Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Insighn122 Insighn122

What's next?

Bump in the night

I cleaned up and headed to our bedroom. A few minutes later Lily entered, still in her silver dress. She jumped on the bed, "Well, that was exciting" she said playfully, giggling. She leaned back on the pillows, her long legs crossed underneath her. She motioned towards me to come closer.

"I got them set up in the spare room" she said with a cheeky smile. "I told them to try to be quiet" she giggled.

"Do you think they will?" I asked, a sceptical expression crossing my face.

Lily rolled her eyes, "she's had a taste now" she said with a smirk. I lay beside her, our fingers intertwined. We were silent for a moment.

Then it started. The guest room headboard banging on the wall. I closed my eyes, listening to the sounds coming from the spare room. Abby's moans accompanied the hammering, gradually getting louder. "Fuck me Jake!" Abby screamed, her voice echoing throughout the room. Lily and I exchanged a glance. It sounded like things were getting pretty intense in there.

I imagined Jake's cock plunging in and out of Abby's tight little pussy, her legs wrapped around him as she begged for more. My own cock stirred in response, throbbing as my imagination ran wild. I glanced over at Lily, "sounds like they're having fun," she murmured, her voice tinged with a note of envy.

I started to drift off, the banging on the wall was almost soothing. I listened to the faint sounds of moaning, mixed with the creaking of the bed. Lily shifted in her sleep, pressing close to me. I fought the urge to grab hold of her, afraid of waking her.

I closed my eyes, letting my mind wander. The events of the past hour replayed themselves in my mind. I thought about Lily and Jake, the way she had been with him earlier.

I awoke a few hours later, it was dark and quiet. I got up to go to the toilet. moving quietly so I didn't wake Lily.

I passed by the guest room on my way to the bathroom. the door was slightly ajar, I peered inside. Abby was sprawled out on the bed, alone, fast asleep. the sheets tangled around her legs, the only thing covering her naked form. I wished that she'd move a little, to let me catch a glimpse of her body.

I couldn't help but notice the slight sheen of sweat on her, evidence of the passionate encounter she'd had last night, and this morning.

I reluctantly pulled myself away. I didn't want to get caught watching her. I'm not a pervert, I thought to myself.

I started walking to the bathroom again, a thought popped into my head, where was Jake?

The bathroom light was on. The door was open. I crept up, trying not to make any noise. I peered in, I could see Jake stood in front of the toilet, his back to me.

Then I saw her. Lily was sat on the toilet. Jake stood in front of her. I couldn't see what she was doing, but it was pretty obvious. I stood there, frozen in shock.

"How does she taste" Jake said to her as she bobbed her head up and down on his cock. Lily bobbed her head faster, I could hear the slurping as she took his length down her throat.

Jake must have been enjoying himself. He placed his hands on her head, holding her in place.

I couldn't believe what I was seeing. It seemed so surreal, the sight of my girlfriend going down on another guy. I hated seeing her pleasure another man, it made me sick. But at the same time, I couldn't deny how hot it was.

Watching Lily deepthroating Jake right in front of me was turning me on more than I cared to admit. Her hands gripped his thighs tightly, her lips taking his length. I felt a twinge of jealousy, followed immediately by arousal.

"Take that big cock," he growled, pumping his cock into her mouth. I could hear **** sounds and through his legs I could see she was rubbing her pussy as he fucked her mouth.

Suddenly Lily broke free from his grasp, standing up. She turned around and lent over the toilet. She was wearing one of my t-shirts and she lifted it up at the back to expose her cute, naked ass.

Jake positioned himself behind her. He put his arms around her waist, pulling her close to him. His hands roamed up and down her sides, tracing her curves. I could feel my heart racing, watching them.

I pulled out my cock and began jerking as Jake pushed his way inside of her. I could only see his back but it the stimulation it was giving me was unbelievable.

My hand moved swiftly up and down my shaft, my breath quickening as I watched Jake pound her from behind. I heard her moans growing louder, her body shivering with pleasure as he drove into her. She had her head thrown back, her long hair cascading down her shoulders. She looked so fucking beautiful, lost in the moment with this other guy.

Watching her like this was driving me crazy. My hand moved faster on my cock, my need to cum intensifying with every passing second.

But as much as I wanted to watch them, part of me wished I wasn't here. Seeing her like this hurt me deeply. Even though I knew it was wrong, I couldn't help but wonder if she would ever feel the same way about me.

I glanced down at my erection, already leaking pre-cum onto my palm.

I couldn't believe how turned on I was, watching her like this. Despite the pain it caused me, the thought of her being taken by someone else was incredibly arousing.

As I watched from the shadows, Jake slowly increased his pace, thrusting deeper into her with each stroke. Her breath came in short gasps, her body arching backwards as he pounded into her. I could see the muscles in his back ripple with each powerful thrust, the veins standing out prominently against his skin.

He held onto her hips tightly, his movements forceful and unrelenting. I watched in awe as he took control of the situation, claiming possession of my girlfriend's body.

As I continued to watch, Lily's breath grew ragged, her moans becoming more insistent. She arched her back, meeting each of Jake's thrusts with equal fervour.

I came so hard I had to use every ounce of strength not to moan out loud.

I looked down, my cock spewing thick, white cum all over the floor. It was the most intense orgasm I had ever experienced. I tried to calm my breathing, but my heart was still racing.

Lily and Jake kept fucking, oblivious to my presence.

Eventually, they finished, Jake pulling out of her and shooting his load onto her back.

Lily groaned as his warm seed dripped down her skin, leaving a trail of stickiness behind. She turned around, facing him. Their faces were close together, their breaths mingling in the air between them. "I can't believe how good you feel," she whispered, her voice hoarse from excitement.

Jake smiled, running his fingers through his hair. "You better get back to Alex," he replied, his eyes fixed on hers. Lily nodded, **** to leave his side.

I took that as my cue to head back to the bedroom. I climbed under the sheets and pretended to be asleep. A few minutes later I heard Lily sneak in behind me.

She crawled into bed, nestling up against me. Her skin was still warm from her encounter with Jake. I resisted the urge to turn and look at her.

I lay awake for a while, trying to clear my mind. I couldn't stop thinking about what I had just seen.

Then, more banging from the guest room. More moaning from Abby, how is he already going again? I thought, rolling my eyes.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)