Give her a non-committal response

For some reason, the first thing that pops up in your head is the question ‘What would Sabrina think?’ At first, you can picture Sabrina not liking it much at all. Then, as you think about it some more, maybe this could be another opportunity to mess with Emma. Of course, that wouldn’t be fair to Emma. You barely know her and you’ve been harassing her with these pranks purely because that’s what Sabrina wanted. You wonder if this is all just overblown sibling rivalry. Maybe you SHOULD spend some time with Emma and get to know her.

You are hit with doubts and benefits from both sides: Go out with Emma and piss off Sabrina, but get to know Emma. Emma is attractive and outgoing, also creative. If this were any other circumstance, you’d jump at the chance to get to know her more, but you work with Sabrina, both as interns and on her Onlyfans. Those relationships would definitely sour if you started dating her sister. Is Emma worth it?

Emma starts to notice that you’re taking way too long to answer.

“Hey, if you have a thing for my sister, I understand…” she tells you.

“Me and Sabrina? No… we, we’re purely professional. Workmates,” you say.

“You were buck naked in her apartment last weekend,” Emma replies, unconvinced.

“Well… yeah, OK, maybe more than workmates…” you begrudgingly admit. “But, we’re not a couple.”

“Yeah… I guess not. She DID take that other girl into her room, not you,” she points out. It feels like a light jab against you, but you shake it off. “So, if you’re not seeing her, and you’re not interested in her, why not go out with me?” She leans up closer and brushes your hand. “I wouldn’t let such a nice looking body go to waste…”

You squirm awkwardly in your chair at the younger woman’s forwardness. “I mean, we could hang out…” you answer. “You, me, Sabrina, this is nice, right? All three of us hanging out together?”

“It’d be even nicer if it’s just the two of us…” she promises. Her fingers wrap around your thumb and they start to stroke it subliminally. She eyes you with sexual desire. You tug at your collar.

“Well, based on what you’ve told me about your weekends, you two could be a lot of fun together as well…” you point out.

Emma blushes as she goes deep into thought. It takes a moment for Emma to fully wrap her head around the idea of a threesome with her sister. She makes a lewd face as the thought crosses her mind, then quickly buries it and makes a thin lipped smile. “You’re a dirty thinker…” she teases.

Your phone buzzes, indicating you have a message. You thank your lucky stars for the reprieve and pick it up. It’s from Sabrina.

Sabrina: Look what you made me do…

There is an attached image of a pair of panties being held up in front of a sink. It is wet and creamy. Emma looks at you, expecting you to explain what the message is.