Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Insighn122 Insighn122

What's next?

Bump in the night

I'm not sure what woke me up. I rolled over and Lily was lying next to me, snoring quietly with her mouth open. Even like that she looked stunning, I thought. I'd drank a lot last night so I got up and walked to the bathroom. Trying to be as quiet as possible.

The house was quiet and dark, it must have been around 4am, but I hadn't grabbed my phone so that's a guess. I had a pee then washed my hands. I took a few moments to look at myself in the mirror. "Last night got crazy really fast" I said to myself, quietly.

I opened the bathroom door and jumped when I saw Abby standing on the other side.

"Shit, you scared the life out of me."

I whispered, trying to regain my composure.

"Sorry," she giggled quietly.

She was standing in one of my T shirts, Lily must have loaned her it to sleep in. Her legs were bare and my mind wondered about what was hiding under the oversized T. She looked so sweet and innocent. The image of her taking Jake's huge cock in her mouth made me so angry. "How are you feeling?" I asked her. My concern was evident.

"I'm okay" she replied, her voice barely above a whisper. "Do you have anything to drink?"

I turned around and gestured for her to follow me downstairs to the kitchen. Once we were there, I grabbed a glass from the cupboard and filled it with water from the fridge.

As I handed her the glass, she looked up at me with those big, trusting eyes of hers. There was something **** about her, which only intensified her appeal. I found myself drawn to her, wanting to protect her yet also consumed by lust.

In the dim light cast by the hallway, I could see her face more clearly. The soft moonlight highlighted her features, casting a gentle glow across her cheekbones. Her lips parted slightly as she sipped the water, and I couldn't help but notice how full they looked, begging to be kissed.

We stood there in silence for a moment, sharing the comfortable calm of the early morning hours. Abby finished her water and placed the glass back on the counter. Turning to face me, she ran her fingers through her hair, pushing it back from her face.

"Thanks," she said softly, indicating the glass of water. "That helped."

I nodded, studying her carefully. "You look good in that." I commented, motioning towards her shirt.

"Thank you," she blushed slightly, seemingly embarrassed by the compliment.

"But I'd bet you look good in anything" I stumbled with the compliment, feeling my cheeks heat up.

"Really?" she asked, tilting her head to the side and giving me a curious look.

I nodded, smiling softly. "Yes, really."

We stood there for a few moments in silence. Finally, I spoke up. "Do you want to go back to your room?"

Abby hesitated for a moment, then shook her head. "No, it's fine here."

Without thinking, emboldened by the ****, I moved towards her and kissed her passionately. She responded immediately, wrapping her arms around my neck, pulling me closer.

Our tongues danced playfully, teasing and testing each other's boundaries. As our lips intertwined, our hands roamed restlessly over each other's bodies, searching for new erogenous zones to explore. I ran my hands over her curves, memorizing the contours of her body, revelling in the feel of her skin beneath my fingertips.

She moaned softly, her hands trailing down my chest, lingering on my stomach before reaching lower. My cock throbbed with anticipation, straining against my briefs. I knew I couldn't wait any longer, and without breaking the kiss, I lifted her onto the counter.

Her legs wrapped around my waist instinctively, allowing me to position myself between them. Our lips never broke contact, and our hands continued exploring each other's bodies. Abby's breasts were firm and full, perfectly complementing her soft curves.

My hands found their way to the hem of her T-shirt lifting it enough to see her little white lace panties. The sight sent a surge of desire coursing through my veins. Unable to resist any longer, I slid my hands underneath her shirt, cupping her breasts tenderly. She gasped, arching her back, pressing herself further into my touch.

Her nipples hardened under my caress, and I felt a sharp stab of desire in my groin. I wanted nothing more than to taste her. I dropped to my knees, pulling her panties to the side I gently kissed her inner thigh, moving higher slowly. Her breath caught in her throat, her hands clutching at my head, urging me on. Finally, I reached her entrance, and I paused, savouring the moment.

With one, long, teasing motion, I licked the soft flesh at the edge of her pussy. Her reaction was instantaneous - a gasp followed by a whimper as she pushed herself further into my face.

