its painful cage. Evan looked Max in the eye, sincerely saying, "Yes, sir, please, it hurts so bad".

Max smiled and unlocked his phone; after pressing a few buttons, a small whir emanated from the cage on Evan's dick, and the two halves sprung apart.

Evan groaned in relief as he pulled the device off of his dick, the pipe in his urethra scraping his insides, but Evan was so relieved to get the thing off he didn't care.

It didn't take long from his massaging his dick back to health for it to start to grow; Evan panicked for a split second, expecting the pain of the cage and then realising how quickly he'd been conditioned by the cage carried on massaging.

"Thank you" slipped from Evan's lips. He immediately regretted saying it, but it felt so good to be free.

"Thank you, what?" Max reminded.

Evan didn't want to say it, but "Thank you, sir" came from his lips, not wanting to be restrained again.

"You make a beautiful couple," Max mused.

"Evan, I noticed in your videos that you're both very comfortable with each other's bodies. Katelyn, you didn't hesitate to take Evan's dick into your mouth and give the most enthusiastic 4-minute, 24-second sloppy blowjob I've ever seen."

Katelyn blushed, not only had the creep watched her sucking Evan's dick but he's timed her too.

"Katelyn, you looked happy when Evan picked you up and threw you onto the bed before he sank his full length into your pussy and rutted into you for 9 minutes and 4 seconds."

"Evan, when you have access to a woman as hot as Katelyn here, with a body as beautiful as she has, why didn't I see you penetrating Katelyn's beautiful Texas butt? It doesn't seem right."

Katelyn blushed, cutting across Evan, who was stuttering to try and answer why he didn't film himself sodomising his beautiful wife.

"Oh, no, no, no, he's far too big for that," Katelyn said.

"Evan, have you ever even tried?" Max asked, bewildered.

"I, I, I mean, we've..." Evan continued to stutter, turning red.

Katelyn put a hand on Evan's leg and let out a breath before answering.

"We tried it once when we first started dating, and we agreed that if either of us didn't like it, then it wasn't going to be something that we would do going forward."

"So, let me guess, Evan. Were you the one who didn't like it?" Max let out a chuckle and grinned.

Evan cast his eyes down to his knees, feeling defeated.

"No, it was me". Katelyn offered, not quite getting Max's jab at Evan.

"We came to an agreement that if he didn't put his, you know, thing, back there, then I'd spend at least 5 minutes giving him a mind-blowing blowjob whenever we have sex".

"Babe, please, stop. He doesn't need to know this." Evan pleaded.

Max chuckled again, "Well, I guess this is your lucky day, Evan. By my calculations, wait. Let's check them. Carry the seven. Yes, a 4-minute, 24-second blowjob is not at least 5 minutes. I think that means you need to reward Evan's not-so-little friend here."

Katelyn stared at Max. "Wait, what do you mean".

Evan looked at Max dumbfounded as he nodded from Katelyn to the floor.

"Katelyn, please get on the floor," Max asked firmly.

Katelyn slid off of the sofa onto her butt.

Max looked at her sternly, making eye contact so there was no mistake "On your knees, please".

Katelyn complied, pointing her head towards Max and her butt to Evan, where it would be safe.

"Now, Katelyn, be a good girl, kneel on all fours."

Katelyn again complied with Max's instructions, not quite seeing where this was going.

Evan couldn't believe his eyes; his beautiful wife was naked, on all fours, following the instructions of her co-worker, who was about to order her to fulfil one of his wildest desires, surely not.

"Now you, Evan, get behind her." Max's order snapped Evan from his trance, looking at his wife's smooth round ass, presenting to him with her on all fours.

As Evan slid off the sofa and crawled to position himself behind Katelyn, Max took a pump-action bottle of lube out of his bag and threw it to Evan.

Katelyn asked what that was for, looking back at Evan behind her over her shoulder.

"Err, Katelyn, I think he wants me to put my dick in your ass," Evan asked expectantly, looking at Max.

"Ding, ding, ding, give that man a prize", Max said as Katelyn turned herself away from Evan, trying to protect her butt.

"Position", she heard Max shout with such vehemence that her body sprang back to its previous position.

"I, please, no," Katelyn begged, looking up at Max with large dowey eyes.

Max just said, "Stay, good girl", patronising Katelyn as if she were a dog.

Katelyn felt a drip of lube fall from Evan's hand onto her round butt cheek; it slid down the back of her thigh, tickling her as it went.

"Be gentle," Katelyn said through gritted teeth to Evan.

"And, use lots of lube." She added as Evan started to stroke his lubed-up penis over her unlubed ass.

"Oh, yeah, he he, I forget," Evan chuckled, pumping a couple of squirts of lube directly onto Katelyn's asshole.

Katelyn winced as she felt the cold liquid pool in her butt crack, some escaping and dripping down her legs.

"No, no, no, no", Katelyn squealed as she felt Evan again brush her buttocks with his penis, this time she felt pressure on her asshole as Evan began pushing, slowly increasing the pressure his iron rod of a penis was exerting on Katelyn's protective asshole.

"It's like you said, Katelyn, he's in charge, I have to. And he's right, you didn't blow me for long enough, so I guess I don't really have a choice but to do as he says".

Evan heard a loud eek, scream come from Katelyn as he felt her anal sphincter give way to his probing.

"Aww, aww, aww"

"Are you going to disappoint your Master, Katelyn? Should Evan stop?" Max asked

"No, sir. Evan, just be gentle," Katelyn squeaked.

"Sounds like the lady wants more," Max said to Evan.

