Kelly

Kelly stared at the empty space where the genie had been. "That's it? But you didn't even do anything! Nothing even changed! This is bull--" She trailed off as she noticed that Aaron wasn't listening to her. Instead, he was staring at her crotch.

She looked down to see what he was looking at, but didn't see anything out of the ordinary. There were her B-cub breasts (which Aaron always said were the perfect size), her toned stomach (which he always took time to appreciate when they had sex), her bulge--

"WHAT THE FUCK?" She nearly ripped her shorts in her haste to get them off. There, for the first time in her life, was a 6" penis. "Why do I have a dick?!"

Aaron couldn't take his eyes off his girlfriend's cock. "I... uh-- well--"

"This doesn't make any sense!" Kelly continued. "He said we wished to be together, this obviously isn't about that. Then he said I wished to be who you want me to be, and that wouldn't... NO."

Aaron's cheeks went bright red, but his gaze remained fixed on her dick.

"YOU gave me a penis? You WANTED me to have a penis?"

"It wasn't-- I didn't--" He finally snapped out of his reverie and looked Kelly in the face. "Look, I always fantasized about having a futa girlfriend."

"A what?"

"Futanari. It means you still have your vagina as well as a dick."

"What a lovely consolation."

"Hey! Stop for a minute and take stock of yourself. Did anything else change?"

That finally got Kelly to pause and listen.

Aaron continued, "Your personality is the same. Your wants and desires are the same. Your body is the same. I mean, except for... y'know."

"My dick." They both looked down at her new appendage, and Kelly realized that Aaron was right. Aaron wanted her to have a penis, so now she had a penis. So if he had wanted anything else, she would have changed accordingly. But she didn't change. He really loved her just the way she was. "That is so sweet!"

She looked back at Aaron, and finally noticed the lust in his eyes as he beheld her cock. Holy shit, this is hot, she thought.

"So this is what you wanted, huh?" Kelly stepped closer to Aaron and purred, "Why don't we take it for a spin?"