Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by Ylad Ylad

Which character would you like to follow?

Penelope - Playful Princess

This route will focus on Futa on female, some light **** but overall more romantic. Penelope has been turning away suitors for years because she has her eyes set on her childhood friend and faithful knight Kathryn, she's fed up waiting for Kathryn to come to her senses so takes matters into her own hands.


Penelope was in the Princess's tower, which she supposed was aptly named given how much time she spent there. Past Sigardian princesses had no doubt spent time here sewing or writing poetry or whatever it is that princesses were supposed to do while awaiting a husband but Penelope wasn't much concerned with keeping up appearances. She had converted the tower into an alchemy lab and was currently focused on her newest experiment, a love potion. Now what would a beautiful woman like Penelope, who had potential partners come from far and wide to woo her, have need of a love potion for? The answer was right outside the door in the form of Kathryn, Penelope's childhood friend.

Kathryn was an orphan who long ago had been caught trespassing on castle grounds, luckily she was caught by Penelope who was much too curious about this woman to let her be punished. Kathryn had all but been adopted into the royal family, though technically not in the line of royal succession, she was afforded many of the privileges they enjoyed. However Kathryn was not the type of woman to accept a gift without offering some form of repayment, after Penelope had gifted her so much Kathryn had trained to become a knight, vowing to protect Penelope to her last breath. The issue was, Penelope didn't want Kathryn as a knight, she wanted her as a partner. Growing up together Penelope had quickly grown to love her protector and eagerly awaited the day that Kathryn would return her affections. However, that day didn't seem to be coming quite quick enough, hence the love potion.

Penelope worked tirelessly measuring ingredients, reciting magical incantations, boiling and cooling various liquids, stirring and mixing and blending and whisking her concoction until it was finally ready. Today would be the day, after weeks of failure Penelope was relatively certain that she had come up with a formula that would work, well at least 90 percent certain. Now all she needed was to somehow convince Kathryn to drink the potion, she would be overcome with her love for her and she would propose and they would live happily ever after.


Kathryn was nothing if not dedicated, she had one hand on her sword and a constant ear out for potential attackers, she would never allow hard to come to her Penelope, not while she still breathed. What could possibly harm a Princess in the center of her country at the top of one of the castle's towers? Kathryn wasn't entirely sure but she knew that if trouble reared it's ugly head then she would be ready.

"Kathryn, would you mind joining me in here." Kathryn heard Penelope inquire through the door.

"At once my princess." She replied, pushing open the door and immediately assessing the room for threats. Luckily it seemed to be safe, Penelope's alchemy kit was off to one side with various flasks bubbling away but that was to be expected, at least Kathryn hoped it was to be expected, it wouldn't have been the first time that Penelope had caused an explosion with her tinkering. The only things of note in the room were a small table laid out with a tea set and of course Penelope herself.

Though Kathryn had known her for many years she couldn't help but admire the woman each time she saw her. The precocious young girl that she had known had flowered into a beautiful woman, long flowing pink hair spilled all the way down her back and though she wore a sensible outfit for her experiments it was easy to tell just how alluring she was. Penelope had an incredible bust, large perky breasts that she had no doubt inherited from her mother, that even when contained in a smock bulged in a pleasant fashion. Below she had wide child-bearing hips and an ass that was positively mouth watering. Blushing when she realized that she was staring, she chastised herself for becoming distracted, though I suppose you do need to know the person you're meant to be protecting, so maybe looking a little longer couldn't hurt.

"Kathryn, I have prepared refreshments for us. Please take a seat." Penelope said in an imperious that would broker no disagreement, gesturing at a chair across from the one she sat in.


Penelope's plan was going flawlessly, she'd finished the love potion and all she needed now was to trick Kathryn into drinking it. She knew that Kathryn would be skeptical of anything she offered her, especially given her past tendency to use the girl as a guinea pig for her alchemical concoctions so the solution was simple, she would pour the potion into the tea, Kathryn would drink it and then she would fall madly in love with her and they would live happily ever after.

"Princess, I'm afraid I can't partake in such frivolities at this time, I must focus on your protection." Kathryn says standing up straighter and refusing to make eye contact.

"Now really Kat, I've told you many times to call me Penny." She says pouting slightly, putting on her most adorable expression and staring up at Kathryn with puppy dog eyes. "Besides, you need to keep your strength up if you're supposed to protect me, what could possibly be the harm in one cup of tea?"

"My Pri-Penelope, since I have known you any time you have said 'what could possibly be the harm' has only ended with getting us in trouble."

"Please Kat, when have I ever got you in trouble?"

"To start there was the time we went to the stables and you accidentally released your mothers prize mare, all the times that you ran off into town forcing me to follow you, not to mention the time you went swimming in the moat and almost drowned."

"Please now Kat, I am a perfectly capable swimmer and would have been fine."

"If I recall correctly it ended with you yelling out for help and had me swim out to save you and then perform mouth to mouth."

A slight blush comes over Penelope's face at the memory, but she doesn't let that dissuade her.

"Now really, all of that is neither here nor there, I simply shall not take no for an answer, you will sit down and join me for tea." Penelope presses, she knew that Kat could be stubborn but she always gave into her whims in the end.

"I suppose one cup of tea couldn't hurt..." Kathryn says, sighing to herself.

Perfect, Penelope thinks to herself, now, which of the teacups did I put the potion in again?

Which of the cups did Penelope put the potion in?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)