"Er, yes, er, sir," Evan stuttered out, leaning harder into his wife's warm behind.

"Babe, like you said, he's in charge," as Evan pushed another inch into his wife's behind.

"Owe, owe, owe", Katelyn repeated.

"Yes," Max says, capturing Katelyn's gaze, causing a pit of fear to form in her stomach.

"Katelyn, your kind and gentle master wants you to please her husband; from now on, if he asks to take you up your butt, you will let him, do you understand"?

"But it hurts so much," Katelyn cried.

Evan was only halfway into her ass and already bottomed out, stroking half his length slowly back and forth inside Katelyn; Evan had his eyes closed and loved the feeling of her tight ass opening up to receive him as he pulled back harder and harder on her hips".

"Evan seems to get this. You'll eventually get used to doing butt stuff; god knows you've got a lot of it coming in your future. Eventually, your anal canal will be stretched and moulded to fit your husband's penis like a glove."

Evan felt himself getting close to coming; his pace quickened, and his strokes became less gentle as he listened to Max describe Katelyn's future. Before he knew it, he was spurting his warm, sticky love juice into Katelyn's rectum as she moaned out in pain.

"I know it doesn't feel like it now," Max said as he held Katelyn's face up. "But one day, you'll be able to cum, just from someone fucking you in the ass, and on that day, you'll thank me".

Katelyn just lay panting on the floor, unable to hold herself up anymore as Evan slipped out of her. Katelyn could feel Evan's seed leaking out of her asshole and rolling across her butt cheek as she lay on her side, rubbing her soar asshole.

Max left the couple to recuperate for a few minutes before he approached a now furious Katelyn.

He reached into his bag and thrust something into her hands.

Katelyn looked confused but did as she was told when Max ordered her to "Put it on".

Katelyn stood, wearing her new item; never had she thought she'd be wearing something like this, but here she was.

She put a hand down to the long, thick, hard, hot pink penis that thrust itself away from her sex. Katelyn grabbed the member, swinging her hips, making it bounce around, forgetting where she was.

She turned to Evan, almost hitting him in the face with it. Katelyn looked at the expression on Evan's face; he was as pale as she had ever remembered him.

Max announced, "That's right, Evan. Turnabout is fair play; you had your fun with Katelyn; it's only fair that she has her turn fucking you. I hope you like the strap-on. I went as large as I could find. I'm sure Katelyn's going to have fun stretching you out too".

"On your knees", Max ordered Evan.

Slowly, he complied. Looking at Katelyn's evil look, he didn't think he was in for an easy ride.

"Katelyn, please don't," he tried.

"Something about doing whatever he says," Katelyn said. Don't worry; I'll be as gentle as you were."

Katelyn shoved the head of the lube bottle into Evan's ass and gave it a couple of pumps before taking some into her hand and stroking up and down the long pink shaft, loving the feeling of having something so weighty and long in her hand.

Lining herself up against Evan's asshole, she heard him whimper, "Please, love, be gentle", as she pushed the hard rubber member into his behind.

Evil Katelyn didn't care how much Evan protested, she just pushed her whole weight into Evan's behind, unable to feel his body reaching through the rod, she was sodomising her husband with.

"How does it feel, lover?" Katelyn asked as she pulled out almost completely before throwing herself back into Evan, trying to make him feel the pain she'd felt just a few minutes before".

Evan cried as Katelyn got into a rhythm of rutting in and out of his ass, he was able to take the long member impressively, but the pain was almost as bad as the cage he's just escaped from.

After a few minutes, Katelyn calmed down and just began stroking long strokes back and forth into Evan; his pained moans turned from a whimper of pain into something mixed with pleasure. With Evan broken, Katelyn looked at Max for approval before pulling out of her husband.

Max stood over the couple, both sitting on the floor now, both nursing a painful behind.

"New rule," Max announced.

"No more vaginal sex between the two of you, Evan; if you want to fuck your wife, Katelyn, if you want to be fucked by Evan, he will fuck you up the butt. And for denying him for so long, he can do this whenever he wants."

Katelyn started to protest, not wanting to give Evan that power. She knew he loved her and would try to be gentle, but she had just felt how much pain he could cause when he lost control.

Evan looked up at Max, still feeling the pain in his own ass but strangely grateful that he could now take Katelyn how he'd always wanted to, a smile creeping across his pained face.

"And Katelyn," Max continued. "Every time Evan sodomises you, you'll make sure to sodomise him in return with your new pink friend".

Evan's face dropped, and now a smirk came over Katelyn's face.

Max knew that the loving couple would both be thinking about the pain the other had inflicted on the other for some time, driving a wedge between them.

He also felt sure that Evan would find the draw of fucking Katelyn in the ass more irresistible than the concern over the consequences.

Katelyn had already let Evil Katelyn out as she took her **** on Evan's ass. Max was sure he could push the couple apart and insert himself into their relationship through manipulation.

"Now, Evan, once we're done here, I want you to go shopping and fill the house with high-quality CCTV cameras, multiple in each room, the garden, everywhere."

We're going to start some new projects; the cameras for the moment will be for Evan and Katelyn, both behind the scenes and live, as well as a vlog channel.

For the moment, we'll start building content privately for Evan and Katelyn after dark and maybe some other channels.

Katelyn, Whilst Evan is putting up cameras, you can work on registering channels and editing some of what I've just filmed.

Max put his hand out for Katelyn to take; she tried to reach for her top as she got up. One look from Max made her leave it where it was as she walked naked except for her strap-on bouncing between her legs, leading Max by the hand to the editing den while Evan was left to add cameras to the house.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)