She moaned softly, her hips writhing with pleasure as she tried to maintain her balance on the counter. Her musky scent mixed with the faint smell of her perfume intoxicated me even more.

I gently licked her, swirling my tongue around her clitoris, teasing her, building her arousal. Her body began to shudder, and she moaned again, pushing herself deeper into my mouth.

Her hands tightened in my hair, her nails digging gently into my scalp. I Reached down, freeing my cock, stroking it to hardness as I pushed my tongue into her wetness. I could feel her muscles quiver beneath my touch. Her moans turned into gasps, and she gripped the edge of the counter, holding on for dear life. I sucked harder, drawing her orgasm nearer.

Her cries of pleasure filled the room, I was worried someone might hear, but I was way too into it to stop.

My name escaped her lips in a **** plea. "Oh Alex, I'm going to cum" she moaned, her hips bucking violently as she did. Her body convulsed with pleasure, waves of ecstasy coursing through her as she climaxed.

I stood up and pulled her panties off while she was still riding the wave of pleasure. My cock was just centimetres away from her soaking wet pussy. She looked at me with those big, trusting eyes of hers, an unspoken question filling them.

Without waiting for permission, I pushed into her, causing her to gasp as our bodies met. Her tightness engulfed me, sending waves of pleasure coursing through my body.

She held onto me, her hands clenching my shoulders as we began to move together in rhythm. "Oh, Alex," she whispered, arching her back. "That feels so good."

I watched her face intently, witnessing the expression of pure ecstasy on her features. It drove me wild with desire, my own need growing stronger by the second.

Abby threw her head back, her hair falling over her shoulders. Her eyes were closed, and her lips parted slightly.

I took that as my cue, thrusting into her forcefully, wanting to make her feel every inch of me. Her walls squeezed me tightly, her gasps turning into moans as she adjusted to my size.

My pace grew faster, pushing her limits. I covered her mouth as she lost her inhibitions and started moaning loudly.

I didn't want anyone to wake up and catch us. Her muffled screams turned into whimpers, and I knew she was close to another orgasm. Her body trembled beneath me, and I increased the pace, knowing it would push her over the edge. With a sudden cry, she came again, her body pulsing around me.

"Alex," she gasped, looking up at me with wide eyes. "I need you to pull out when you cum, okay?" she requested, her breath still ragged from her climax. I nodded, noticing the intensity in her eyes.

She wrapped her legs tighter around my waist, pulling me deeper into her. I started fucking her more aggressively, matching her enthusiasm.

Her eyes were glazed over with desire, her breath coming in quick bursts. She bit her lip, her fingers digging into my shoulder as her moans became louder. The intensity of our lovemaking was driving us both towards the edge.

Without warning, Abby suddenly gripped my shoulders tightly, her entire body tensing up. I could sense her orgasm approaching, and my own need escalating. I continued thrusting into her, my own release imminent. Her grip on my shoulders grew tighter, her nails digging into my skin. The intensity of her hold mirrored the ferocity of our connection.

Her body trembled beneath me, and her breathing quickened, echoing the thunderous beat of my heart. With a sharp cry, she succumbed to her orgasm, her body convulsing with the **** of it.

I felt my own release approaching, her body squeezing me tightly as my cock throbbed inside her. I pulled out just a moment too late, the first rope of cum shooting inside of her. I clumsily pulled out, shooting rope after rope of cum up her T-shirt and onto her soft thighs.

Her eyes searched mine, uncertainty filling them. "Sorry about that," I muttered, unable to meet her gaze.

She smiled nervously, running her fingers through my hair. "It's okay," she whispered, kissing me gently. "It happens."

Embarrassment crept up my spine, making me wish I could disappear. But instead, I leaned down and gently pressed my lips to hers, feeling the warmth of her embrace.

We separated and Abby went to get cleaned up. I headed back up to Lily and climbed back into bed. She stirred in her sleep, sensing my presence beside her. I fell asleep with a big smile on my face.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)