Teddy's got questions, what else is new?

Teddy had handled the early morning rush and was idly wiping a counter as Lily came in from the back tying her apron on. He smiled broadly at her, eager for what he intuitively knew would be a motherlode of juicy stories. But in his wildest dreams he never could have prepared himself for what Lily disclosed in hushed tones. His eyes grew so wide Lily half feared they’d pop out of his head “girl, I thought the last time you came in with an undercut and eyebrow slit you’d peaked. Holy shit.” Lily shrugged “no one is more surprised than I am Teddy, but there’s actually a bit more.” Teddy looked ready to faint at the prospect but leaned in, eyes twinkling, “Oh do go on.”

Lily hadn’t yet informed him of the plan to help George and Cassie catch up on the queer fun they’d been so cruelly denied for much of their lives. “Ok so, the thing is, George and Cassie actually met at a conversion camp their shitty parent’s **** them to go to. They met and fell in love, but whatever happened at that place really fucked them both up.” Teddy’s face was a mask of rage “I FUCKING hate those bible thumping pieces of shit. Those conversion therapy shit holes are fucking concentration camps Lily. It’s fucking gross.” Lily nodded, grateful she didn’t have any first hand experience with them.

“So I was thinking Teddy… you’re someone I know and love and trust andddddd” Teddy picked up on the unsubtle hint “and you wanted to see if me or Tyler or both would help old Georgie catch up on lost time.” His face twisted in thought, weighing the idea, “first things first, let’s see a picture of the boy. Then, if it’s not an immediate no, we’ll need a dick pic, and Tyler over here to discuss.” Lily was amazed Teddy hadn’t immediately shot it down, she’d heard more than once how jealous Teddy could get when other men got involved with Tyler or his previous boyfriends.

Pulling up George’s social media handle, Cassie presented her phone to Teddy for inspection as she took a customer’s order. As she returned, Teddy nodded appreciatively “he’s certainly got that all-American football player sort of look. He’s passed the first round. Now let’s get a better idea of what he’s working with.” Lily pinged her group text with Cassie and George, amused that Cassie responded a few moments later with a shot of George’s flaccid uncut cock. About thirty seconds after that a second image came through, the now erect cock glistening from what was certainly Cassie’s spit next to a ruler showing an impressive seven and a half inches. Lily once again offered her phone to Teddy who held on to it much longer this time before pulling out his own and sending a flurry of messages.

Teddy looked Lily up and down “Test two also passed, I sent Tyler a couple of questions and he’ll be over here after work so we three can have a little tete a tete… a tete.” Lily smiled and hugged Teddy, thanking him for giving it some thought, “Hey hey now, I’m not promising anything you wild ass sloot. Agreed to talk it over that’s all.”

The rest of the shift flew by in a blur of activity, a steady pace of orders flowed in and in her downtime Lily entertained herself by texting Quinn, Cassie, and George intermittently. She backfilled Quinn on the unexpected updates to the Cassie situation, earning an immediate and enthusiastic yes to the question of if she’d like a reunion threesome with Cassie. George eagerly awaited Teddy’s decision (Lily knew Tyler would go along with whatever Teddy said, sweet, beautiful himbo that he was) but Teddy was being unusually tight lipped about his feelings. Lily promised to keep him updated but gave Teddy space to not feel pressured. She did troll through Teddy and Tyler’s socials to find example pictures for George of his potential future hookups, and in reply George sent a picture of his erect cock as approval.

Around closing time Tyler showed up, Teddy was in the back so he leaned over the counter to smile at Lily “you are trouble you know that?” Lily smiled back and batted her eyelashes innocently “Oh? Whatever do you mean Tyler?” The muscular man shrugged “oh I don’t know, despite my famously possessive boyfriend’s reputation we’ve had two threesomes in a week, and now you’re trying to add another man to the mix?” Lily shrugged “Maybe I just like having sex with wildly attractive people who happen to be my friends. Plus, the George sitch is special. Think of it more of an act of queer charity.” Before Tyler could respond Teddy appeared from the back, a serious expression on his face.

Lily and Tyler looked to the slim man and waited for him to speak. Clearing his throat and seeming uncertain Teddy spoke slowly “I haven’t told either of you this, but my parents **** me to go to a conversion shithole in my teens. It was awful, and it fucked me up pretty badly. Who knows, maybe some of my jealously and abandonment issues come from being stuck at that hell for 8 months.” Tyler immediately wrapped his lover in his arms to console him as Lily suddenly felt terrible for dredging up painful memories from her friend’s past. Teddy sniffed but composed himself “Not going to lie Lily, it’s a weird ask, but in fairness we’ve already shared Tyler twice now. I’m down if you are babe” he finished, turning to Tyler at the end.

Tyler chewed on a thought “Not for my sake Teddy Bear, but I think this could be good for you. You’re the only man for me, but this might help both you and George.” Teddy turned to Lily “I guess we’re in. But a couple thoughts- if we’re gonna do this I’d rather it not be at our apartment, and two if it starts feelings weird we’re out.” Lily nodded “Do you want me or Cassie to be there? And you guys can use my apartment if you want.” Teddy looked at Tyler who nodded “I’m good with you being there, at least we know you can suck a cock and eat ass ya sloot. And it’s about time you invited me over bitch!” Some of Teddy’s usual pep had begun returning to his voice and mannerisms, a smile plastered all over Tyler’s face. Lily grinned in return “well then boys, any plans for tonight?”